Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Why going small is the big move you should consider

Here are a few key reasons you may find yourself happier at a smaller agency.

Small team

[Images: Friends Stock/Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of amanda.yello@community.co

As the Kansas City Chiefs mounted their comeback against the Philadelphia Eagles in Super Bowl LVII, the camera panned to the celebrities in the crowd. Jay-Z, Elon Musk, and Bradley Cooper were all in attendance, taking in the back-and-forth battle. Also in attendance, though not in the spotlight, were several lucky ad executives, guests of large platforms and broadcasters who provide that perk as an attempt to create favorable relationships and remain top of mind for the large budgets those agencies control. 

I should know. In my decades-long career at a large agency, I attended multiple Super Bowls, even going on the field at one of them. Not a bad job if you can get it. 

The Big Agency experience provides a lot of perks and excitement. It’s one of the reasons I spent 26 years at a big holding company agency with over 80,000 employees. I loved my time at that agency (since I was there for more than ⅓ of the average lifespan of an American, I would have been a glutton for punishment if I thought otherwise!).  

But I’ve never been happier than when I joined NOVUS and the small-to-mid-sized agency world (~150 employees) over four years ago. Sure, we may not get invited to Super Bowls, but the benefits and the power of the work more than make up for it.

And I know I’m not alone. My colleagues—many of whom are also “converts”—often talk about the differences between large and small agencies. Here are a few key reasons we agree we are happier now than ever before. 

AN ENTREPRENEURIAL CULTURE

While entrepreneurism can happen in big agencies, everyone has been hired to perform a certain role. You can suggest something you think can be improved outside of your remit, but then the team responsible for it would likely decide whether to take it on or not. And I’ve seen good ideas die in committee or be dropped by the responsible team because of shifting priorities.

At a mid-sized agency like NOVUS, we get to actually implement the crazy and not-so-crazy ideas we suggest, and we’re expected to actually follow through. 

DEEPER CONNECTIONS

At a big agency, I worked on accounts with people I’ve never met in person. At many small agencies, it’s not uncommon to have met every person in the company in person multiple times. We’re relatively big for a small agency, yet every employee recently came to our corporate retreat in Minneapolis. Junior Planners regularly hit me up for a quick Zoom call, or think nothing of asking our senior leaders for advice, be it for work or something personal. Forging connections with the people you work with is worth its weight in gold.

BETTER MENTORSHIP

I’ve always enjoyed working with junior staffers, but you have fewer interactions with them in a large hierarchical structure. I’d wager that nearly every employee at our agency (and other small agencies like ours) has had significant facetime with our CEO in small group settings. They definitely have more facetime with their direct supervisor and that supervisor’s boss(es). This leads to more opportunities to absorb leadership lessons and demonstrate their skills to move up the agency ladder.

MORE ORGANIC CULTURE

I know of several big agencies that have created an impressive and lasting culture despite their size. But ultimately, it’s harder to maintain that culture with thousands of people, and it’s exceedingly difficult to give junior people a seat at the table to affect it.

Small agency culture is more organic and, I’d argue, more meaningful. At large agencies, culture is established and dictated by the top and studied through questionnaires. At smaller agencies, everyone lives and influences the culture, and it’s easier to adjust if it’s not working as it should. 

MORE EXPOSURE TO IMPORTANT MOMENTS

Almost every big agency has a dedicated new business team to handle pitches. While the executive who will be the senior lead on the account is usually included in those pitches, the junior staffers almost always fail to make the cut. Other important moments, like difficult conversations with clients and opportunities to upsell, also fall to the senior-most people. At Novus and at other small agencies, everyone who works there long enough will likely participate in more pitches and take part in more career-enriching moments than at larger agencies.  

ABILITY TO WORK WITH ANYONE

Large agencies may beg to differ, but I know from experience: there’s a tendency to work within the network or with established partners when you need external help.

I love that we can tap into any resource we want as a smaller agency. There’s no pressure to work with the holding company’s preferred partners or in-network sister agencies (because there is no holding company and no sister agencies!). We can partner with any agency, consultant, or whoever else will help us solve our clients’ biggest challenges.

And, maybe the best feeling of all: winning business can feel like a David versus Goliath situation. Every time we win a big account, we’re reminded that you don’t necessarily need a huge team to demonstrate value to your prospects—just a tight-knit one with great ideas and execution.

Small agencies aren’t for everyone, but they’re magic for the right people. You can really make a difference across multiple aspects of the business, build meaningful relationships with everyone in the organization, and work with a variety of excellent partners. If you’ve spent your career in larger agencies and above sounds like a fun challenge, maybe it’s time to leap. I know I’m glad I did. 


Rob Davis, President & Chief Marketing Officer at NOVUS.