Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

The beat failure method: Strategizing for success by embracing uncertainty

Going into the new year, the business landscape for agencies has shifted from defining their strategies for success to planning for the possibility of failure.

Woman leading a meeting

[Images: BGStock72/Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Trevor Hubbard

In the post-pandemic future of business, companies are likely to have fewer resources, greater budget constraints, and a higher prevalence of risk drivers. As 2023 begins, agencies are pivoting in response to layoffs and budget deficits that have catalyzed an environment of uncertainty, especially in the enterprise and technology client sectors. Going into the new year, the business landscape for agencies has shifted from defining their strategies for success to planning for the possibility of failure.

At first blush, this seems like a bad thing. However, I posit that failure is not the opposite of success. Embracing failure is actually a prerequisite to success, and initiating a conversation about this is not an admission of defeat but rather the creation of a space to apply the antidote to failure: clarity. 

AN EXERCISE IN CLARITY 

In agencies, lack of clarity breeds drama. Your company’s greatest competitive advantage is human capital. Everyone in your company is unique. They don’t look or talk the same. They certainly don’t think the same. The value in this diversity consists of the multiplicity of perspectives afforded by those who are experts in your company and its success strategy.

In times of risk and uncertainty, I organize a “beat failure clarity session,” offering everyone a seat at the table with the goal of identifying failure points, brainstorming solutions, and subsequently assigning ownership of those solutions to the leaders who will execute them with their teams. This lessens the possibility of failure throughout the organization and makes it a company priority in which everyone plays a role. 

A beat failure clarity session has four main components:

  1. Define what success means for the organization in a few minutes.
  2. Identify failure points and rank them in an hour.
  3. Brainstorm solutions to prevent the biggest failure points (ongoing).
  4. Check back in to see how things are tracking (ongoing).

Starting with the success statement allows your leaders to describe what success looks like for the organization. To be clear, this is not the company’s strategy—this is an articulation of what success means for the agency. For instance, is the company successful when it maintains revenue or when it maintains profit margins? Is it successful when it achieves growth or when it achieves a high return on capital? Or is it successful when it’s delivering great work or maintaining a high level of talent and culture?

However your company defines it, your success statement will inherently encompass potential failure—those things that might possibly get in the way of the outcomes you are trying to achieve. To evaluate this, you’ll move on to the primary purpose of the clarity session: identifying failure points—what would cause your success statement to fail?

START BY SYNTHESIZING IDEAS

Solving difficult problems with a team requires clear and open communication, an environment in which everyone has a voice, and a team committed to helping to dig out of an unsuccessful strategy and move into a new one. Your people are your greatest assets, and by including them in the planning process, you solidify their ownership in the company’s strategy. 

Ideally, a clarity session consists of six to eight people. Once everyone has a seat at the table, ask them to consider the success statement and then brainstorm its pressure points—where could it fail? Are there weaknesses in the structure or process? What could go wrong? Note all resulting suggestions and insights on a whiteboard or a virtual Figma board for everyone to view and consider. 

The relatively small number of people will enable the articulation of a well-rounded perspective. These people are the experts in how your organization works, and their insights are invaluable. Offering them the space to air out their thoughts and collaborate will yield a synthesis of ideas that is arguably your greatest defense against failure. 

NEXT, LOOK FOR REDUNDANCIES 

As you review the ideas your team is sharing, take note of any redundancies. If everyone is saying the same thing, look for things that are categorically the same. These categories could be any number of things: customers, finance, brand, marketing, talent, budgets, etc. 

As you start to group these categories on your whiteboard, you’ll begin to see patterns in the groups. Some groups might have more categories than others, indicating that your best people have the most concerns regarding that area of business. 

CONCLUDE BY RANKING THE IMPACT OF FAILURE POINTS 

This is where things get interesting.

Moving through the categories item by item, ask your team to rank the likelihood that these risk factors or failure points will occur. Have your participants make educated guesses on a scale of one to ten, then pay special attention to those failure points on the upper end of the scale. For these, ask your team to debate the relative impact of these potential failures on the company, brand, or business.

For instance, using another Likert-type scale of one to ten, rank each risk according to its impact and likelihood. Multiply the two numbers. Failure points with the greatest impact take top priority, shifting the conversation toward the company’s position if these failure points were to occur.

This is the point at which contingency plans and strategies are created to prevent and counteract the impact of failure.

FROM CLARITY TO STRATEGY 

Ultimately, your clarity session will expose the blind spots that could lead to failure. At the end of the session, everyone will leave with a hit list of the top 10 to 20 failure points. Assigning them to individual members of your team increases accountability and empowers them to find the right resources and information, while identifying dependencies and the right team to counter the possibility of failure. 

When everyone has a stake in the outcome, each individual instinctively becomes an empowered “failure preventer.” Such a culture creates a unique competitive dynamic for your company. Rather than measuring success by how many expenses you’ve eliminated, you’ll be measuring it by how many failure points you’ve eliminated, and this is the future of competitive strategy.


Trevor is the CEO of Butchershop, a creative brand consultancy built for the future of culture and commerce.