In 1998, researchers Larry Page and Sergey Brin published a paper at Stanford entitled “The Anatomy of a Large-Scale Hypertextual Web Search Engine.” In the paper, they anticipated the rise of the gatekeeper algorithm: “The predominant business model for commercial search engines is advertising. The goals of the advertising business model do not always correspond to providing quality search to users.” Later that same year, inspired by this realization, the two would go on to found Google and implement the first user-centric search algorithm, PageRank.
PageRank revolutionized the early web by prioritizing pages according to the number and types of links on each page. What was previously a Wild West of disjointed webpages—Geocities homesteads, Wikipedia articles, and independent sites for any subculture you can imagine—became dramatically more organized and accessible. Disparate streets and villages merged into a metropolis with laudable public transit. But, in the process of gaining order, was something else lost?
Flash forward to today. Google is very much still around—and so is PageRank. But both have fallen victim to the sway of algorithm-as-business-driver and sacrificed quality in the process. And they’re not the only ones. The broader web landscape has strayed from its original promise: to enable us to be the best, most genuine version of ourselves. Instead, we’re trapped in a system that perpetuates sameness and discourages individuality, all at the hands of algorithms gone wild.
Algorithms have infiltrated the most critical elements of modern life, from music to dating to healthcare. It’s now impossible to go online without encountering content that claims it’s been curated “for you.” But these algorithms don’t recognize how complex, contradictory, and ever-changing human attitudes and tastes can be. Because of their overly simplistic calculations, we are rarely shown anything new, different, or exciting. Spotify listeners end up hearing the same songs and artists over and over, even when “shuffling.” Dating app users keep swiping on eerily similar people—sometimes even the same ones. And on the more insidious end of the spectrum, YouTube, Facebook, and TikTok lock us into political echo chambers that can result in attempts to undermine democracy.
Combine the pervasiveness of manipulative algorithms with the addictiveness of the platforms themselves and you have a dangerous cocktail, one that threatens to flatten each of our individual identities and tastes. That may seem dramatic, but the data validates just how influenced we are, whether we realize it or not.
Are our tastes really our own? Or is personal taste a modern myth?
WHAT DO WE RISK IF NOTHING CHANGES?
Algorithms flatten our tastes by pushing us all toward the same ideas and aesthetics while making it harder for free-thinkers and subcultures to rise up. But innovation requires those who are willing and able to break molds and go against the grain of algorithmic trend cycles. Societal innovation and advancement at large will stagnate without environments for new ideas to incubate and disseminate.
We already see this happening: despite the fact that the internet has made it easier for anyone to become a creator, only a handful of creators actually see traction. It’s why six of the 10 fiction best sellers in 2022 were from the same author. It’s why every single new movie is either a reboot, remake, requel, prequel, or sequel. And it’s why the outfits you see today’s Gen Zers touting as trendy look eerily similar to your early-aughts wardrobe. We’re stuck in a cycle of cultural regurgitation.
Will there be a reckoning, one that reverses our course? Or will we continue to witness the erosion of individual taste?
WHAT CAN BE DONE?
There’s hope to be had. For one, companies are wisening to the impacts of the algorithms they employ. In the past few months, TikTok, one of the latest and greatest offenders, announced an algorithmic reset tool, and Twitter revealed the logic and source code for its recommendation algorithm. Spotify also launched an “exclude from your taste profile” button on songs and playlists, giving users more control over their own music tastes. Power is (gradually) being returned to the people.
Young consumers are also actively reclaiming their tastes, rejecting social media altogether, tapping into more human sources for recommendations, and building platforms that reflect the kind of social connection they desire—curated by themselves and not by faceless math equations. Beyond that, the US Supreme Court is even evaluating the boundaries of content recommendation algorithms. The rehabilitation of personal taste is underway.
Undoubtedly, algorithms are here to stay. But if we hope to avert innovation stagnation, taste must be returned to its rightful owners. We all have a hand in making that happen.
Alain is Founder and CEO of SYLVAIN, a strategy and design consultancy that provokes progress for companies, people, and society at large.