Are you confused by all this marketplace lingo? Between 1P, 2P, and 3P; unmanaged, lightly managed, and managed; C2C, B2C, and B2B; and vertical and horizontal marketplaces, it can get complicated.
What does it all mean? How do you select the right type of marketplace for your business? I’ve broken down the various kinds of marketplaces out there. Now keep in mind that some of these marketplaces can overlap. For instance, Amazon can be considered a 1P, B2C, managed, and horizontal marketplace.
1P, 2P, AND 3P MARKETPLACES
First-party marketplace (1P): This is when a wholesaler sells directly to retailers such as Nordstrom, T.J. Maxx, or Amazon. This is a good choice if you are a retailer who takes ownership of products and sells them to consumers.
Second-party marketplace (2P): Second-party marketplaces are when sellers depend on a distributor partnership to ship products to customers. The brand making the item sells to the distributor, and the distributor then sells it to the retailer. This is appropriate if you don’t want to deal with distribution and you would rather have someone else do it.
Third-party marketplace (3P): Third-party marketplaces are where the brand keeps ownership of its products and uses a platform like Amazon for marketing and selling the goods. When a sale occurs, the brand oversees the fulfillment of the goods. Farm Rio and Saks Fifth Avenue have a relationship like this. This is an excellent choice for a brand with a direct-to-consumer model that also wants to enjoy the perks of wholesale.
UNMANAGED, LIGHTLY MANAGED, AND MANAGED MARKETPLACES
Unmanaged marketplace: In this case, the owner doesn’t interfere with the consumer-to-vendor transaction. The owner does not invest in their company’s quality control, usually relying on a peer-review or rating system to maintain credibility. This choice can be risky if you want customers to trust your brand.
Lightly managed marketplace: A lightly managed marketplace focuses more on customers, putting effort into vetting vendors, quality assurance, and background and identity checks. Uber, Grubhub, Airbnb, and Lyft are examples of lightly managed marketplaces. This is a great option if you offer a service rather than an actual physical product—think providing a place to stay, delivering food, or allowing access to transportation.
Managed marketplace: Managed marketplaces are marketplaces where the retailer is more involved with the transaction execution. Examples include Rebag, the luxury resale platform I founded, thredUP, and Opendoor. This is a good model if you want customers to trust your business.
P2P, C2C, B2B, AND B2C MARKETPLACES
Peer-to-peer (P2P) or consumer-to-consumer (C2C): P2P, also known as C2C, platforms allow individuals who provide products or services with a platform to meet consumers and potential customers. Examples include eBay, Vestiaire Collective, and Airbnb. If you want to help people build their businesses and you don’t want to deal with purchasing inventory, P2P is the way to go.
Business-to-business (B2B) marketplace: A B2B marketplace links consumers (businesses) to vendors (other businesses) so that they can provide goods and services for the business. If you’re B2B, you provide services or goods to other businesses.
Business-to-consumer (B2C) marketplace: This is the general term for businesses that cater to consumers, like Bloomingdale’s, Amazon, or Target. Most companies are also B2C. If you cater to consumers, you’re B2C.
Consignment: Consignment is when somebody who wants to sell their product leaves the item or items with a third party to sell. When an item sells, the third party receives a portion of the revenue in the form of a flat rate, or commission. One example is The RealReal, which takes a percentage of each sale from the original seller. With this model, you don’t have to purchase inventory—you simply pay the provider a commission once it sells.
VERTICAL AND HORIZONTAL MARKETPLACES
Vertical marketplace: A vertical marketplace offers goods or services that cater to a specific market. Spotify, Barnes & Noble, and Patagonia are examples of vertical marketplaces. If you provide goods within a specific market to a particular consumer base, this is your model.
Horizontal marketplace: A horizontal marketplace delivers a wide range of goods and services. Examples include MatchesFashion, Amazon, and Walmart. If you provide many goods and services, then you operate within a horizontal marketplace.
Now comes the interesting part—figuring out which marketplace model is right for your business. As I developed Rebag, I evaluated these models myself, deciding that a managed marketplace was ideal for its business model. Perhaps you already have your business in place, but you’re not sure which type of marketplace it is, or you are looking to start a new company, but want to make sure it’s a specific market model. Whatever your case is, read over the definitions to figure out which marketplace model is right for your business and clientele. Each has its pros and cons—the hard part is picking out which suits your business the best.
Charles Gorra is the Founder & CEO of Rebag, the ultimate destination for trading, selling, and buying the world’s most sought-after brands.