Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

What do retailers want from the internet economy?

If we want to have a diverse e-commerce ecosystem to speak of in 25 years, retailers need to emphasize curation, improving the experience for every e-commerce participant.

Female retailer holding a tablet

[Images: Adobe Stock/loreanto]

Profile photo of Adrien Nussenbaum

BY Adrien Nussenbaum

In 1997, Amazon filed its initial public offering, turning the page on the first chapter of the company’s dramatic expansion into global e-commerce. From famously humble beginnings—who hasn’t seen the photo of Jeff Bezos working from his garage?—the company has grown to become an international e-commerce behemoth, the bully in the center of the ring. 

Amazon’s global marketplace connects third-party sellers to the world’s largest retail audience. While selling on Amazon is an incredible opportunity for businesses looking to grow, success isn’t guaranteed. The products and sellers that Amazon chooses to promote on the marketplace platform will inevitably survive; those that don’t are dead in the water. Meanwhile, for traditional retailers—those that aren’t selling on Amazon, but rather, competing with it—the behemoth’s sheer size and resources are impossible to match. This is the internet economy as it stands today: unlimited resources channeled by a privileged few, with legions of smaller businesses “lucky” to survive by participating in these mega-platforms.

The 25th anniversary of Amazon’s IPO gives us a good vantage point to see e-commerce as it stands today. We’re at a turning point: if a small number of digital giants are allowed to control the market, consumers will only have access to the brands and products that have been filtered by a company with its thumb on the scale. And if other retailers don’t adapt quickly, they will eventually disappear into an Amazon-owned world.

THE GOOD AND BAD OF AN E-COMMERCE GIANT

Amazon is an exceptional company. They reached their current position by rethinking the way businesses serve their customers, creating an entirely new set of shopper expectations. Amazon’s customer-first approach makes the traditional retail merchandising mindset—focusing on the business first and customers second—a non-starter. It recognized that the principles of success in retail are choice, price, and quality of service. 

Today, Amazon has all of the ingredients for a thriving customer-first business. Through their marketplace, they have access to the widest assortment of products from a global range of third-party sellers. Using enormous amounts of customer data, Amazon is able to serve customers the items they want, practically before they know they want them. Amazon can also lean on unparalleled economies of scale to deliver prices and shipping times that other companies simply can’t match.

But while Amazon’s approach delivers tangible benefits to customers in the short term, it represents a significant threat in the long term. Amazon’s algorithm rewards sellers that offer the lowest prices and pay fees to participate in Amazon’s fulfillment program. The result is bad for everyone except Amazon itself: small businesses can only take so much downward price pressure until they’re forced out of business. And as Amazon gains more control over the market, the customer experience becomes less of a priority. Why bother with low prices and fast shipping if you’re the only game in town?

WORKING TOGETHER FOR SURVIVAL

As a co-founder of a company that helps retailers build online marketplace platforms, I have a stake in the survival of retailers, and I also understand the tools and strategies that help companies remain competitive. For retailers to survive the next 25 years, they will need to work together and emphasize what makes them different from Amazon—while taking a page out of their playbook.

The fundamental difference between Amazon and its competitors is that Amazon itself isn’t a retail business—it’s a platform company. Retailers are incentivized to develop a brand identity, curate an assortment of products, and develop loyalty among customers. Platform companies are in the business of making connections between buyers and sellers—and letting those stakeholders do much of the work that retailers typically leave to internal teams like marketing and merchandising. Retailers’ survival will depend on their ability to think and operate more like platform companies while simultaneously maintaining their finely-honed identity.

When you take on one powerful enemy, you need a united front to be successful. A handful of retailers embracing platform strategies won’t change the tide—the scale of the competition is too great. More retailers must consider how platform technology can work for them in order to bring greater agility and scale by teaming up with third-party sellers. The trick is to do this without compromising on curation, presenting a united assortment that maintains the retailer’s overall brand identity. Amazon offers shoppers an entirely uncurated endless aisle, akin to a garage sale where shoppers must sift through page after page of product listings. With platform strategies, retailers can match the endless aisle experience, while providing the customer experience and product recommendations that will help them build and maintain loyalty. 

The opportunities for collaboration aren’t limited to e-commerce platforms. Stores can work together and engage last-mile delivery companies to match or even beat Amazon’s delivery times. Taking advantage of their existing network of physical stores, these businesses could outhustle and outmaneuver Amazon and its notorious warehouses. Containing Amazon will require a combination of technological innovation, business model transformation, and a new definition of what it means to be a competitor or partner among non-Amazon companies. 

THE FUTURE OF THE INTERNET ECONOMY

This is an existential moment for the vast majority of retailers. Amazon’s rise to prominence began as the company slowly killed off bookstores, outperforming everyone from the single-storefront shops to national chains with superior product selection, availability, and price. Amazon is now taking on today’s retailers with the same assets, as well as superior delivery, Amazon Prime as a tool for customer acquisition, and an astonishing amount of customer data to inform their offerings.

For retail, the status quo is starting to look like a self-inflicted death sentence. If we want to have a diverse e-commerce ecosystem to speak of in 25 years, retailers need to emphasize curation, improving the experience for every e-commerce participant. With an intelligent approach to platform technology and brand identity, retailers can achieve curation at scale and improve outcomes for their partners and customers. We know where e-commerce is heading, but retailers must make the choice to adapt and move in that direction.

This is the moment for retailers and customers alike to reconsider what we want from the internet economy. It may be our last chance.


Adrien Nussenbaum is the co-founder and CEO of Mirakl, a global leader in enterprise marketplace solutions.