In Star Trek: The Original Series, Captain Kirk is often heard asking his chief engineer to give him more from the Enterprise—More speed! More power to the shields!—and Scotty typically gives him some version of, “I’m giving you everything she’s got!” Do you ever feel like you are frequently asked to do more with less? If so, then chances are high that you are going through some form of cost optimization at your company.
If it’s your first round of cost rationalization, then it’s likely there will be some low-hanging fruit. On the people side, things like reducing employee perks (e.g., travel for conferences), pausing salary increases, early retirement packages, and freezing hiring for vacant positions are common levers used by organizations. Another popular lever is renegotiating supplier contracts.
These are all fairly quick wins but typically don’t get to more than 5%-10% of cost reduction. Even when going through the first round, you should be thinking about strategic choices versus across-the-board cuts. One common approach is to divide the corporate targets equally among departments (straight red line), but without thinking through the strategic priorities, you may make cuts to employees who are supporting essential capabilities only to have to rehire them a few months down the road or hire contractors to fill the gap in the short term, which is often more expensive in the long run.
Many cost rationalization opportunities are near-term options focused on improving operational excellence. Longer-term opportunities focus on structural changes related to the delivery of capabilities or strategic choices on your portfolio of products.
OPERATIONAL EXCELLENCE OPTIONS
To achieve cost reduction targets of 20% or higher, more strategic and thoughtful tradeoffs need to be made. You may have started renegotiating with suppliers, but to get better cost savings, consider revising the contract type or consolidating contracts. I recently worked with a client on a merger where the organization used integration as a trigger to renegotiate contracts (e.g., an increase in the volume of services via consolidation, so net a deeper discount) which exceeded the expected synergy target by 25%.
From a human capital perspective, after pulling the initial levers for short-term savings, manage your workforce productivity and utilization. This is also the time to deal with underperformers, if you haven’t already been doing so. Many managers are reluctant to make these decisions, but if your performance management system does not provide the data to make these decisions easily, one way to restructure the department is to define the essential roles and have employees rehired into them.
Automation is another popular lever to reduce costs. However, this typically requires an upfront investment, which is often harder to justify depending on how capital is allocated. One example is to use a chatbot or self-service tools to answer routine questions from customers instead of call center agents.
Similar to automation, real estate consolidation is another lever that can be pulled. Post-pandemic, virtual options are possible for many non-essential or front-line staff. With virtual options, the real estate footprint can be reduced by consolidating offices or facilities. My manufacturing clients are considering and executing on consolidation of facilities to lower-cost locations globally.
STRUCTURAL AND PORTFOLIO OPTIONS
Structural options rely on modifying an organization’s operating model. This takes many forms—reducing organizational layers, outsourcing, and lower-cost delivery models.
From a human capital perspective, the consolidation of departments to reduce the layers of leadership and middle management is another area to examine. In addition to de-layering, consider lower-cost options for delivery—if you are in a business where outsourcing or offshore resources are options, these levers should be considered as well.
As you restructure your team, always keep the customer in mind. Will the changes you make impact your service level agreements (SLAs)? Headcount reductions have consequences on the amount of work that can be done. Step one is to reduce the non-essential work and make tradeoffs to stop work on non-priority projects to make the workload manageable for those who remain. Ultimately, if the cuts are too deep, SLAs will need to be renegotiated.
Capital investments are impacted by any cost reduction efforts. My clients in healthcare, oil and gas, and manufacturing often explore joint ventures or other partnerships with vendors or other organizations in their sector with a synergistic focus so they can jointly invest in new capabilities and benefit from the joint offering. Auto manufacturers Ford and VW invested in Argo AI to commercialize an automated driving system to benefit from economies of scale and shared investment costs. Though Argo AI shuttered in 2022, this is a common strategy organizations take to share capital costs.
Lastly, consider simplifying your portfolio of products. This is one of the most challenging levers to pull as it requires making trade-offs to rationalize your portfolio to a narrower, focused set of products and services.
In my experience, sustainable cost rationalization requires organizational alignment and commitment. Companies that reduce costs sustainably typically avoid across-the-board cuts and instead use a focused approach to structural changes and portfolio rationalization.
Krishna Kutty is Managing Partner & Co-Founder at Kuroshio Consulting, advising clients on strategy, transformations, and leadership.