The Carbon Bankroll report turned heads earlier this year in finding that the No. 1 largest carbon footprint contributor for several tech companies is their investments and cash holdings. For Alphabet (Google parent), Meta, and Paypal, the cash and investment footprint is larger than all other portions of the footprint combined! The report was issued by the Climate Safe Lending Network, a coalition of financial institutions, nonprofits, and think tanks that seeks to align lending policies and practices of North American and European banks with a well-below 1.5-degree rise in global temperature by 2025.
What’s striking about the finding is that cash and investment footprint is generally neither measured nor reported. But is the claim true? And if it is true, why has cash and investment accounting not been common practice?
To start, let’s step back to the GHG Protocol, the international standard that governs how corporate greenhouse gas (GHG) accounting (i.e., carbon footprinting) is done. GHG accounting fans know that emissions are typically categorized as scope 1 (direct operations footprint), scope 2 (indirect operations footprint), and scope 3 (value chain emissions outside of your operations). The inherent complexity of Scope 3 has been broken down into 15 categories, the last of which is investments, so the structure for accounting for investments (including equity, debt, and project finance) is indeed already in the GHG Protocol.
The introduction of that category states, “This category is applicable to investors (i.e., companies that make an investment with the objective of making a profit) and companies that provide financial services.”
By common interpretation, if you’re not strictly an investor as your core business or a financial services company, the category does not apply. However, the first clause in the sentence invites greater scrutiny. If your company engages in investments with your cash holdings to make a profit, are you not still an investor? Whether or not you view your company as an investor, it is reasonable to expect your investments have a carbon footprint like similar investments made by those who are formal investors.
Later in the protocol, the guidance for companies that have investments but “neither financial control nor significant influence over the emitting entity” is”Account for proportional scope 1 and scope 2 emissions of equity investments that occur in the reporting year in scope 3, category 15 (Investments). Companies may establish a threshold (e.g., equity share of 1 percent) below which the company excludes equity investments from the inventory, if disclosed and justified.”
Let’s also assess materiality. How prominent do we expect investments to be, compared to other aspects of scope 3? The more cash and investments your company has on hand, the more prominent they become. Tech companies, particularly cloud software companies, are an easy target for the Climate Safe Lending Network, as they are exceptionally profitable, less resource-intensive than many other industries in primarily dealing in electrons, and relatively responsible for reducing emissions from their supply chain. Where Meta, Google, and others have made strides in sourcing renewable energy for their data centers, other portions of their value chain become more significant. (In general, when we solve our No. 1 problem, the second becomes No. 1. That doesn’t mean the second became worse, just more prominent.)
In terms of measurement, if you know what companies your investments are in, your percent ownership of those companies, as well as their reported emissions, you can calculate your share of those emissions and, hence, your investment footprint. Carbon Bankroll did not have that level of detail and instead calculated investment emissions by converting dollars in a general asset class (rather than specific companies) to GHG emissions. Tech companies that have more information on their specific investments can expand on their approach.
If you are not in a high-flying tech company but instead in a high-volume, low-margin business, investments are less likely to be material. One quick way to gauge materiality is to compare the magnitude of your annual purchasing with your cash and investments. In contrast with investments, purchased goods and services are typically reported in GHG accounting, as category 1 of scope 3, and are commonly a large portion of emissions for any product company.
There are also spend-based approaches to convert purchasing dollars or other currencies into equivalent GHG emissions. After working through a spend-based approach, compare the spend-based purchasing footprint with your investment footprint—you could use best-case and worst-case GHG/$ metrics from the Carbon Bankroll report to start to help you assess whether investments should be incorporated into reporting.
Note that calculating a GHG emissions flow from a cash flow (purchasing expense) in general is qualitatively different than calculating GHG emissions from an asset (investment). However, the Carbon Bankroll approach effectively converts the asset into flows using corporate reporting. For investments other than holding equity in GHG reporting companies you may have to use different approaches, like amortizing asset emissions over the lifetime of the investment.
Should you report your investment GHG emissions? If you’re a financial institution, you should already be doing so. If you’re a cloud-based software company, you should certainly consider it if you have significant investments and have reduced emissions in the value chain. If you’re a consumer products company—be it food processing, apparel, or other consumer goods—work through the purchasing versus investment evaluation above to gauge whether investments appear significant. For all companies, focus on what’s significant and decarbonize, whether purchasing, investments, or other aspects of your value chain.
Founder of Climate Positive Consulting, leading the firm’s carbon footprint reduction strategy practice; Author at Routledge.