Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

In-house agencies: A new model of advertising and marketing

Many brands are setting up in-house teams to do work traditionally performed by agencies, and a new model of advertising and marketing is emerging.

Team having a meeting

[Images: Adobe Stock/Prostock-studio]

Profile photo of Rio Longacre

Managing Director · Slalom Consulting

BY Rio Longacre

Many brands are setting up in-house teams to do work traditionally performed by agencies, and a new model of advertising and marketing is emerging. Given this new model’s potential cost savings—along with increased control of data and richer insights into performance—it’s no surprise adoption is surging.

MARKETING IN TURBULENCE 

Marketers face ongoing challenges tied to compliance with evolving data privacy regulations, inefficient marketing and advertising operations, and a digital ecosystem in flux. Business leaders are placing increased emphasis on customer intelligence, cost transparency, data governance, speed to market, and tech ownership.

Over the past year, a challenging macroeconomic environment coupled with the need for data-driven insights has been pressuring marketing leaders to ensure media investments are delivering impactful customer experiences and positive business gains. A recent study by the CMO Council recently found two in three marketing leaders are not confident in their current marketing and advertising program.

Given this paradigm, brands are pivoting how data, tech, and operations are structured into a collaborative model in which brands build internal teams to perform some activities historically handled by agencies—shifting the role of agencies and how they interact with brands while redefining capabilities supported by marketers. While agencies will continue to be critical players when it comes to advertising and marketing, a realignment is taking place.

IRRECONCILABLE DIFFERENCES

I became aware of agency in-housing several years ago when marketing clients began telling me they were struggling to get adequate value from agency partners. The agency model was showing its age.

One of the main drivers was a gradual deterioration of relationships between agencies and brands. Back in 2017, the Wall Street Journal reported some agencies were manipulating the RFI/RFP bidding process using phony “check bids” from other agencies so contracts could be awarded to their teams—an act that is unethical and illegal.

Many large media agencies have also failed to protect brands from pervasive ad fraud totaling $81 billion globally in 2022, which is predicted to increase to $100 billion this year. While ad fraud may be increasingly sophisticated and run by criminal syndicates (i.e., organized crime), pretending it doesn’t exist while collecting fees is, frankly, an unacceptable practice.

Nor are these problems isolated or unreported. K2 Intelligence, a company commissioned by the Association of National Advertisers (ANA) to investigate the advertising industry, reported shady business practices were “pervasive and systemic” across the industry.

OFF TO A SLOW START…

While the concept has been around for a while, agency in-housing has only become mainstream over the past couple of years. As recently as 2017, I pitched the concept to a friendly brand marketer. The pitch went well, or so I thought, with plenty of head nods, but when it ended, the client simply said: “We love our agency.”

This type of response was not uncommon at the time. Nothing against marketers, but many may be loath to admit they act as glorified vendor managers, rely on agency partners to do most if not all heavy lifting, and frankly, don’t do very much actual marketing. In other words, bringing marketing in-house may seem daunting because it requires being an actual marketer.

Today, by contrast, many big brands are taking the plunge. A recent study by the Association of National Advertisers, or ANA, reported that 82% of advertisers now have in-house agencies. AdAge reported last year that in-house agencies have grown 7% in size since 2019.

COMPETING MODELS

Two distinct models are emerging: in-house and hybrid in-house agencies. The in-house agency model builds out the entire digital marketing function within the brand, granting complete control of data, the ability to change tactics immediately, and a greater degree of confidence data is following privacy regulations.

In the hybrid in-house model, critical data is both owned and resides with the brand. The brand usually owns the AdTech accounts, media accounts, and data repository solutions, and has a small team that oversees agency activities with clearly defined outputs.

The hybrid in-house model is often more practical for organizations with small digital marketing teams that lack the digital resources and expertise to bring data in-house. Campaign infrastructure and accounts all live with the brand, while the agency runs campaigns as before, but across advertiser accounts.

In my experience, very few brands will in-house media buying, especially programmatic, which is a big reason the hybrid model is gaining the most traction. In most hybrid models, the agency has access to all necessary data, but it resides with the brand, while AdTech, Media, and platform accounts are also owned by the brand.

MODELS WITH BENEFITS

Regardless of the model, the most important benefit of in-housing is cost savings. A study by ANA revealed 38% of brands with in-house teams rate cost efficiencies as the main benefit, followed by brand knowledge, and nimbleness.

In my experience, brands can expect to see overall cost savings of around 15%. A recent initiative with a global pharma resulted in $11.8M in annualized media savings through data cost reductions and improved audience efficiencies.

Other benefits can also be realized. Here’s a quick list:

  • Tech/Data Ownership: MarTech/AdTech migrates in-house as first-party data ownership becomes critical in a privacy-first, cookieless world.
  • Cost Savings: Bringing platform contracts in-house reduces media markups, fees, and waste—media assessments usually uncover savings of 15%-25% of media budgets from underperformance spending, hidden fees, and markups.
  • Control: Transparency into media buying operations helps identify optimization opportunities, which can be implemented quicker and less expensively.
  • Insights: As we move to a cookieless world, greater ownership of data becomes paramount—in-housing activates first-party data more efficiently, leading to enhanced personalization and real-time insights.

Rio Longacre is a Managing Director at Slalom Consulting and has two decades of experience in the digital trenches.