Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Why are product management mishires still prevalent?

Organizational context is such a critical part of any hiring process. This imbues everything from how the job description is worded, learning and development (training) during tenures, and the success (or failure) of the hired individual. 

Product management mishires

[Pixel-Shot / Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Krishna Kutty

“I’m the Head of Product X…” was how the call started from an acquaintance at a mid-sized organization who had called me for career advice, and after 20 minutes of bravado, it ended with, “I’m currently five levels removed from the Chief Product Officer but don’t feel empowered to do what I thought I was hired to do.” In close succession, I received a call from a senior director of product management of a large organization who led with, “I got the worst performance review of my career… what went so wrong? It has only been two years—what do they expect me to have achieved in this role?” 

From my perspective, while both were talented individuals, they were mishires for their respective organizations. But why is this still so prevalent in the product management space?

Organizational context is such a critical part of any hiring process. This imbues everything from how the job description is worded, learning and development (training) during tenures, and the success (or failure) of the hired individual. 

CHANGE BEGINS WITH JOB DESCRIPTIONS

A quick scan of hiring platforms showed me that the everything-but-the-kitchen-sink approach to job descriptions for a product manager is, unfortunately, alive and thriving. This range includes developing the go-to-market plan; monitoring task progression; setting pricing; coordinating with sales and development teams; being responsible for user experience; independently driving progress and success of the product; implementing agile ways of working; having deep technical expertise to do quality assurance and testing; and owning the strategic planning process.

Instead of every skill under the sun, I expected to see requirements that I know and have experienced as core product-management functions. Skills like engaging with customers to uncover problems and prioritization via relative value assessments were sometimes missing. How does one understand what “core” capabilities are required, though, if organizational context is driving the need to post these jobs?

In my search, there was also a blend of individual contributor roles versus people manager responsibilities. In most organizations, product managers are given the onus of being responsible for the product outcome, but without direct reporting relationships with the multitude of functions required to achieve that desired outcome (e.g., sales, development, marketing, regulatory, finance). Even if people-manager responsibilities exist, I have not seen them include reports from all the functional areas that are required; for example, in the Fortune 500 space, a common direct reporting line leader across all of those functions doesn’t generally exist until you get to the business unit president level or above.

Finally, a few descriptions made a call-out regarding how a product manager differs from a project manager. While I would agree with the sentiment, what I have found is that this tends to quite often be a way to abdicate responsibility for core product manager responsibilities, such as communication, persuasion, influence, tact, and adaptability. It is important to know how the sausage (or product) is made at an organization. In large, global organizations, especially those with complex operating models, these soft skills are sometimes the make-or-break points of careers and successful product outcomes.

FINDING THE RIGHT CANDIDATE

So, with all the variants of job descriptions and the driving force being specific organizational needs, how does a hiring manager or an HR professional review and filter potential candidates who apply with the same variety of work experiences? A tough proposition!

My recommendation would be to start by leveraging the Association of Product Professionals’ Product Proficiency Framework, which defines 26 critical skills (both technical and adaptive). Hiring managers and HR professionals can use these and the available benchmark data they can provide. In addition, it is important to consider the organization size and the complexity of the operating model to understand where to index more heavily in terms of required skill sets. This can help better signal the role expectations and help focus in on candidates who are more closely aligned to your organization’s needs.

In a small start-up that includes a flat hierarchy, one product, and a culture of quick decision-making, a candidate profile that shows a senior director, head of product, or chief product officer role may entail a skill set that leans toward technical product management and day-to-day execution, with no team or a small team. I emphasize “may,” as this is also highly dependent on the growth stage of the start-up and a host of other factors.

I would encourage any hiring manager to ask probing questions that can showcase whether the potential candidate has the right skill set to navigate the complexity of your operating model. While this candidate may be a potential match due to experience in the same industry, there are factors you should consider that drive these probing questions. These factors include: your established organizational hierarchy, the number of products you have, whether the functional accountabilities have been clearly defined, and whether the product management role is embedded in a team of specialists versus sitting in a more strategic leadership seat.

A final point for consideration: If this is the first time your organization is making a pivot to using rigor to define and find a product manager, ensure that you are putting learning and development opportunities in place that support skill-set-gap closure and growth. That applies not only for the new hire, but also for personnel from extended functional departments that are required to deliver on your desired outcomes.

At Kuroshio Consulting, we have provided product management training, consulting, and executive advisory services to clients ranging from start-ups through to the Fortune 10. It still is a shock when organizations share that they expect one newly hired individual or one existing leader to be solely accountable for driving (often transformational) change. I’ve personally had too many discussions with client executives who focus on skill set gaps of the product manager or leader without also acknowledging the surrounding landscape. In my experience, understanding your organizational context and providing the support structures to enable your product manager and the extended team to succeed is critical for long-term success and the prevention of mishires.


Krishna Kutty is Managing Partner & Co-Founder at Kuroshio Consulting, advising clients on strategy, transformations, and leadership.