Blame the impotent roosters. When the wholesale price of a pound of chicken wings blew out to $3.22 last year, the chicken-wing franchise Wingstop was in trouble. The combination of soaring demand, a labor shortage, and lackluster roosters conspired to create a shortage of the company’s core product. In an era of great change, there has never been a greater need for innovation and creativity. Wingstop considered canceling advertising, but what they needed was a left-field solution—and the guts to implement it.
The thing about left-field solutions is that they emerge from a blind spot in the company’s conventional approach. By definition, breakthrough innovative thinking involves a creative leap of faith. Clients who first want to see evidence that a new approach will work before investing in innovation miss the point. If case studies have already been accumulated, then it isn’t new.
The answer, in this case, was to be found in another part of the bird’s anatomy. With wholesale chicken thighs still about half the price of wings, the fast-food chain rebranded its product “Thighstop” for a month. The servings of thighs were available only online or through DoorDash, but sales surged, and the company captured the nation’s cultural imagination. It took vision and courage to depart from the crux of their brand, but the corresponding surge in sales demonstrates the prospective impact of this attitude.
Doing nothing was an option, but can be the worst decision of all, robbing a business of the chance to use disruption as a catalyst to drive greater sales. Wingstop pivoting their product line hadn’t been tested in the market, but it was an outrageous success. If you look at the world right now, which brand is having the same year they had last year? With supply-chain issues, inflation, and economic uncertainty, no brand has emerged unscathed. You cannot afford to run last year’s playbook in today’s environment. Clients who do, get the advertising they deserve.
DON’T BE A MONDAY-MORNING QUARTERBACK
Change is messy and nobody is immune. Amazon is having mass layoffs, Microsoft and Alphabet (Google) just missed their earnings, and Meta (Facebook) posted the first negative earnings since their foundation. Everybody needs creative innovation.
The challenges of changing demographics, shifting work patterns, and social responsibility require new ways of working, and that is only possible through creativity and innovation. To rework a trope: doing business as usual while expecting a different result is the definition of insanity.
Businesses that pivoted during the pandemic—such as liquor distillers turning into hand-sanitizer factories, Zoom offering a lower barrier to entry, and takeout-delivery platforms such as Uber Eats and DoorDash expanding into groceries—saw their profits boom.
Leaders who resist change miss a huge opportunity to pivot their business and drive growth in a rapidly evolving marketplace. Change is inevitable and continuing with the tried and true contains its own risk: you can never win if you are not on the field of play.
It is a lot easier to be on the sidelines watching others daring to be different than getting dirty in the arena. As a client, if you believe in yourself and your business, you would want to be out there contributing to team success. New ways of working don’t shy away from risk, but embrace it for competitive advantage. Otherwise, you are dissecting the game from a safe distance on Monday morning.
THE MONKEY TRAP OF BRAND RECOGNITION
It’s an adaptable analogy, with origins in south India and Thailand, but the story of the gormless monkey is the same. Trappers place a piece of fruit in a hollowed-out coconut, and the monkey reaches inside but gets its hand stuck because it is holding fast to its prize. With a choice between freedom and releasing the fruit, the monkey chooses to hold what it has and is easily caught.
For businesses, the fruit is doing more of the same, and these businesses are sitting prey for competitors when change threatens to make their strategy obsolete.
Remember Nokia? Once the largest maker of cell phones, Nokia had been a model of innovation after starting out as a paper mill around 1865 in Finland, then diversifying into rubber, electronics, and cable, before focusing on the telecommunications sector. But Nokia became too big and unwieldy to adapt to sudden change when Apple launched its first smartphone and Google developed Android.
It stuck with its Symbian operating system and ended up being sold to Microsoft at a fraction of its value at the company’s peak. Blackberry suffered a similar fate when it stubbornly refused to adapt to touchscreen technology, and Kodak was far too slow to go digital.
Once companies become big and profitable, they try to protect their market share rather than embrace innovation in the face of disruptive trends such as Kindle’s challenge to the print-book market and Netflix helping nudge Blockbuster out of business. Big organizations refuse to let go of the proverbial fruit.
BATTER UP! TAKE YOUR BEST SWING
In a period of great change, creativity can be a force multiplier that gives you a competitive advantage. But if you are not willing to allow space for divergent thinkers, embrace risk, and do something truly innovative, you are under-leveraging your creative resource.
Advertising agencies can see your business through a different lens to help drive innovation through creative bravery. They can put you back in the batter’s box. The decision-makers at Wingstop could have canceled advertising and thrown up their hands. Instead, the temporary switch to “Thighstop” enhanced the brand. The beauty of being in the batter’s box is you actually have a chance to hit a home run. Creative bravery is taking that opportunity to swing for the fences.
Andrew Swinand is the CEO of the Creative Group across all Publicis agencies, as well as the CEO of Leo Burnett.