Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Leader v. manager: How managing a company is different from leading a board

Getting a seat on a company board might feel like sitting at the top of the food chain, and as leaders of our companies, we might all assume we know how to take the lead on a board. But running a board is not like running a company.

Leader v. manager: How managing a company is different from leading a board

[Photo Credits: ty / Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Martin Rowinski

In the corporate world, when we finally make it to CEO, we become company leaders. This is not a position many people know firsthand—if Zippia’s estimate of over 38,708 chief executive officers in the U.S. is correct, that means CEOs make up just 0.0001% of the country’s population. C-Suite executives and vice presidents also experience the feeling of knowing what it takes to be a leader, but not all leadership is alike. 

Getting a seat on a company board might feel like sitting at the top of the food chain, and as leaders of our companies, we might all assume we know how to take the lead on a board. But running a board is not like running a company. All board members—especially CEOs, for whom roles most often cross—should recognize the difference between the leadership it takes to manage a company and lead a board.

COMPANY LEADERS MANAGE THE COMPANY

Those who have risen to the top of their company—CEO, president, vice, or C-suite executives—are leaders, but the role of a company leader is mostly one of management. Even managers are leaders in a company, but unlike top-level leadership with a more broad understanding of all of its cogs, their leadership is usually focused on a specific skill or knowledge. Just like a sales manager checks their monthly sales goals daily, so is a CEO checking their progress toward the organization’s month-end and quarterly goals day by day. A CEO has to be grounded in the present.

When we compare how a CEO leads their company to what a manager does with their team, the behavior is pretty similar. While managers accomplish department objectives, the company leaders accomplish company objectives. CEOs plan and evaluate company activities, maintain staff, and develop growth opportunities. They set goals, execute strategies, and focus on achieving success, getting elbows deep in the company day to day to make that happen. Their job is to lead by digging in—working with individual employees and guiding them toward being their best. They endorse a healthy company culture and promote it through their teams.

A BOARD REQUIRES A LEADER

As chairman of the board, a leader needs to be a visionary. They need to think down the line about how one decision will lead to another and plot the company’s future. Leaders as managers can also be visionaries, but they still have to follow the vision of their board’s leadership. Board leaders create that vision with an understanding that they are not the only ones needed to get them there; their vision inspires other people to take action. While company leaders need to think about the whole organization from the inside, board members see it from above and make decisions with that bigger picture in mind. 

While a company leader manages, a board leader strategizes, and according to the Harvard Business Review, a company needs both: 

“A board chair leads the board’s effort to excel at advising on strategy, monitoring performance, overseeing finance and controls, and evaluating management. A CEO establishes within the company a shared set of values, practices, and goals that enables [it] to execute its strategic plan and build a meaningful future.”

The company leadership comes to the board to find solutions and board members bring ideas to the table. They work as a team to determine the best path forward and CEOs bring those strategies back to their company to implement them. With the right board of diverse experience and skill sets in the right areas, members should be able to craft more successful strategies than a CEO could do on their own. But the CEO, as company manager, is responsible for carrying those strategies through to success. 

THERE WILL BE TIMES THAT CALL FOR BOTH

Of course, there are also times when these roles will overlap, especially for CEOs. As board chairmen, they might find themselves making decisions or forming strategies that they then need to take back to execute with their company. They go from board visionaries back to leaders managing an organization: meeting with other top-level leadership, discussing team goals, and presenting those strategies to the company for implementation. At the next board meeting, members expect the CEO, as its chair, to report on the strategy’s success. 

This crossover between company and board leadership happens all the time, especially for CEOs and smaller companies. I am very hands-on as a CEO at a relatively small company, so on boards, when I have to look to the future, I also keep in mind my involvement in daily company tasks. But at a certain point, the company grows so large that the CEO should no longer be as entrenched in company management. The founder needs to cede more control and open themselves up to external influence and feedback. This is when a powerful team of board members can step in and help balance decision-making with diverse perspectives. 

While most founders usually step in and fill both positions in the early stages of the company, not everyone has the skills to be both the best CEO and most effectively lead its board—or realize what traits they might be missing. This is why experts recommend that a company’s CEO and board chairman be two different people—the company benefits from the additional skills, experience, and capacity of a second leader and the board engages in more authentic and open dialogue regarding feedback. For an effective board that drives company success, CEOs should diversify their insights and leverage both types of leadership.


Martin Rowinski is the CEO of Boardsi, a corporate board recruitment company.