The lack of regulation for meal kit companies poses an increased risk of food poisoning due to unsafe food temperatures and lack of traceability. Meal kit companies with e-commerce business models are not as regulated as traditional food manufacturers, causing growing concern among many food industry experts as high-profile cases become more frequent.
While consumers can arm themselves by asking questions about temperature control, ready-to-eat proteins, and allergen management, the real responsibility falls to the e-commerce companies distributing meal kits and the regulatory agencies that define and establish compliance standards that govern the behavior of said companies.
As e-commerce food businesses continue to operate while federal regulations catch up, companies should put in place a number of traceability capabilities to ensure consumer safety, prevent waste, and improve last-mile delivery.
NEED FOR BETTER FOOD SAFETY REGULATION
It’s unacceptable to have a lack of regulation in a vertical where consumer safety is not being properly prioritized. Unfortunately, the driver of proper regulatory guidance and enforcement is continued cases of consumer harm.
As direct-to-consumer (DTC) companies, meal delivery services are regulated by state and local governments rather than the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). Last year, the FDA and Center for Disease Control (CDC) signed an MOU with the intention of supporting state, tribal, local, and territorial levels of government with efforts for better transparency of food safety data collection. The recognition for better food safety collaboration at all levels is apparent, but the DTC companies are still a low priority for regulators.
ADDRESSING COSTS OF SAFETY AND COMPLIANCE INFRASTRUCTURE
Should responsibility for the food safety compliance of DTC companies fall primarily to federal control, or should accountability be tightened at the current government levels?
Regardless of the appropriate answer, any level of increased regulation will increase costs for DTC meal delivery services. Those costs will need to be considered in their business models moving forward as they invest in better compliance and safety infrastructure while maintaining an environment where profitability is achievable.
The aim of regulation should not be to build bureaucracy but to create compliance that keeps consumers safe and ultimately saves lives. Whether greater regulation comes in the preparation, transportation, or delivery of meals, the objective should be to create a compliance culture that takes the threat of foodborne illness seriously and builds mechanisms for speed in traceability and corrective action.
For meal delivery services specifically, consideration must be made for the feasibility of low-cost sensors or data loggers that record and communicate critical food safety measurements for temperature and humidity. Right now, even the most cost-efficient Bluetooth sensors are prohibitive for one-time use. Meal delivery companies could potentially learn something from the old Netflix DVD model, where end users had to mail back the DVD after watching it or pay a sizeable fee. Could we see a company implement something like this with reusable ice packs or low-cost sensing capabilities? Currently, there’s not a sustainable business model for it. However, regulatory and consumer pressure could require a solution that leans on hardware reusability.
INNOVATION DRIVES THE MARKET
Driven by advancements around mobile ordering, at-home delivery, and pandemic-related obstacles, the food delivery space has been an exciting avenue for innovation. There is recent precedent for new ideas that could drive progress in the space, such as the development of a fleet of mobile restaurants that deliver right to your home. Whether it’s mobile ordering in an interface that’s enriched with personalization, third-party app integration that meets the consumer where they are online, or a chef-on-wheels that prepares custom meals right outside your home, the new ideas that are being explored and executed in the marketplace are raising consumers’ expectations for convenience and quality service.
Other verticals have shown a willingness to innovate around the delivery channels that modern times require. During the peak of the COVID-19 pandemic, pharmacy retailers executed vaccination events in parking lots that required new sensing capabilities for monitoring ice pack use in the outdoor administration of critical vaccinations. They found solutions that were fully compliant and NIST-certified to adhere to the increased regulations for vaccines. When the need presents itself, the right solution and accompanying compliance can come together to protect consumer and patient needs.
As governing bodies work to address gaps in regulation, responsible meal kit companies need to ask themselves what they can do now to mitigate risks of foodborne illness in their operations. We’ve seen numerous innovations in delivery. Now, we need to see that same level of innovation created and implemented for food safety. Compliance and innovation have costs, but when we’re talking about lives at stake, money isn’t the motive.
Guy Yehiav is President of SmartSense.