Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Diving deep: Tips for choosing one creative solution out of a sea of ideas

The most effective creative processes from tech startups, innovation, and marketing are iterative, with incremental learnings that are the bowling gutter bumpers messily leading you to a mind-blowing idea. 

[Images: Sunny studio/AdobeStock]

Profile photo of Susan Treacy

When solving a creative problem, the toughest challenge isn’t the problem itself. It’s picking which solution is best. Creativity isn’t like a math problem with a definite answer. A creative solution is entirely subjective, hidden behind all the fleshing out that has yet to happen. So once you have a lot of possible ideas, how do you choose one?

A good first step is to not frame the whole process as a horse race with one crowned winner. The most effective creative processes from tech startups, innovation, and marketing are iterative, with incremental learnings that are the bowling gutter bumpers messily leading you to a mind-blowing idea. 

In evaluating a lot of rough ideas, creative directors use some idea GPS devices for navigating through the ambiguity muck. We routinely find these different ways of working enlighten us when we know the solution is buried in a pile of Post-its. 

STICK TO YOUR FILTERS

How are you judging success? Best decided before you begin, your success metrics could be your KPIs, but also timing, feasibility, first-out ideas, or “good crazy.” This simple discipline grounds you when your bottomless pit of creativity has you swirling. Ideas that meet the objective key criteria move on, and the others can be set aside. Don’t be tempted to pursue an interesting idea that doesn’t match your objectives.

GROUP BY THEME

As a creative director, I first do a lot of bucketing. Arranging like ideas by theme makes it easier to then judge the relatively stronger ideas within any bucket. It’s just like comparing paint color for a wall when you put the grays or greens side by side: The best shade is easier to spot when within its grouping. Suddenly, with your ideas, one bucket is clearly not as promising, or as generative, as another. Entire groupings may be eliminated. Many times the best few ideas in the surviving buckets now emerge, outing the most fruitful ideas to pursue.  

PROTOTYPE, CRUDELY

An important step when evaluating a new idea is to put it in a form that is clear and understandable. I’ve found prototyping helps the team make sure they are all actually talking about the same idea. Ideo’s Tim Brown explains in Change by Design, “The faster we make our ideas tangible, the sooner we will be able to evaluate them, refine them, and zero in on the best solution.”

Making a tangible prototype helps determine whether your idea works. For example, you could create a simplistic simulation of a website made from still images found in a quick Google image search and a headline on a Keynote slide, a script a sales person would say for a service, or a physical object made from cardboard, tape, and a Sharpie. Even a crude prototype makes a vague idea a tangible thing to evaluate.

RANK VOTE

When forced to make a gut call on your top ideas, it can be revealing what stands out. Ask people on the team or key stakeholders to rank their top two ideas. To avoid group think, or having the leader sway a diverse team to their reality, do this privately. If everyone is together, each team member writes their top two choices on a Post-it, then at once, puts it on the wall.

Just keep in mind as the decision-maker that sometimes the group can gravitate toward the familiar, so you need to be the group’s bravery conscience. Their voting is just input to consider where the heat is, not the idea election.

STEP AWAY

When ambiguity is clouding your creative progress, it helps to switch tasks for a while. In convergent thinking, cognitive fixation is often a barrier, causing us to center on preconceived notions, or fail to seriously consider new angles. Taking a break frees our minds, giving time for our incoming biases to wear off. Switching tasks helps restructure our thinking when we return, changing how we search for ideas and solutions. Only then can we spot a novel solution.

RELINQUISH CONTROL

When navigating the ambiguity of picking your best idea, there is a strong instinctual reaction to try to control the uncertainty. You find yourself looking for comfort in the familiar. In Navigating Ambiguity, authors Andrea Small and Kelly Schmutte tell us, “Control is a natural response to the inevitable uncertainty, riskiness, and messiness of collaboration and creativity.” But if you let go and trust the iterative process, you are open to the necessary adapting, tweaking, or even pivoting. This letting go gets harder farther along in the creative process, so try to make choices early on when you have lots of ideas but aren’t too invested in any one. 

Once you have one promising idea, or a few, it can be inspiring to then start a next level of thinking with this as the new starting point. I have found this process kind of like searching in a network of caves. The first rounds of “white paper” ideating are super shallow and quite wide: digging for lots of ideas in lots of directions to make sure we are really thinking the problem through. But once we chose an idea, I like to double down on another round of ideating within that area to go down deep within it. We often re-emerge with a much more original set of ideas to evaluate.

Even then, sometimes, you decide it really wasn’t the best after all. But this worst-case scenario isn’t a failure. When you start again on a fresh round of ideas, you know so much more when picking from the new ideas. You take all that learning from the dead first round and move faster. You use these evaluation tips once again, and finally, the needle in the idea haystack will reveal itself to you.


Susan Treacy is Executive Creative Director at EnergyBBDO. She leads content marketing programs and facilitates creative workshops.