Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

What the last six months have taught us about the future of retail

Both retailers and customers are changing quickly, aiming to adapt to a new normal in which low prices and convenience are more important than ever before.

Women working in retail

[Images: Adobe Stock/(JLco) Julia Amaral]

Profile photo of Adrien Nussenbaum

BY Adrien Nussenbaum

After three years shaken and reshaped by the COVID-19 pandemic, we can now say that the retail industry has returned to a sense of normalcy. The past six months offer a window into how consumers and brands have adjusted to the post-pandemic environment. Have customers fully returned to in-person shopping? How is inflation impacting overall sales numbers? Have these past seasons been a case of permanent transformation or just a blip on the radar?

Recent sales figures point to a series of new truths about retail trends and the way consumers are approaching holidays and traditional sales events. The National Retail Federation observed a 17 percent year-over-year increase in in-person shopping during Cyber Week (the five-day period from Thanksgiving through Cyber Monday), indicating a significant return to normalcy for brick-and-mortar retailers. This increase far outpaces online shopping, which only grew by 2% in comparison to 2021.

If you were to only look at those NRF statistics, you would think we’re headed on a path back to pre-pandemic shopping habits and levels. However, when we zoom out and look at statistics across in-person and online channels, we see a different picture entirely.

SHOPPERS NO LONGER DRIVEN BY MAJOR HOLIDAYS

We’ve been taught that the name “Black Friday” refers to retailers finally recording their profits in black ink on the day after Thanksgiving, following 11 months of operating at a loss and accounting in red ink. Whether it’s true or not, this legend points to the historical significance of the holiday shopping season as a make-or-break period for retailers. In a typical year, retail sales increase during the months of November and December as shoppers increase spending in advance of the holidays.

Surprisingly, this wasn’t the case in 2022. According to data from the U.S. Census Bureau, November and December were the two lowest months for retail sales during the second half of the year. Monthly retail sales peaked in October at $602.58 billion, but November ($595.82 billion) and December ($588.80 billion) both lagged behind the previous four months. While it remains to be seen how much the current cost-of-living crisis shaped spending, those figures should deliver a clear message to retailers—any month could be your most profitable, and any Friday could become your Black Friday. 

INFLATION SHAPES ONLINE SALES

The past three years have seen retailers adapt rapidly to the rise of online shopping, offering convenient services ranging from the well-known “buy online, pick up in store” (BOPIS) to its fast-growing sibling, “buy online, return in store” (BORIS); seamless third-party marketplace offerings online; and even innovative omnichannel experiences that bring online marketplace products to pop-ups where they’re prominently displayed in brick-and-mortar stores. Retailers are experimenting with new ways to keep customers loyal—whether online or in-store—and shoppers are responding with their own adjustments.

According to Salesforce’s recent Retail Holiday Insights report, the number of online orders returned by consumers increased by a massive 63% year over year. This spike points to a fascinating trend in online shopping: not only are consumers spending more of their time and money online, but they’re taking steps to make online shopping function more like an in-store experience. Shoppers may order multiple items or different sizes, try on several at home and then return the products that aren’t a good fit. This previously would have been a light customer service lift for brick-and-mortar employees; it’s much more resource-intensive for online retailers.

The past holiday season also saw well-known retailers take aim at their biggest digital competitor. Walmart, Target, and Kohl’s each outpaced Amazon in terms of customer attention on Black Friday, as ad tech company Captify found that consumers were most likely to conduct an online search for Black Friday discounts on these big-box retailers. Amazon’s dominant position in the e-commerce market may not be as well entrenched as it seems.

MARKETPLACES CONTINUE TO OUTPACE E-COMMERCE

While e-commerce as a whole lost momentum towards the end of 2022, some retailers stood out for their use of technology—and avoided becoming a casualty of the cost-of-living crisis. Enterprise marketplace platform Mirakl found that sales across customer marketplaces grew by 53% year-over-year globally during Cyber Week, compared to just 2% growth for overall e-commerce. This contributed to overall growth reaching 43% year-over-year on marketplaces in 2022 and follows two consecutive years during which marketplaces grew at double the growth rate of overall e-commerce. 

The last six months have shown that the retail industry remains in a period of transition. Both retailers and customers are changing quickly, aiming to adapt to a new normal in which low prices and convenience are more important than ever before. From marketplace momentum to year-round sales events to Amazon’s slipping grip on e-commerce, it’s clear that retailers of every size have opportunities to move into the fast lane and accelerate their growth. Retail leaders who are willing to keep their finger on the pulse of the market and get creative with sales and technology strategies will find that they can rise above a single sales event and drive success throughout the year.


Adrien Nussenbaum is the co-founder and CEO of Mirakl, a global leader in enterprise marketplace solutions.