Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Who owns the metaverse?

This new supply chain is unlike anything we’ve seen before, not only because of the ambiguous boundary between the physical and virtual worlds, but also because of the questions of ownership and governance. 

Women with virtual reality headset

[Images: dobe Stock / _KUBE_]

Profile photo of Jason Cottrell

When it comes to the metaverse, it’s hard not to be struck with deja vu. There was a time when people spoke in a similar way about the internet. The fact that no one could predict its applications lent a certain air of mystery. And as we now straddle the edge of Web 3.0, many of us find ourselves struck by the same sense of wonder and curiosity. 

In the wake of the initial metaverse hype, countless companies from fashion brands to blockchain tech giants have claimed a stake, revealing an incredibly diverse network of vendors, suppliers, digital manufacturers, systems engineers, retailers, and more. In other words: a supply chain.

This new supply chain is unlike anything we’ve seen before, not only because of the ambiguous boundary between the physical and virtual worlds, but also because of the questions of ownership and governance. 

IS THE METAVERSE TRULY DECENTRALIZED?

In the case of Web 1.0, for example, users were primarily consumers of content, engaging on open networks to access information. With the emergence of Web 2.0, users could become content creators, as well, but much of the information was closed off from the greater public behind social media platforms and other centralized apps, such as Google and Amazon. Whereas information characterized Web 1.0, user data and advertising were the hallmarks of Web 2.0.

While some describe the metaverse as “decentralized,” this might actually be a misnomer—at least for the time being. The individual components that make up the metaverse are largely decentralized: blockchain, cryptocurrency, non-fungible tokens, and the smart contracts that determine ownership of individual assets. As it stands now, however, the metaverse is a series of fragmented platforms, ranging from social platforms such as Decentraland and Sandbox to gaming platforms such as Roblox and Fortnite. Very little interoperability exists between these platforms:

• Users create separate profiles and avatars for each platform.

• Users can’t import digital assets (e.g., costumes and skins) from one platform to another.

• Users can’t exchange currency from one platform to another.

METAVERSE GOVERNANCE ON A SPECTRUM

Despite these current limitations, there seem to be three possible ways the governance system of the metaverse might unfold. The first, like Web 2.0, is characterized by a few gatekeepers that restrict access to users of their metaverse, with little to no integration with other metaverses. Meta (formerly Facebook), for example, is investing heavily in building a metaverse hegemony “in which all activities and transactions take place within the walls of massive virtual kingdoms,” and where the company can assert control over vendors and products. 

The second, like Web 1.0, is a sort of “decentralized utopia,” where users can move seamlessly from one metaverse to the next, carrying with them a universal profile along with their unique digital assets and currencies. According to a research paper by Outlier Ventures, a tech company working on an open metaverse accelerator, a true metaverse requires “its own economy and currencies native to it, where value can be earnt, spent, lent, borrowed or invested interchangeably in both a physical or virtual sense and most importantly, without the need for a government.” And in this world where multiple metaverses exist, states Boson Protocol, “we need frameworks of ownership, commerce, and value transfer that allow assets to flow seamlessly from one metaverse to another.”

These first two possibilities seem to exist at opposite ends of the same spectrum—closed and centralized on one end and open and decentralized on the other. The third route, and perhaps the most realistic one, is a middle ground between the two. In the event that gatekeepers establish control over the metaverse landscape, it’s possible that other intermediaries will emerge to make the metaverse appear seamless. 

Similar to the way tech companies are able to provide software that’s compatible with different operating systems such as Windows and MacOS, it’s no stretch to think that companies may be able to do the same with different metaverse platforms. It’s also worth noting that when something is growing exponentially, the players who cooperate on the infrastructure ultimately win. Rather than companies trying to take the entire proverbial pie for themselves, it’s more likely they will try to share it instead.

OPEN OR CLOSED?

Despite the uncertainty of the metaverse’s future, the opposing forces of centralization versus decentralization are already at play. Jon Radoff, CEO of gaming engine Beamable, said he believes that the choices and investments made now will determine which of the paths will unfold. While big tech corporations such as Meta and Oculus are attempting to dominate the space with their closed platforms, other companies like Decentraland are advocating for open, blockchain-based platforms. As the space continues to evolve and consensus builds, the matter of ownership and interoperability will become less of a question.


Jason Cottrell is CEO & Founder of Orium, North America’s leading composable commerce consultancy and system integrator.