Much has been made of HR’s “coming-out party” since the start of the COVID pandemic.
Sure, there’s since been massive burnout and awful turnover, remote and hybrid work protocols, and Quiet Quitting to deal with—not to mention ratcheting demands for analytics and dashboards, meaningful DEI, reskilling/upskilling, employer branding, and about a thousand other things.
But supposedly, the momentum is in HR’s favor. More top talent than ever has moved into HR over the last few years and budgets are up to mirror millennial and Gen Z demands. HR’s profile has been raised, and for once, the proverbial “seat at the table” has materialized.
CEOs are listening. They’re also spending—on systems, consultants, coaches, and above all, perks and employer branding. It’s as if, after decades of disrespect and largely custodial duties, HR is no longer the corporate step-child, but a true partner in the business—an adult in the room. We are no longer seen as those cringeworthy paper-pushers portrayed in The Office, or heartless, robotic termination machines like George Clooney’s character in Up in The Air.
Or so we like to tell ourselves. Perhaps our reflexive virtue-signaling is just more window dressing, lipstick on the proverbial pig. Perceptions die hard. And frankly, PR has never been HR’s strong suit.
Now, recession signals are flashing all over the place. And when a crisis hits, command-and-control leadership tends to rear its ugly head.
The first casualty? You bet, it’s HR. Budgets are getting slashed. People initiatives are getting mothballed. Staff is getting laid off. And it’s not just in tech! HR’s Cinderella-like glass slipper moment is slipping away. And odds are, any coming recession will only turn the clock back to before midnight. As most seasoned HR people know, HR is generally “last on, first off.”
And the trouble goes much deeper than just the cost-center view of HR from a financial model perspective. Firstly, founders, CEOs, and non-CHRO execs very rarely have any experience as HR practitioners. Strike one for empathy and understanding.
Secondly, relatively few HR leaders come from other C-suite positions or prominent academic backgrounds. Sixty-seven percent of HR practitioners have a bachelor’s degree, while only 14% have a master’s. Of those, 15% of Fortune 200 CHROs have an MBA and 56% have a master’s or doctorate of some sort.
By contrast, a full 54% of top North American CEOs hold an MBA, and 66% of all the world’s top CEOs have either a master’s or doctorate. Strike two for perceived legitimacy and boardroom dynamics.
Thirdly, out of all C-suite leaders, CHROs are the least likely to become CEOs. Strike three for “people as the core of our business.”
Lastly, a significant majority of HR leaders and practitioners are women who skew older (the average age of an HR practitioner is 46.6 years). In 2021, women made up a full 74.8% of HR managers in the U.S. Contrast this with only 25% of all key, C-suite roles being held by women. Another strike for HR getting a meaningful voice and (non-pro-forma) seat at the table, thanks to boardroom dynamics.
And so we have it, a gulf between HR’s perception and corporate reality.
There’s no question that HR has raised its profile during COVID. But recessions and crises have a way of washing away tenuous progress quickly. Just witness the stunning erosion of women’s gender equality in the workplace. As of this writing, layoffs are gaining steam even as experts are warning against laying off staff reflexively in difficult business conditions.
As Josh Bersin warns, the unfortunate truth (backed by his research) is that most CEOs have no idea of the best course of action in downturns, regardless of their endless consultants, meetings, and ideas. Re-enter command-and-control leadership.
As a CHRO during COVID, I’ve seen firsthand the brute force of cost cuts, layoffs, and shelved employee initiatives (including well-being, coaching, HR systems, and the like). And this is the case for companies undergoing record growth, not just those with diminishing balance sheets. Fear of a downturn is just as potent as the actual thing.
And so, what can HR do to save face, to keep intact—and grow—the company culture and people function, in spite of the economic headwinds?
For starters, the dreaded “business case,” “ROI,” and cost projections connected to layoffs (as compared to keeping people and asking for voluntary pay cuts) must inevitably re-emerge.
Secondly, once core talent retention becomes the main goal of HR, strong learning and development (upskilling, reskilling, mental model shifts, and new manager training), and coaching programs must materialize.
Thirdly, effective internal communication will take on new importance as more will be asked from fewer staff members. This means more in-person one-on-ones, fewer useless meetings, and less reliance on Slack, Zoom, and email. There’s still no better way to motivate people than in person, sometimes.
Fourth, instead of shrinking back into passive preservation mode, HR must demand more resources, budgets, and staffing to do proactive work, rather than stay silent about cuts and layoffs. If it’s “all hands on deck” during “crisis mode,” then the caretakers (HR) must be cared for, or they’ll leave the sinking ship like rats, leaving nobody to care for the creators, sellers, marketers, and operators.
Lastly—and most importantly—HR must find and grow its proverbial “mojo.” HR is no longer just a custodial, “keep the status quo” legal/compliance function, and cost center. It’s also the Chief Employee Advocate, Chief Wellness Office, teacher of skills and mental models, career coach, ombudsman, event planner, workforce developer, performance manager, rewards/recognition engine, salary adjuster, and more.
The point of no return is here. Since CEOs won’t suddenly see the light, HR teams themselves must take a stand. If HR blinks first, it’s back to the Dark Ages. It’s almost midnight and it’s time to go big or go home. Glass slipper or not, there’s no going back to business as usual. Adult HR is here to stay.
Award-winning CEO of HR, Talent & Systems, Top 5 HR Global Thought Leader and Influencer, VC/PE HR Tech Advisor, C-suite coach, 5x author