Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

How your data can help indecisive customers commit

As the world gets used to a data-driven society, we’re finding an ever-growing number of nuanced applications for the endless information at our fingertips—including the resolution of one classic business conundrum: the indecisive customer.

Tech employees

[Images: Adobe Stock/Gorodenkoff]

Profile photo of Chalmers Brown

CTO & Co-Founder · Due

Data is sending rockets into space. It’s revolutionizing agriculture. It’s reshaping how we’re entertained. Everywhere you look, data (and the information that we glean from it) is transforming life as we know it.

As the world gets used to a data-driven society, we’re finding an ever-growing number of nuanced applications for the endless information at our fingertips—including the resolution of one classic business conundrum: the indecisive customer.

THE ISSUE OF INDECISIVE CUSTOMERS IN THE 21ST CENTURY

Humans are indecisive creatures—especially when we have too many options. And the sheer number and variety of options in practically every category of the market have never been greater than in the modern era. Technology and e-commerce, in particular, are giving consumers so many options it’s easy for a potential customer to hesitate when they want to make a purchase.

“Could I get a better deal elsewhere?” “Should I get faster shipping?” “Am I supporting local businesses?” These and other questions like them plague the modern consumer, creating analysis paralysis and generating indecisive customers in the process.

How bad is the problem? Let’s consider abandoned cart rates as an indicator of how often customers can’t commit, particularly in an online setting (i.e., with minimal customer support).

ABANDONED CARTS: THE CRUX OF THE PROBLEM

According to Statista, abandonment rates around the world were 88% in 2022. That means nearly nine out of every 10 customers put items in their carts only to click away from an e-commerce site before completing a purchase. Email marketing company Moosend puts the universal number closer to 69%. 

Either way, the sheer number of consumers who fail to commit to an online purchase should have every company looking for a way to remedy the issue.

Fortunately, there’s a tried and true solution in the form of abandoned cart emails. These are automated emails that trigger when someone leaves an e-cart filled with unpurchased goods.

Moosend adds that the average open rate for abandoned cart emails is an impressive 45%, with a CTR (clickthrough rate) of 21%, and a robust conversion rate of 10.7%. In other words, sending abandoned cart emails can have a powerful effect on consumers. It serves as a reminder (often accompanied by a coupon code or some other deal thrown into the mix) that gently encourages them to complete their purchase. This increases revenue and boosts a company’s bottom line with minimal effort.

The primary concern with abandoned cart emails, though, is getting the personal information required to send them in the first place. That’s where data comes into the picture.

ALIGNING DATA WITH YOUR CUSTOMER RETENTION STRATEGY

There are multiple ways to harvest data to set the stage for an effective abandoned cart strategy. 

For instance, an email signup form is a great way to link a user to their cart. This is particularly effective if you integrate an email platform into your e-commerce site so that they can share information.

Another option is to have customers create full-blown accounts in order to fill a cart. This immediately provides a detailed data bank for your company to use to track visitor cart activity. You can even use their additional account preferences to tailor any promotional elements you might include in a follow-up email.

Of course, for many businesses, the vast majority of shoppers are anonymous. When that’s the case, you can use what is referred to as “identity resolution software.” This type of software enables brands to gather first-party data from anonymous visitors, data that you can use to send abandoned cart messages after the fact.

USING DATA TO CONVERT CUSTOMERS

Whether it’s a membership login, email sign-up, or identity resolution software, there are multiple ways companies can fix the issue of abandoned carts. 

Of course, this is just one way to address the indecisive customer issue. There are others, such as providing easy on-site navigation and direct customer support during the customer journey.

But the number of abandoned carts across most e-commerce sites makes it public enemy number one when it comes to turning indecisive customers into paying patrons.

So, review your e-commerce site’s data. How many abandoned carts do you have? If it’s anything near the average, it’s the perfect starting point. Use the data-driven strategies above to start encouraging those hesitant visitors to become a satisfied part of your customer base.


Chalmers Brown is the Chief Technology Officer of Due.