Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Why DEI is more important during economic downturns

Despite ample statistics pointing to DEI’s profitability, economic downturns significantly impact women and historically underrepresented groups.

[Seventyfour/Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Ebbie Parsons

As many are increasingly aware, 2023 brings predictions of an economic downturn. Fannie Mae economists cited U.S. economy recession and shrinkage, targeting businesses with high inflation. Oxford Economics forecasted growth to be the lowest since 2008.

Many companies have started preparations for this projection. Google announced its hiring pause on July 20, and other tech companies followed suit by laying off hundreds of employees. These indicators sent a shock wave of alarm in industries outside of tech, as the actions of tech companies are often indicators of upcoming economic trends.

Despite ample statistics pointing to Diversity, Equity & Inclusion’s profitability, economic downturns significantly impact women and historically underrepresented groups: Black and brown people, LGBTQ+ people, and disabled people. Organizations in the upper quartile for gender diversity are 21% more likely to outperform their peers. Companies top-ranked for ethnic and racial diversity on executive teams are 33% more likely to outperform other industry leaders. On average, companies that practice gender diversity in executive teams outperform peers by over 20%. Employee pre-tax earnings rise 0.8% for every 10% diversity increase on the senior executive team. These wins are critical during predicted economic growth stagnation.

Unfortunately, if left unchecked, historically underrepresented groups are often positioned at the bottom of a company’s hierarchy and are the first to be laid off. Historically, women don’t get hired as much as men into highly technical, well-compensated positions and are often placed in non-technical roles. In a recent Wired article, Code 2040 CEO Mimi Fox Melton says non-technical employees are “more likely to face layoffs because they are seen as less essential to the business than those who develop or maintain the product.”

On top of that, elimination processes can be biased against underrepresented groups. Systems designed to be fair and intermediary end up disadvantaging the people they are designed to protect. People of color are rated lower in performance reviews for the same or better performance than their colleagues, causing them to appear to contribute less than they do.

What do we do about this? First, companies with highly inclusive workplaces gained a 4x larger stock return than the S&P 500 and thrived throughout the Great Recession. A more robust preparation process (greater workplace health, ideas, innovation) is best for a company to keep up to survive during a recession. Preparation creates stability and prevents a revolving door of talent down the line.

In order to have an inclusive and robust preparation process, it’s important to backtrack and make sure representation exists across all departments and levels, including the executive team. That means there is diverse leadership, diversity in critical functions of the organization, fair compensation across genders, and embedded DEI in all stages of the employee lifecycle.

How should you refocus if you’re not in a position to be proactive with the above recommendations?

You’re likely to impact women and people of color if you’ve recently hired diverse talent to increase your pipeline and then default on a “last hired/first fired” policy for severance planning. Black employees in particular have historically been affected by this type of policy. Be wary of when you hired underrepresented talent and if their hiring timeline skews toward the last fiscal years. It’s essential to change your strategy if this is the case.

Additionally, consider another path than reducing contractors versus employees hired full-time. Underrepresented groups are more likely to participate in the gig economy and are directly impacted when contractor pool cuts are made. Lastly, don’t decentralize decisions to managers. It’s important to be strategic from the top. Breaking down decisions opens the door significantly to duplicate biases against underrepresented groups.

Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Strategist Lily Zheng tells employers who care “about DEI and are considering layoffs… [to] do everything in their power to choose another option first.”

Some suggestions from Zheng include: “Have your senior leaders take a pay cut or forgo bonuses; Offer voluntary furloughs, or opportunities for time off without pay; Choose not to renew the least-utilized / least-beneficial vendor services; Reduce hours for non-mission critical employees; Reskill or upskill your current employees to take on more essential or critical roles; Strengthen the relational aspects of your culture while cutting the material perks (‘swag’).”

Letting go of people is difficult and stressful. It’s imperative in this process to have diverse buy-in from leadership, consistently implement strategically, and learn from past economic downturns by focusing on the value DEI can add during the anticipated hardships ahead.


Dr. Ebbie Parsons, III is the Managing Partner of Yardstick Management, America’s leading Black-owned Management Consulting firm.