Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Make your survey matter: How to actually increase employee engagement

How do we reimagine the employee engagement survey so that it helps create meaningful and lasting change?

[Images: Adobe Stock / fizkes]

Profile photo of Shani Harmon

Co-Founder, Chief Executive Officer · Stop Meeting Like This

Why do we even bother measuring employee engagement? We already know it’s not a pretty picture. According to the latest Gallup State of the Global Workplace Report, only 21 percent of employees are engaged at work. That means that 79 percent are not. Abysmal. And not surprising.

The intention for measuring employee engagement is so that leaders can demonstrate they care about employee well-being. Countless hours and dollars are invested annually in measuring the current state, dicing the organization up into micro-units for comparison, and then executing lengthy communication cascades and action-planning processes. Too bad the most common outcome, in my experience, is cynicism. These efforts tend to be seen as somewhere between useless and downright deceptive, with leaders making the right motions but nothing really changing.

So how do we reimagine the employee engagement survey so that it helps create meaningful and lasting change?

The survey itself is not the challenge. While it can often be onerous, the questions are typically both thoughtful and useful. It’s everything that happens after the survey that undermines the intent. Here’s a more fruitful approach.

MAKE MEANING OF THE RESULTS TOGETHER WITH EMPLOYEES

Rather than benchmarking your organization against other similar companies, supplement your understanding of the data through the eyes of the team. Who cares whether you score three percentage points above your competition if your employees feel too psychologically unsafe to share their true opinions? Use an outside facilitator to host a series of optional focus groups to get underneath the data and add the flesh-and-bone experience of the team.

USE EXPERTS TO DESIGN THE SUBSEQUENT INTERVENTIONS

Once you have a robust picture of the current employee experience and how it varies from unit to unit, you’re ready to build an action plan. But first, call in the experts.

Engaging the team in identifying solutions is valuable, but relying on them to design and execute culture-building initiatives is a little like asking a car salesman to change your oil. Specialized expertise is required to do that job well, and the same is true for employee engagement initiatives.

Centralized experts—either the HR team or outside resources—can identify common needs and determine the most widely useful interventions. While it’s true that an employee’s experience of an organization’s culture is defined at the team level, action-planning at that level often results in well-intentioned initiatives that typically lose steam and/or fail to deliver the desired result. Too often we see a proliferation of culture and communication committees trying to tackle the same problem with varying degrees of success. A central resource can create a playbook and resources that each team can then customize and adopt.

MEASURE THE COST OF EMPLOYEE ENGAGEMENT PROCESSES IN TIME AS WELL AS DOLLARS

Many companies have a strong bias against using external experts to support subsequent initiatives because it’s “expensive.” If the true cost of the employee engagement process was known, however, the consulting fees would pale in comparison. Just consider the number of meetings that the top three levels of leadership attend to process the survey data, communicate it to the teams, and then follow up on action plans. The time cost is extraordinary.

One place investment can make a big difference is in communication training for top leadership. A critical success factor for employee engagement is how leaders connect with the members of the team. Many leaders struggle with finding a good balance between being professional and leaderlike with being authentic and approachable. Supporting their development to communicate in a way that signals respect and appreciation for the team is money far better spent when it comes to improving overall engagement.

The worst way to invest your dollars is to spend time and money on collecting feedback from your employees, analyzing the results, and then doing nothing to create meaningful change. Cultivating a healthy organizational culture in which your team feels safe, engaged, and heard will return your investment exponentially in terms of retention and productivity. That’s the data to really celebrate.


Shani Harmon is the co-founder of Stop Meeting Like This, which partners with forward-looking companies to transform how work gets done.