Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Google Analytics 4: How brands can prepare for this complex and potentially disruptive change

Google is framing the shift to Google Analytics 4 as a simple migration. In all actuality, it’s a complex and potentially disruptive transition, and brands should be prepared.

Woman on a laptop

[Images: PaeGAG/Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Rio Longacre

Managing Director · Slalom Consulting

It is not hyperbole to state digital advertising is being disrupted. Global privacy statutes, mixed with platform-level changes by tech firms, are making it much more difficult for brands to engage with prospects and customers online.

Though generating less publicity, Google has begun implementing its new analytics platform, Google Analytics 4, and with it, the sunsetting of Universal Analytics. For many organizations, switching to GA4 could be extremely disruptive—certainly more so, in my opinion, than Google is letting on.

Despite what Google says, it’s not necessarily an easy switch. “To put it mildly, GA4 is making people nervous,” states Databox. Marketers may be fretting because, while many brands are talking about transitioning UA to GA4 as a migration, this is not the case with GA4, which is like implementing an entirely new system from scratch.

Given this reality, brands should immediately start taking stock of their overall web and digital analytics strategy. The stakes are high, and the timeline is tight. I believe what’s in play is nothing less than close to 90% of all web traffic globally.

PRIVACY AND BIG TECH

Being a digital marketer has never been easy, but it’s gotten significantly more challenging as marketers adapt to the vicissitudes of the digital ecosystem. One major change has been the introduction of sweeping new privacy laws globally, rolled out in response to growing public anger with and distrust of Big Tech.

In response, major tech companies are rolling out critical platform updates. First among these changes is the deprecation of third-party cookies on Google Chrome, the world’s most popular browser with 65% market share. First-party cookies store information related to the site that placed the cookie, while third-party cookies track users as they browse across the internet.

While the date has shifted several times, Google announced its plans to deprecate third-party cookies by the middle of 2023. Third-party cookie deprecation is important because they drive a huge portion of digital ads—digital agency Epsilon estimates up to 80% of digital ads are served this way.

With the launch of iOS 14, Apple introduced App Tracking Transparency, which requires apps to request user permission to track a user or device. This enhancement allows users to decide if they want apps to track their data, targeting the Identifier for Advertisers—a tracker that marketers use to personalize across apps.

BAD ADS AND PLUMMETING ROAS

While cookies and IDFA may sound esoteric, the effects are real and far-reaching. Advertisers will no longer be able to use third-party data, which is meaningful because 80% rely on it to personalize content. Even so, investments in third-party data have continued to grow, and marketers continue to rely on it for retargeting.

Recent changes have seen addressability levels plunge to 30%, leaving most consumers “un-addressable,” according to AdWeek. Addressability refers to the ability to target users with relevant, personalized content based on what is known about them. The result is a slew of bad ads: The New York Times published an article titled “Why Are You Seeing So Many Bad Digital Ads Now?” in early February. Bad ads mean poor conversion rates, which in turn depress return on ad spend, which means less value for every ad dollar spent. 

THE GA4 MIGRATION MYTH

Google is officially transitioning marketers to GA4. Starting on July 1, 2023 (July 1, 2024, for GA360), Google’s current web analytics platform, GA3, also known as Universal Analytics, will sunset. Starting on that date, Google will stop processing new hits to all UA properties.

Google thinks GA4 is a good idea, but I’ve found marketers are less sanguine. Reasons for this trepidation range from interface changes to dual tagging requirements, from lack of features and decreased functionality to the general lack of time to make the switch. 

GA4 is fundamentally different from UA because it uses an event-based model rather than a page and session-based one. Every action is tracked as a distinct event, and this model is more akin to what many consider product analytics, rather than web analytics. Web analytics provide deeper analysis of how users behave and interact with a business versus which pages they viewed within a session.

Google Analytics currently enjoys an extremely dominant market share with 86.1% market penetration. Forcing millions to change their analytics platform is risky, but Google obviously thinks it’s worth it. Considering there are mature product analytics solutions out there, I believe it is likely Google loses market share.

FUTURE-PROOFING MARKETING

While the end of UA may seem daunting, it can also be seen as a push to support data privacy and the shift from third-party data, not to mention an opportunity to refresh organizational data strategy to support business goals. 

The fact is, many brands have built data stacks incrementally and leverage disconnected or duplicative systems. For this reason, many brands are exploring customer data platforms and data clean rooms to future-proof their organizations. According to Insider Intelligence, 37% of media owners and agencies are increasing their investment in data clean rooms this year.

TIPS FOR RETHINKING YOUR FIRST-PARTY DATA AND PRIVACY STRATEGIES

1.Evaluate and potentially rethink your organization’s first-party data strategy to assess readiness for a cookieless, privacy-first world.

2. Assess MarTech/AdTech tech tools and solutions used by your organization for data collection and maintenance. Are they the right ones? Is anything missing?

3. Evaluate whether GA4 best meets your future needs. Are there other product analytics solutions (I’ve worked with Amplitude, Pendo, and Mixpanel) that may be a better fit?

4. Consider implementing a data clean room (one I work with is AWS Clean Room) solution to safeguard customer data while unlocking advanced marketing and product use cases in a privacy-compliant environment.

This shift is an opportunity for brands to rethink their first-party data and privacy strategies. These are two important topics that should be explored urgently considering the broad changes in the digital world today.


Rio Longacre is a Managing Director at Slalom Consulting and has two decades of experience in the digital trenches.