I believe the way many organizations today are led and managed is broken and must transform to adapt to unprecedented new realities. These include tremendous talent challenges such as the Great Resignation, quiet quitting, an epidemic of mental health issues in the workplace, and endemically poor levels of engagement. One of the fundamental ways that the leadership imperative has transformed is related to the role of a leader as a provider of meaning. While the world has been moving toward this new paradigm for a number of years, we have now fully entered the era of the “meaning-full” leader as a critical component of organizational success.
World-renowned psychiatrist Viktor Frankl, through his own experiences as a concentration camp survivor, found that the drives for pleasure and power are, in fact, not the most fundamental human drivers. In his seminal work, Man’s Search for Meaning, he speaks to the primary driver of the human being as one of finding and experiencing meaning in life.
WHY DOES MEANING MATTER MORE THAN EVER IN LEADERSHIP TODAY?
As a leader, you have the opportunity each day to bring meaning to your team members and colleagues. Meaning ignites the human spirit and is the core fuel of purpose-driven work. It is an essential source of creativity, innovation, and value creation.
Let’s look at some examples of this in the business world:
McKinsey survey respondents who said they were “living their purpose” at work demonstrated four times higher engagement and five times higher well-being than those who were not. Unfortunately, only one-third of respondents felt their organizations were strongly connecting actions to purpose.
A Harvard Business School study used Great Places to Work’s database to show that when employees, especially middle managers, experienced both purpose and clarity at work, company returns outperformed the stock market by 6.9%.
Indiggo’s 2022 ROL100 ranking in partnership with Fortune revealed that “the most purpose-driven companies outperformed on core financial metrics.” Three-year revenue growth was 58% higher, and earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization per employee were over 90% greater for companies ranked in the top 25 versus those in the bottom 25.
BEING A MEANING-FULL LEADER
Creating a context of meaning for your team members is not rocket science, but it does take sincere commitment. How can you accomplish this?
1. FOCUS ON THE “WHY”
I’m seeing more and more companies crafting statements of core purpose that answer, “Why does our company exist/What is its core contribution to the world?”
This is a positive trend, but I don’t believe it is enough. Unless team members experience the stated purpose as authentic, it can create a loss of trust and disengagement rather than meaning and engagement.
However, even in the case of an inauthentic corporate purpose statement, a manager can still provide an environment of meaning and purpose for team members. This can be done by connecting the dots on how a team member’s work makes a difference—how that person’s efforts result in a tangible, positive impact on others, whether it be external stakeholders or colleagues inside the organization.
2. CULTIVATE MEANINGFUL WORKING RELATIONSHIPS
I’ve found today’s employees want workplaces where they have trusting, authentic relationships with their leaders, and where a focus on results is balanced with a genuine concern for team members’ needs. I believe the current wave of resignations and quiet quitting is partly the consequence of people not experiencing this enough at work. Leaders who are able to create meaningful working relationships can also create the type of environment where employees will go the extra mile.
A Harvard Business Review/Zenger Folkman study found that for managers who were not adept at relationships, 14% of their direct reports were quietly quitting while just 20% were willing to put in more effort. In contrast, managers who were more highly rated when it came to balancing relationships and results saw just 3% of their direct reports quietly quitting while 62% were willing to go the extra mile.
3. GIVE MEANINGFUL WORK TO YOUR TEAM MEMBERS
I’ve consistently observed that extrinsic incentives and rewards provide no meaning (and can even show a negative correlation to performance).
In contrast, a vital source of meaning and satisfaction can be found in the work itself. This can happen when team members are challenged with the appropriate level of difficulty and required growth (not too little or too much) and are doing work that matters. Bestselling author Daniel Pink calls this work Goldilocks tasks, where employees can all have the experience at work of “being in the zone.” This fundamental source of meaning may be overlooked in overwhelmed workdays, where overcrowded plates and reactivity can crowd out the most meaningful work.
As the old adage goes, people don’t quit their company, they quit their boss. With today’s talent challenges and opportunities, I believe meaningful leadership is critical. You may need to unlearn unproductive management styles from a bygone era and live in the reality that you are a human leading other humans. Authentic, meaningful relationships can be game changers, purpose matters, and meaningful work seals the deal. By embracing the era of the meaningful leader, you can give your organization a powerful edge in the brand-new realities unfolding in front of us all.
Marc Inzelstein is Co-founder and Chief Leadership officer of Indiggo.