The modern world surrounds us with branding. A seemingly endless amount of advertising floods our daily lives—from TV, radio and online advertisements to the logos on the clothes we wear. Branding is truly omnipresent.
This led me to think about when branding works and when it doesn’t. I flashed back to a long time ago, during my TV career as an assignment editor at a news station in Toledo, WTOL. Our channel had a news helicopter, which was a big deal in those days, and we were the only station in the market with our own chopper.
Because we had the “advantage” of our helicopter, we contrived ways to use it and feature it as part of the station’s brand. In order to get value from their investment—in a sleepy market with little use for a news helicopter—station management would cook up scenarios for using it as a way to gin up viewer enthusiasm.
BUZZING GREATER TOLEDO
The corniest implementation of this strategy was “Friday Night Flights,” which were segments where they would buzz Toledo and its far-flung suburbs, like Fostoria and Cedar Point, with this dumb news chopper. However, one Friday the chopper couldn’t fly because it may have been cloudy or there may have been a technical issue with the aircraft itself.
Whatever the case, I took the helicopter segment out of my nightly shown “rundown,” which is essentially the agenda of a given news broadcast. But upon seeing that I had removed Friday Night Flights from the show, my executive producer asserted himself, saying that it was Friday night—and that Friday Night Flights were mandatory! I was told that in lieu of an actual flight, we should obtain some b-roll and area maps and have a reporter “front” it from the satellite center.
I told the producer that I thought this was the stupidest thing I’d ever heard of. His retort was, “What’s stupider is not branding our big advantage.” My comeback was, “What’s stupid is what’s stupid. And this is the epitome of stupid.” And I remain convinced of this today!
WHAT MAKES SENSE?
The good news is that despite the turkeys in branding—like mandatory helicopter night—there are more than a few good examples that we can look to. Effective, visible branding helps introduce the public to a company, what it does, and the benefits it brings to B2B audiences and consumers.
One of the keys of branding is repetition, and the concept of title sponsorships—from the Vans Warped tour to the FedexCup PGA golf tour—means that your company’s name is mentioned regularly and often in any promotion or news around these events.
Similarly, branding sponsorships of stadiums and arenas have become an established tactic. In the Bay Area alone, we have SAP Center, Oracle Park and Chase Center. In addition to exclusivity and “ownership” of a venue, which enables the delivery of immersive brand experiences, these facility-naming sponsorships help marketers to both amplify and control their message and, ultimately, reach a huge number of people. When a sportscast begins with “Tonight at Chase Center…” we know that the company is getting valuable mentions in exchange for its investment and is simultaneously building community.
Motorsports branding has also really landed over the years—and in some cases the brand is more recognizable than the car. The detergent brand Tide broke through in the 80s by sponsoring Darrell Waltrip, one of the first linkups between racing teams and big consumer brands. And over 30 years later, the “Tide Chevy” is shorthand for a beloved driver and brand. Even today, ask a NASCAR fan who drives the “M&M’s car” or the “Monster Energy car” and you’ll get an educated answer that shows the indelible link that is created when a company goes all-in on a solid branding integration with a sport that people love.
WHEN BRANDING BACKFIRES
Of course, naming rights and sponsorships of this type can backfire on brands and individuals. Clangers like “Guaranteed Rate Field” don’t exactly roll off the tongue. In many cases, high-visibility sponsorships have been used to promote dubious products and services.
Take, for example, cigarette advertising. It has all but disappeared from most areas of public view, but there is a well-documented history of celebrity endorsers for tobacco. Even as recently as 2019, tobacco companies were attempting to skirt the EU’s original advertising ban made effective in 2006.
Take the Sackler family’s underwriting of a wing of New York’s Metropolitan Museum of Art as an example—their family’s branding was quietly removed as a result of the family’s longstanding ownership of Purdue Pharma, a company known for criminal charges around their sale of opioids.
Even more recent has been the crypto meltdown and the bankruptcy of one of its biggest players, FTX. One would have to be living in a cave to not be aware of the legal troubles that the company has found itself in, and its high-visibility sponsorship deals have crashed to earth along with the company’s valuation.
FLY YOUR OWN PATH
Getting back to the helicopter episode, I can’t remember if we went forward with the dumb helicopter segment that night or not. And I certainly don’t know what happened to that producer, because I left Toledo not long after that and went on to better things. But I’m assuming he stayed behind to make my colleagues suffer, as I went on to PR.
Most importantly, I do know that the incident left me with a career-long understanding that dumb branding exercises—done for their own sake—aren’t worth anyone’s time and effort. My guidance is to look at sponsorships and branding as extensions of your company’s vision, mission and message and to work with industry professionals who understand how to extract both visibility and value from branding investments.
Curtis Sparrer is a principal of Bospar PR. Business Insider has twice listed him as one of the Top Fifty in Tech PR.