It is budgeting season for those of us anchored to the annual fiscal calendar. As we prepare for the coming year, we’ve noticed more than a handful of retail executives questioning their Direct to Customer (DTC) strategies in the face of a changing economy. Echoes of fear about slow demand, advertising costs, and competition threaten a widespread retail pullback. But we must ask, is this reaction premature?
It’s true that the economy is slowing, costs have risen, and performance has been sluggish—not too surprising after a few years of slower retail growth. It seems we marketers have been simultaneously waiting for this shoe to drop and foolishly hoping it wouldn’t. While this trend is concerning, we believe that the DTC channel still offers significant opportunities for brands with long-term omnichannel aspirations.
It is our advice that executives should pause, evaluate performance, and diversify strategies to hedge their marketing mix.
In this DTC State of the Union, we’re reviewing DTC trends, threats, and opportunities, and sharing strategic recommendations for how to stay ahead of impending market changes.
WHY ARE DTC CHANNELS SUFFERING?
In the early days of DTC, retail brands saw an opportunity to expand beyond their brick-and-mortar constraints, and benefit from lower overhead and wider customer reach. For consumers, DTC channels like eCommerce websites offered shopping experiences conveniently tailored to their needs and lifestyle.
Meanwhile, the prospect of lower customer acquisition costs (CAC) excited investors and invited a whole host of new entrants to the marketplace. Notable players like Warby Parker, Dollar Shave Club, and Casper disrupted industries and became overnight case studies for DTC success.
On the flip side, the movement inspired more than a handful of failed launches. Some reacted slowly in the face of change. Others found themselves hamstrung by unfavorable economics, with LTV and CAC ratios that were not in line with the challenges of the online marketplace.
The decade-long period of sustained economic growth—propped up by the unexpected financial events caused by the pandemic—also meant that many companies could mask most signs of unsustainable metrics and continue to raise money at increasingly favorable valuations.
A False Economic Narrative & Pandemic Fever Dream
Fast forward to 2020: DTC businesses are thrust into the spotlight once again with lockdowns forcing consumers and retailers to adapt to an uncomfortable reality. In an instant, home office furniture, sweat pants, and bread flour required convenient two-day delivery and a liberal return policy. With the help of social media, DTC businesses expanded rapidly again, capitalizing on a captive audience in quarantine.
In retrospect, the pandemic was another litmus test for the industry. Some were prepared, but many overestimated the opportunity and have suffered due to soft fundamentals and unrealistic growth prospects.
Privacy and Data Transparency
Apple iOS is a major presence in the market, used by more than 50% of consumers. When it changed its privacy settings, the ability of DTC and eCommerce businesses to track consumer trends suddenly reduced significantly—a huge blow in the ability to target the customer directly.
Furthermore, Apple is not the only brand increasing privacy settings for users. Many companies (i.e. Facebook, Google, and the like) are taking customer concerns about privacy seriously, and allowing them to opt out of tracking. Without insights provided by cookies and tracking, direct targeting has been somewhat hindered, contributing to the rise in ad delivery costs.
Not A Silver Bullet
Relying upon social media to market products made sense for a while, especially with the low costs of advertising on Facebook and Instagram. However, ad costs have steadily risen and privacy changes have since triggered a step reduction in ROAS (return on ad spend).
As a result, the miscalculated unit economics to which many brands and investors were anchored became evident and new DTC strategies became a convenient scapegoat for broader business issues.
In hindsight, there was never an issue with DTC channels, but more so a flaw with the irrational belief that it was a silver bullet.
IS DTC GOING AWAY?
Despite changes to the marketplace, DTC is here to stay. E-commerce accounts for 21% of all retail sales, up from about 19.6% last year, and is expected to grow to 22.3% next year. As a percentage of those sales, DTC is also expected to increase with it.
DTC FORECAST THROUGH 2025 AND BEYOND
Looking ahead to 2025, DTC as a model will continue to gain ground, albeit at the pace it was headed pre-pandemic. Some trends to be expected for the next three years and beyond:
- Physical retailers adopting DTC into their marketing
- Influencer use of DTC to market their own brands
- The growth of competition in DTC
- Increased use of subscription-based and flexible payment plans
- The expansion of DTC into other business categories.
TIPS FOR CONTINUED DTC SUCCESS
What can be done to keep DTC viable and successful? Below are some tips and tactics to take note of.
Easy Return Policy
Since your customer will not be dealing with the product directly until after they have bought it, a complicated return policy may scare them off.
Financial-Based Marketing
Spending without proper planning or an understanding of core business KPIs or unit-level economics creates waste; it doesn’t optimize you for the future, and it limits your ability to adapt.
Social Commerce
Working with influencers or engaging directly with your customers on social media brings your brand into the customer’s space, allowing them to buy products as they scroll through their feeds.
DTC MAY BE DOWN, BUT IT ISN’T OUT
The DTC model has dipped in the wake of the ‘pandemic bubble burst,’ but it is still an important avenue to pursue. It just requires the right focus and expectations so that it can be a sustainable sales channel.
Chris Jones, co-founder and MP at Markacy, specializes in strategic marketing campaigns that optimize financial and commercial objectives.