Much has been said about the impact of the Great Resignation on the hourly workforce, but hourly workers are not the only ones leaving behind jobs where they are overworked and undervalued. Executive leaders are jumping ship, too—a whopping 70% say they are considering quitting their jobs.
As a headhunter, I’ve seen this firsthand. Company after company has approached me seeking to fill leadership roles. But finding talent is increasingly harder.
Executives are not necessarily leaving for new jobs with higher paychecks—many have decided to ditch their 60-hour work weeks entirely. So if we can no longer retain top talent with higher salaries, what can we do to get them to stay?
JUMPING OFF THE HAMSTER WHEEL
Traditionally, executives receive top dollar in exchange for near-total dedication to their jobs. Many have spent their entire careers on the proverbial hamster wheel, running faster and faster until they burn out.
The COVID-19 pandemic caused many of these hard-working executives to slow down for the first time in decades. They had the space to re-evaluate their priorities, asking, “What have I missed out on all these years?”
After making a six- to seven-figure salary for a decade or more, executives realized they don’t have to keep working to be financially secure. This was their chance to get off the hamster wheel for good. Many left their jobs to spend more time with their families, pursue hobbies, or take long-awaited vacations.
Executives aren’t willing to return to business as usual if they don’t have to. If we want to find employees with the talent to lead our companies, we need to provide better options than “work yourself into the ground or leave.”
VALUE GOES BEYOND DOLLAR SIGNS
Picture this: An executive comes to you with a request. This person has been with the company for years and consistently drives excellent results. But they’re also caring for an elderly parent who needs to go to doctors’ appointments on Mondays. The employee asks if it’s possible to move the standing Monday meeting to Tuesday so they can be there for their mother.
An employer could take a hard-line stance: we pay you the big bucks, so why can’t you hire someone else to care of your mother? Maybe this saves the employer a scheduling headache, but denying the employee’s request tells them their needs are irrelevant. The employee will feel unheard and devalued, and they will likely start reconsidering those headhunters’ calls.
What if we said instead, “I hear you. We’ll see what we can do.” What if we became a solution for our executives instead of another problem?
In return, employers are rewarded with higher retention rates and a happier executive team, which makes it easier to attract new talent. People don’t become leaders without networking, so your current team can provide some of the best referrals to fill open positions—but only if those team members are willing to encourage others to join them at your company.
Value goes beyond money. Today, offering a competitive salary is no longer enough—and that should be considered a good thing. The value that executives are finding in a more flexible workplace also means that it’s easier for companies to attract top talent without having to pay exorbitant salaries. Executives who are getting burnt out can be lured from their current roles with the promise of flexible schedules, remote work options, and the promise of a healthy work-life balance.
LEAD WITH HUMILITY AND AN OPEN MIND
If the exit interview is the first time we hear about an executive’s unmet needs, we’ve already missed the boat. We cannot wait until they have one foot out the door to convince employees to stay. Instead of the exit interview, check in with them before the milk turns sour.
In our business, we call these conversations “stay interviews.” We ask our employees, “How are you doing at our company?” And “What do you need more of to feel supported?” If our team members are less than content, we are given the chance to address their needs before it becomes a bigger problem.
We cannot go into these meetings with ulterior motives or pre-determined outcomes in mind. We have to start the conversation with humility. Approach the conversation, not with the intention to change someone else’s mind, but to change your mind and to better support your employees.
Drop your defenses and try not to respond with “can’t” or “yes, but…” statements. If you don’t have an immediate solution, tell the leader that you will see what is reasonably possible. And remember that these check-ins are not a one-and-done deal. Be sure to follow up after time has passed to ask for their feedback.
A NEW BUSINESS LANDSCAPE REQUIRES NEW WAYS OF THINKING
The world changed permanently in 2020, and if we are to be successful going forward, we have to reckon with the way our businesses changed. Instead of trying to return to business as usual, leaders should consider what’s next.
There is no one-size-fits-all in life or business, and we cannot impose our will on executives merely because our “way” is how we’ve always done it. Our kindergarten teachers touted the golden rule. But in business, the platinum rule may be more applicable: “treat others the way they want to be treated.”
This mindset will make openings at your company more enticing for prospective talent. Imagine an executive who’s starting to question whether the 60-hour work weeks are worth the burnout—if a headhunter reaches out to them with a reasonable schedule and remote work opportunities, they’ll be more likely to make the leap to your company. By being flexible, you’ll demonstrate that your company isn’t stuck in a bygone era of business, and that you value your leaders’ happiness. In a post-COVID landscape, an appreciation for your team’s individual needs may be the biggest advantage you have when attracting new talent.
Robert Newland is CEO of the executive search and talent optimization firm Newland Associates.