Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Healthy workplace cultures begin or end with leadership

Success in constructive leadership breeds organizational success.

Female leader

[Images: Studio Romantic/Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Yumi Clevenger-Lee

Global CMO · Quest Global

Imagine sales are down and under forecast. In one scenario, the CEO charges in, yells at the executive team, and then drills the head of sales with detailed questions to expose incompetence. In another scenario, the CEO arrives early to the meeting and goes straight to the sales leader who missed their target and gives them a pat on the back. The CEO tells their head of sales, “I know you’re aware of your performance this month and are already beating yourself up, so I’m not going to pile on. I believe in you. What actions are you considering? How can I help you?” 

The difference in how these CEOs choose to lead impacts how the next-level leaders respond and how they will, in turn, motivate their teams to rally. Success in constructive leadership breeds organizational success.

When people leaders repeatedly show aggression, the impact of their behavior is magnified across the organization. Aggressive leaders often breed combative teams or passive teams that accept being told what to do. In both cases, the opportunity for sustained high performance, collaboration, and innovation for the future diminishes. The alternative is constructive leadership—leaders who are emotionally level, supportive, and encouraging. These leaders foster teams that consistently deliver results.

If we as leaders want people to perform at their potential, we must create an environment where people have psychological safety, and we must reject behaviors that will trigger aggression or fear. That starts with a shift in how we help our teams overcome barriers.

SHIFT FROM PUSHING TO PULLING

Early in my career, when I was a new manager, I tried to come up with all the answers myself. If we had a packaging issue, I tried to present a solution and give exact directions for how the team should execute. But I didn’t actually know the answer. I’m not a package design engineer. 

I had a misconception about my role as a leader and thought it meant I had to have the answers and instruct others on their next steps. But with experience, I learned that my true role as a leader is to listen intently, ask the right questions, encourage autonomy, and support each of my team members to take ownership and solve their problems efficiently and effectively. Showing up as a coach and asking the right questions at the right time is an art. Putting on my “coaching hat,” I’d ask reflective questions, such as:

• What is the root problem you are trying to solve? 

• Why do you think this is happening?

• Who can help solve the problem? What do you think will happen if you try option A or B? Have you thought about C?

• What can we all learn from this situation?

I learned that by shifting my role, I could empower and enable teams of incredibly talented and ambitious people to come up with better solutions—I could gradually pull those answers out of them instead of pushing them toward the answers I thought we needed. I found that my teams were thriving, learning, experimenting more, and above all—consistently delivering superior results. Better results happen when we work to everyone’s strengths.  

RESULTS SHOULDN’T BE MORE IMPORTANT THAN HOW THEY’RE ACHIEVED

A healthy culture measures both the what and how when it comes to performance results. In my career, I have seen many instances of managers who are praised by senior leaders for getting results but are notoriously terrible people leaders. This simple incongruence between performance results and how they were achieved is the most important signal employees feel when they see their company culture in action. It is not enough to measure leaders on performance results alone—we must also dive into how leaders are getting there.

I once worked with an operations leader who was amazing at his job. We had an abundance of supply chain issues, and he could fix any problem and keep our factories performing above targets. But during performance reviews, we got the same feedback on him every year: “He’s so hard on people.”

When I began coaching him, I learned the problem was a lack of self-awareness—the organization failed to give him the right coaching. He had good intentions, consistently delivered results, and was rewarded with the highest performance ratings, but he didn’t know that people operated in fear around him. Not to mention the fact that he was exhausted. He was always in the grind because he thought he was responsible for pounding the work out and pushing his teams to deliver—at all costs. 

We had many conversations about transitioning from an aggressive leadership model to a constructive approach. Instead of expressing his frustrations and micromanaging his teams, he started asking questions like, “Why do you think this happened? How do you think you can solve the problem?” He learned how to create a different dynamic where people leaned in instead of leaning away because they feared being attacked or being wrong.

CONSTRUCTIVE LEADERSHIP IS NOT ABOUT BEING ‘SOFT’

In the fiercely competitive world of a for-profit business, numbers are important, performance is critical, and leaders are under a lot of pressure to achieve those results. I totally get it and am fiercely competitive myself. But the stress we feel to deliver the numbers is not necessarily helpful to the organizations we lead. Leaders have to compartmentalize that stress so we don’t translate that pressure in a paralyzing way to others. We should think, “How can I help eliminate barriers to unlock transformative ideas? How can I motivate my team despite numerous headwinds?”

When we build high-performing teams and unleash the potential and passion of our people by being constructive leaders, we not only deliver superior business results but also do so together with consistency and joy. Let’s face it, we spend a lot of time at work, so let’s make the work inspiring, energizing, and rewarding. Constructive leadership is not about being soft. It is a sharp leadership tool to consistently deliver business results.


Yumi Clevenger-Lee is the Global Chief Marketing Officer for Quest Global, an end-to-end product engineering services company.