Earlier this year, I bought a product from a home decor retailer online. They told me it would take a few weeks to arrive, but I was still waiting after four months. I rarely do this, but I was so upset—I called customer service and yelled.
And yet, I understand what probably happened. Despite being out of reach of many initial pandemic-related challenges, retail is still struggling, from supply chain breakdowns to labor shortages and a potential recession. This experience was hardly my first time confronting it, and my delayed item was not of life-or-death importance. Still, I felt the company communicated a certain lack of respect in failing to share the truth of the matter—a truth they already knew.
Amidst so much uncertainty, the relationship between consumers and businesses has worn thin. Facing the holidays amid an oncoming economic downturn, retailers that lean into transparency, open communication, and resiliency to restore delicate consumer-business relationships will come out on top.
THE BURDEN AFFECTS US ALL
Over two years have passed since we first began reopening after the COVID-19 shutdown, but life has not gotten more manageable for the retail industry. At first, there was widespread job loss. Then, there were mass resignations. Quit rates are still high across many industries, but leisure, hospitality, and retail businesses are having an especially hard time retaining employees.
Although consumer demand bounced back quickly, continued changes in product demands have disrupted inventories and continue to exacerbate supply chain issues. Add rising inflation, high gas prices, and a looming recession, and everyone is feeling the strain—from retail workers and CEOs to consumers.
NO ONE HAS CONTROL
When I called about my purchase, I felt powerless in the situation. But, I began to realize that no one holds power. I called the retailer wanting my item delivered, hoping they could somehow control the logistics.
But we are facing issues on a global scale, issues that cross industries. The representative on the line explained all the points along the supply chain causing the hold-up: “We have no drivers; the cost of gas is high; we’re short on supplies, and we don’t have enough people to work.” I almost felt worse for her than for myself.
So many retail components are beyond anyone’s control, making customer service interactions tense and uncomfortable, sometimes angry but always increasingly fragile.
THERE IS A PATH FORWARD
Everyone feels the heaviness of uncertainty right now. For retailers, empathy is key to navigating this holiday season. Recognize we are all in the same boat and vulnerable to disruptions. Here are a few ways to fortify fragile customer relationships, so they become more robust in the new year:
Transparency
Be honest about shipping times and inventory upfront, or admit to delays the moment they become apparent. Let customers decide right when they put an item into their basket by providing a notification: “This item will take two to four months to ship.” Most customers will appreciate the option to accept a given time frame before they commit to buying.
Communication
Retailers unsure of what to expect from the coming holiday season should open lines of communication early—the sooner, the better. Start communicating with consumers before they even know what they want to buy. Overcommunicate. If customers leave items in a basket, send a message asking if they still want to purchase it. Promote holiday shopping early and get more people committed to purchases in advance.
When supply chain issues occur (and they will), communicate delays as soon as possible and express a genuine understanding of the inconvenience. But always be honest.
Resiliency
Be ready, willing, and eager to support consumer needs through the holidays, and stay prepared to offer backup goodwill to accommodate the unexpected. Offer a discount on a delayed item or future purchases. Send complimentary packages to express understanding. The more flexible a retailer is in accommodating the unexpected, the more likely it will restore healthy customer relationships.
Effective resiliency must be accompanied by transparency and open communication. Once I finished yelling, the customer service representative did offer me a discount; but without upfront transparency and communication, I still felt a little burned.
Customer relationships may be fragile, but we can preserve even the most delicate antiques for centuries when we care for and maintain them. From the start, transparency about my order would have alleviated four months of concern. If the delay was unexpected, I would have appreciated better communication. The desire to appear strong and impenetrable may be tempting, but retailers resilient enough to weather an uncertain holiday season will lean into vulnerability, building lasting relationships with their consumers.
Efrat is CMO at Quantum Metric, with extensive experience in tech leadership and customer-centric organization strategies.