In recent years, the term “upskilling” has been bandied around a lot. While upskilling has always been a hot topic in the tech community, I saw many organizations double down on it during the pandemic. Quickly it became almost a mandate for tech companies to offer similar avenues for skill development in their employee value propositions. Our recent tech hiring survey shows that about 17% of recruiters and 15% of tech employees think upskilling is a must-have for better work culture.
For all the hype around them, tech L&D programs still exist in an opaque reality. Many organizations think they have perfected the process from initiation to course completion and certification, but they have yet to solve the problem of predictability and productivity. In my experience, it’s nearly impossible to pinpoint the exact ROI of upskilling and reskilling employees.
LOW COMPLETION RATES FOR L&D PROGRAMS
While there is not enough data from large organizations on the success rates of their L&D programs, reports suggest that completion rates can be as low as 5%-10%.
The first few days of learning a new technology are often the hardest. Anybody who has learned a new programming language or picked up a new technology can agree that the most painful part of the learning process is setting up the environment and committing your first piece of functional code.
In many organizations, upskilling happens almost osmotically. In the mid-1980s, researchers from North Carolina’s Center for Creative Leadership asked C-level leaders to reflect on the best development experiences in their lifetimes. Their research led to the 70:20:10 model, which postulates that 70% of growth is often an outcome of hands-on learning and application, 20% is from developmental relationships, and only 10% is from coursework and training.
Mandating developers to take courses without proper “application” often sees a dip in interest. No wonder then that only 21% of developers who took our survey feel that the learning modules provided by their companies are valuable to them. In contrast, 32% of developers say that they prefer dedicated coding practice platforms for upskilling and learning since the format is more hands-on. A focus on providing an environment that drives hands-on application can result in increased skill development.
ORG-LED UPSKILLING INITIATIVES OFTEN LACK A SOCIAL CONTRACT
Psychologist Albert Bandura theorized that humans are social creatures who learn their early behaviors, such as walking, eating, and talking, through imitation. The same is true in the workplace, too. Peer-to-peer learning can help in explaining and rationalizing ideas, and learning can be made more effective through collaboration and absorption.
Employee learning and growth in the office starts by building relationships. Software engineers early in their careers are often assigned mentors who can help them understand the business while working on and bettering their specific skill sets. There is an implicit social contract in the way colleagues and leaders work together to share expertise and knowledge. Startups and smaller teams can provide more lucrative upskilling opportunities because social learning through knowledge-sharing sessions often happens more organically in smaller teams.
Now, while some companies have started to recognize the value of peer-driven learning, many are still using age-old “training modules” to upskill and reskill their workforces. In my opinion, this kind of structured training does not foster collaboration or critical thinking and leaves little to no room for ideation and innovation.
This is not to say that structured learning formats have no use case at all. For instance, a leadership program such as an MBA program uses a structured curriculum for learning and it works well. Or, when someone from a non-tech background wishes to move to coding, they would need to take a pre-defined approach to reskilling themselves. However, in the context of upskilling and reskilling existing tech teams, the lack of social collaboration can make the programs seem insular and affect the end result.
THERE IS NO DEFINITE EFFICACY MEASUREMENT MECHANISM
Global tech giants have promised huge investments in employee upskilling programs recently. For a small tech company though, an investment in L&D should be corroborated with ROI and proof of efficacy.
Assuming your engineers have signed up and completed an org-driven L&D plan despite the above concerns, many organizations still do not have a foolproof way of measuring skill development. Especially during a downturn, businesses should understand the exact benefits of upskilling programs beyond employee engagement and retention.
An MIT Sloan report found that a soft-skills training program improved workplace productivity by 250%. However, a similar study does not exist for the kind of specialized learning that tech teams require. Measuring the impact on an organization’s KPIs without the right tools and framework could take too long and produce vague results. Due to this lack of an objective method, organizations often resort to measuring course completions which is but a vanity metric.
LEARNING IS ESSENTIAL, BUT LEADERS NEED TO RELEARN HOW TO
As many tech leaders know, the only thing worse than training employees and having them leave is never training them and having them stay. I believe it is time for tech leaders to retire their old training and upskilling modules like the whiteboard for tech assessments. Learning and development should be more than an org-mandate that requires software engineers to finish X training schedules and gain a certificate. It should be an application-driven process led by tech leaders that integrates real-life work problems and skill training with concrete and realistic business goals.
A developer at heart who believes in the skill-first approach to hiring, Sachin Gupta is the CEO and Founder of HackerEarth.