One of the primary responsibilities of a great manager is to help their employees set goals. This is an essential task for successful teams, but it’s really only half the job. The other half is taking the time to reflect and review the progress made toward those goals. In most businesses, this reflection manifests in the form of mid-year and end-of-year reviews—each of which covers different content and has a distinct approach to execution. To ensure you’re well-prepared for both forms of review, let’s take a look at what each looks like and how they can complement each other.
RELAXED HALFWAY THROUGH
Like end-of-year reviews, mid-year reviews are formal evaluations. However, they tend to be much more relaxed than their counterparts. The focus of mid-year reviews should be on communication and further strengthening the relationship you have with your employee.
So how exactlydo you do this? It starts with gathering data and getting a sense of how the employee performs. In my business, I achieve this through regular accomplishment reviews. These are one-on-one meetings I have on a monthly basis with each team member. My main purpose at every monthly meeting is to celebrate what the employee has accomplished. We talk about their favorite project and what project was the most challenging. It’s a chance to acknowledge progress and let them know I’m on their side. Taking the time to do this helps the employee feel like I see their effort and have their back, which is essential to building trust.
Once you’ve reached the year’s mid-point, compile all of the employee’s accomplishments that you have identified in the monthly meetings into a single list. It’s powerful for the employee to see all of these achievements together, especially if you’re dealing with a high performer who wants to make their mark and be known for what they’re doing. If there’s not a ton on this master list, that’s not necessarily bad. It could be that the employee is working incredibly hard on some bigger projects.
The main goal during the mid-year review is to put the accomplishments in the context of the employee’s larger journey. Figure out how they’re feeling, what they think they need, what they’d like to learn and where they’d ultimately like to go. I recently did this with an employee who had been working on a website redesign project. We had the opportunity to talk about the areas where some additional education might be helpful and the classes she might attempt to take. The conversation gave us a chance to get on the same page and start thinking together about their future.
GETTING MORE SERIOUS TO WRAP THINGS UP
If you think of the mid-year review as the employee’s chance to be heard, the end-of-year review is the manager’s turn. You still want a relaxed, positive atmosphere where you and the employee can connect and be open with each other, but the focus is more on the metrics and figuring out where the employee can improve. Just from this standpoint, it will likely feel far more formal and strategy-driven, so it is especially important to help the employee see how they can achieve the changes you propose.
What’s nice about the end-of-year review is that the systems in most companies are built with the above goals in mind. They’re continuously tapping AI-based computer programs or databases that can easily gather, analyze, and present information in a way everyone can understand. Subsequently, you probably won’t have any difficulty getting the data necessary to put together your agenda. But this is part of the reason the mid-year reviews are necessary: Your tools and infrastructure really aren’t built to connect, encourage, and learn about each other, so you have to have a separate time of the year to prioritize that work.
As you do your year-end review with your employee, remember that when you talk about where the employee can improve, you must connect those points to the larger goals and direction of the business. Particularly if your business has had some big shifts, the end-of-year review is your opportunity to clarify the company’s big picture. This will help the employee understand why your specific metrics matter and what you’re considering when you look at the worker’s performance.
WITH CLARITY OF EXPECTATION COMES SUCCESS
Any good employer-employee relationship is reciprocal. At the same time, work is as much about the human element as it is tasks or profits. Using both a mid-year and end-of-year review ensures that your reflection and goal setting is both collaborative and balanced. For the best results, always let your employee know what your expectations are for each meeting. You’ll both end up better prepared and more effective when there are no surprises on either side.
David Partain is SVP of Northern Trust and CMO of their subsidiary, FlexShares Exchange Traded Funds.