Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Step into the kitchen: Showing up as a creative innovator

Just as creative industries need more chefs and fewer waiters, the same might be said about our institutions, which can produce creative exiles left to thrive after they leave the system.

Frying pan with lightbulbs inside

[Images: small smiles/AdobeStock]

Profile photo of Andrew Swinand

The late chef Anthony Bourdain once wrote that when a patron orders chicken at an upscale restaurant, it’s a sure sign they don’t know what they want to eat. In advertising, we have the same problem with clients who prefer their predictable choice on the table rather than taking a risk with robust flavors and new combinations. They usually start by saying they don’t want the same repurposed ideas but eventually coach the agency back to the same old. 

For Bourdain, good food and good eating were all about risk. 

Many people are risk-averse, and new ideas can be risky. I once had a client ask for a new, never-been-done-before concept and then followed it by asking for data to show that it worked in the past. To truly taste something incredible and original, you need to be open to trying a new dish; the pressure to innovate can feel like a burden, but it is a risk worth taking. 

CHEFS, NOT WAITERS

I believe this lack of risk tolerance in many agencies today leads to an industry full of waitstaff—people who come to the table and ask what the clients want versus listening to what they need. If you have an agency filled with waiters, you’re not deriving or creating value for your clients. 

Unfortunately, the modern education system prepares many people to list the items on the menu by rote rather than teaching them how to be experimental. In my opinion, the emphasis on memorization and teaching to the test comes at the expense of creative development and the ability to think independently.

Much of the creative process involves forming new connections and closing gaps in knowledge and perception. Because linear thinking doesn’t bind the creative mind, we can rebel against rigidly enforced rules. My own family taught me that our current systems could punish the same qualities I most admire among the creative people closest to me. 

When my daughter was in her school’s advanced placement art class, her teacher warned that she would fail an assignment if she didn’t produce the required white-circle needlepoint project. This girl spent every night drawing her own creations but actively avoided doing the assigned task. Two days before the deadline, she ripped the back pocket off her jeans and spent most of the next 48 hours stitching a landscape on the panel, which was neither particularly white nor a circle. At back-to-school night, displayed against a sea of uniformity, her work was set apart from the rest, and I was very proud.

The world needs more people with the boldness to wield the creative force within them, even when our present systems undervalue that force. In our industry, artificial intelligence and data enable us to meet the demand to do more and do it better and faster. But, they are simply more efficient waiters rather than inventive chefs who are quick to experiment with all the elements at their disposal. In many respects, our systems are conditioning people to replicate what already exists. 

MARRY HEAT WITH FLAVOR

We need more chefs, but riding the creative edge is hard work that is dangerous to fixed perspectives. Chefs must deal with fire and knives to craft a dish that may not be a hit, but the upside to all that risk is creating something unique and potentially beautiful. Creatives who step into the kitchen can draw upon all their years of experience when looking at the available ingredients and working out what will make a delicious dish.

However, only some people can be the head chef of a creative project. Every kitchen has a head chef, a sous chef, and a pastry chef. A kitchen is a functioning team with clearly defined roles; each member focuses on their respective expertise and specialties. 

Our philosophy is that the individual who owns the brief owns the problem and, therefore, owns the solution. We have an executive creative officer for every assignment who brings in experience designers, brand identity experts, producers, and copywriters. Our head chef may conceptualize the menu and set the direction, but the whole process is collaborative—made even better when the creative exchange involves the client.

BEHIND THE PASS WITH CLIENTS

We do our best work when clients are willing to get among the fire and knives of the creative kitchen to work with a small team, customizing dishes to their taste. One of our kitchens is a makeshift wall on which we hang work ideas to inspire creative thought across the group and, ideally, have clients participate.

When we rebranded Coors Light to appeal to younger generations of beer drinkers, the Molson Coors chief marketing officer would come to the agency to “walk the wall”—or actively observe our creative progress—every day after her own shift had finished. She would point out what she liked and didn’t like, note which tangents led to provocative thoughts, and, importantly, kill things she felt led nowhere. 

Clients willing to roll up their sleeves can offer different perspectives that are essential to forming new connections. Unfortunately, more and more clients prefer to order from the safety of the dining room or, in the worst case, while waiting for another tired poultry dish. And unfortunately, many agencies operate as waiters, recreating the same tired recipes. Creative industries need chefs—innovators who are courageous enough to take risks by inventing new flavor profiles. 

DEVELOP AN APPETITE FOR THE NEW

There will always come a time to do the heads-down work of executing a concept, but donning the chef whites is a worldview requiring agencies and their staff to make themselves available in the creative process. Clients also benefit from bearing the innovative heat of working in a live kitchen—the more time they spend with us behind the pots and pans, the better the work.

Just as creative industries need more chefs and fewer waiters, the same might be said about our institutions, which can produce creative exiles left to thrive after they leave the system.


Andrew Swinand is the CEO of the Creative Group across all Publicis agencies, as well as the CEO of Leo Burnett.