Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Stop trying to compete with Amazon: How to create value this holiday season

To navigate mixed signals in the market, retailers must ask: How will my brand create value for discerning shoppers?

Santa holding a gift

[Images: eggeeggjiew/Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Ben Crudo

Trees aren’t up yet, but we’re already seeing retail giants like Amazon and Target promoting holiday sales. Amazon announced a two-day holiday sale for its Prime members in October, while Target announced its own holiday sale a week prior—along with a price-match guarantee.

It’s tough to make any solid long-term projections right now with gas prices skyrocketing then dipping, markets plunging and recovering, and minimum wage rising along with the cost of living. Market researchers anticipate a 14.3% increase in year-over-year e-commerce sales, but it’s also clear people are feeling the pinch of high prices, with 89% of consumers expecting inflation to impact their holiday shopping. 

To navigate mixed signals in the market, retailers must ask: How will my brand create value for discerning shoppers?

While flashy sales and discounted prices are attractive, the fact is most retailers can’t afford to slash prices like Target or Amazon—especially this year. Luckily, there are ways to create customer value and engender brand loyalty that don’t involve cutting prices. Here’s how to do it. 

CAPITALIZE ON HUMAN CONNECTION

This holiday, people will be able to shop in person without any pandemic restrictions for the first time in two years. Retail’s return to normalcy means many people will be walking into stores having missed casual, interpersonal interactions—something studies show can make us happier, healthier, and more optimistic. Don’t underestimate how appreciative shoppers will be to find human connection with your staff.

As it’s become harder to attract and retain sales staff with minimum wages, smart retailers are investing in hiring true connoisseurs—people who are passionate about the cultures their products fit into and who have the technical aptitude to improve the in-person experience.

For example, on a recent shopping trip in New York, I popped into the outdoor goods store REI. I had a long chat with a salesperson who shared my love of hiking (a topic my friends are all sick of hearing about!). He empathized with the pain a pair of shoes had been causing me and informed me a small piece of moleskin placed near the heel might be a better fix than investing in a new pair. I didn’t once get the sense he was trying to upsell or push products on me. I walked away not just with new gear, but a sense of belonging and plans to return.  

Eighty percent of Americans consider knowledgeable help and friendly service—along with speed and convenience—to be the most important elements of a positive customer experience, while 92% of consumers agree that a good experience makes them more likely to make another purchase. Ensure your staff are happy, engaged, and have knowledge to share with shoppers and your customers will appreciate it—now more than ever.

OFFER PERSONALIZATION AT SCALE 

When it comes to e-commerce, convenience equals value. This holiday season, there are two intuitive ways e-retailers can improve serviceability and make customers feel like VIPs. Both pertain to personalization—not only in gifts themselves, but in the experience of buying them.

First off, e-retailers can consider adopting video messaging software to create an easy gifting experience that offers an extra personal touch. Some businesses already allow shoppers to add personalized cards when sending a gift, but today’s tech makes it possible to incorporate personalized videos. Social scientists have long known hearing a loved one’s voice reduces stress and makes us feel more bonded—powerful feelings to evoke when gift giving. 

Second, with rising inflation and more climate-conscious consumers, many people want to “buy less and buy better.” Retailers can meet that demand by giving shoppers more options for how to pay. 

With the growth of buy now, pay later services like Afterpay and Affirm, it’s clear point-of-sale software that offers flexible payment options resonates with consumers. The latest tech offers consumers an easy way to go in on a gift together via split-payment transactions. This allows consumers to share the cost of items among a group while checking out with separate credit cards. Integrating split-payment software into your online checkout means shoppers can complete their entire transaction with you, rather than requiring an app like Venmo after the fact. 

Having customized spending options is akin to having more agency over one’s purchases—the value of which can’t be overstated at a moment when consumers are more budget-conscious and are feeling the weight of macroeconomic circumstances beyond their individual control.

FOCUS ON CREATING LONG-TERM VALUE

Making it easier for people to shop their values is creating value. I speak from experience as the world’s #1 dumb phone fan. I’ll explain: the dumb phone industry is smart enough to know eco-minded consumers like me want their products to be repairable and recyclable. As such, they sell spare parts and offer assistance with repairs. By aligning with my ethics, this business model provides added value.

Globally, 85% of consumers have become greener in their purchasing decisions within recent years, and sustainability is an important purchasing criterion for Gen Z. When we talk about “shopping our values” or living a sustainable lifestyle, reuse is at the heart.

Whether it’s by making shirt buttons replaceable, sunscreen bottles refillable, or product repair manuals available on their website, brands have the power to make changes that will get consumers talking about the sensible and sustainable purchase they just made at your store. Likewise, when brands create or curate durable products built to last a lifetime, they build enduring trust with loyal consumers who value quality and longevity over rock-bottom prices.

The holidays can be stressful, but take heart. Retailers that have made it this far have already shown resilience in the face of instability and developed a foundation to navigate future market turns. Those that focus on increasing value for their customers will see dividends paid throughout the New Year.


Ben Crudo is CEO of Diff Agency. A retailer-turned-technologist, Ben is an ecommerce expert helping retailers win today and tomorrow.