Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

The mindset shift you need to make great leadership decisions

Paradoxes often appear to compete, but we should actually view them as interdependent.

[Images: Beholder/Adobe Stock0

Profile photo of Dylan Taylor

Chairman & CEO · Voyager Space

Friction still disorients us. It’s a force that opposes, yet is essential to, motion. It’s a resistance that creates beauty in diamonds, music, and fire. And it’s a form of conflict that leads to innovation.

Friction permeates our world, yet it’s something we seek to avoid. Friction represents a paradox, and people often respond poorly to paradoxes. Yet the authors of a thought-provoking new book encourage us to embrace friction and paradox. Why?

“Ignoring paradoxes will only cause them to come back stronger,” wrote Wendy K. Smith and Marianne W. Lewis. “A better approach, we think, is to effectively engage them.”

Smith and Lewis, management professors and paradox experts, explore this territory in “Both/And Thinking: Embracing Creative Tension to Solve Your Toughest Problems.”

They distilled 25 years of research regarding strategic and organizational paradoxes into a book offering alternate decision-making approaches. 

People constantly face paradoxes: balancing work and life, meeting our needs while serving others, and working today while planning for tomorrow. These paradoxes often appear to compete. But Smith and Lewis theorize that we should view them as interdependent. 

Paradoxes create pressure, which causes anxiety, which drives decision-making. In response, we tend to take a binary approach, making “either/or” decisions as though right and wrong are clear. But what if we took a more holistic view? Instead of choosing between two alternatives, we could incorporate both halves of the paradox and chart a new course.

Visionary leaders have embraced this “both/and” model for decades. Smith and Lewis detail success stories at IBM, Unilever, and NASA in which leaders embraced paradoxes rather than avoiding them. They sought tension, accepted conflict, and ultimately arrived at new solutions.

How did they achieve that? And how should leaders employ a paradox mindset? Smith and Lewis offered some suggestions.

PURSUE TENSION

Leaders who possess a paradoxical mindset don’t wait for tension. They attack it, believing they “can gain increased creativity through navigating these paradoxes,” Smith and Lewis wrote in the Harvard Business Review.

Tension is natural, healthy, and even a constructive friction from which everyone can benefit. First, though, they must understand the concept of strategic paradoxes.

According to Smith and Lewis, strategic paradoxes are essentially unresolvable dilemmas. Leaders face them constantly. Should the company innovate or maintain its core business? Should it develop new products or satisfy customers of legacy products? Should it expand globally or continue to serve locally? 

Too often, leaders draft “either/or” decisions from these tensions. Instead, Smith and Lewis suggest leaders should reframe the questions through a “both/and” mindset. How can the company innovate and maintain its core? How can it expand and serve current customers?

Tension should drive change. Who taught us better than George Costanza? In a classic Seinfeld episode, Costanza acted opposite his every instinct. Instead of shrinking from tension, he charged at it. And after berating the owner of the New York Yankees during a job interview, he was hired.

EMBRACE CONFLICT 

Part of pursuing tension is learning to embrace it. Strategic paradoxes generate competing forces of ambiguity and uncertainty. People reflexively respond by withdrawing from those tensions to remain consistent. Frequently, that’s the wrong approach. Coaches make for good listening in this venue.

Are you familiar with the phrase, “Get comfortable being uncomfortable”? Coaches love it. James Franklin, the head football coach at Penn State University, went viral in 2018 upon delivering that message after a bitter defeat.

Franklin’s team had just lost to Ohio State by one point for the second straight year, and he had seen enough. In a post-game press conference, Franklin spent 10 minutes detailing how the football team would recommit itself to taking the challenging next step from great to elite.

“We have gotten comfortable being great,” Franklin said. “We will no longer be comfortable being great.”

Smith and Lewis write that paradoxical leadership requires leaders to uproot their assumptions. “Well-intentioned consistency” begets complacency. Instead, leaders should be consistently inconsistent—a state that breeds fresh thinking. Leaders who view their resources (time, money, and people) as limited might adjust their lens to see them as abundant. How? “Rather than seeking to slice the pie thinner, people with this value-creating mindset pursue strategies to grow the pie,” Smith and Lewis advised.

Every strong leader will choose discomfort over complacency every time.

TAKE YOUR PARADOX MINDSET INVENTORY

How well-developed is your paradox mindset? In other words, how fast can you work while avoiding mistakes? How comfortable are you employing current skills and learning new ones? How do you innovate while adhering to the rules?

This might seem difficult to quantify, but Smith and Lewis have devised a survey to assess your paradox mindset inventory. The questions, which people grade on an agree/disagree scale, explore different types of tensions and how we experience them. Here’s a sampling:

  • I sometimes hold two ideas in mind that seem contradictory when appearing together.
  • When I consider conflicting perspectives, I understand the issue better.
  • I feel uplifted when I realize that two opposites can be true.
  • I need to be original while conforming to existing norms.
  • I need to focus on my own needs while addressing the needs of others.

Leaders who understand their base paradox mindset equip themselves to develop it further, which is vital to managing the modern workforce. Today, ESG (environmental, social, and governmental) initiatives ask leaders to run profitable and responsible companies.

That doesn’t have to be an “either/or” quest. Leaders can make better decisions by embracing the friction, the paradox, and a “both/and” approach. In turn, they can make purpose and profit interdependent. 


Dylan Taylor is the Chairman & CEO of Voyager Space Holdings.