When I talk to business owners about their goals and why they aren’t achieving their desired levels of growth, they often cite people as the biggest problem, and some blame HR for this failure to provide results. Their solution? Spend more money on sales, marketing, and the like. They spend more money on anything but HR.
This pattern emerges among companies of all sizes. Time and time again, CEOs invest the least money and resources into HR, leaving it at the bottom of the pile because it is not considered a revenue-producing department. Meanwhile, the challenges of HR become more demanding with growth. Leadership often tends to minimize the importance of HR, as if it will magically solve itself.
Growing companies should consider the three-layer cake of HR: risk mitigation, operations optimization, and talent strategy. Unless we set the proper foundation for growth and assemble our cake correctly, it might collapse.
LAYER 1: MITIGATING RISK
The first layer of the HR cake doesn’t directly grow your business, but risk mitigation offers a layer of protection needed to succeed. We see too many leaders justifying working in some legal gray areas “until we grow a little.” They think they know what they’re doing and the risks they are assuming—but the truth is, they don’t.
A common example is failing to secure the proper verification documentation that your staff can legally be employed in the United States. Civil penalties for violations of I-9 compliance range from $252 to $2,507 per form. Once, while advising an organization, I found that 20 of their 30 employees were being paid as contractors. Yet, after digging a little deeper, I realized they should have been paid as employees. Imagine the cost if exposed!
It’s estimated that 10% to 30% of employers misclassify their employees. Just because a company pays them as a contractor doesn’t mean they are. If the wage-and-hour department had audited that organization, it would have been liable for unpaid payroll taxes, back pay, and additional fines. The losses can run into the millions.
Risk mitigation also pertains to things like employee protection and sexual-harassment policies. Without these, you put the company in further jeopardy. In all these situations, playing fast and loose with risk is like speeding without auto and health insurance. Is it worth taking that chance for a few extra bucks?
We advise doing an HR audit—from record-keeping and recruitment to training and terminations. Finding out where you are at risk and taking corrective action will give our HR cake a stable base.
LAYER 2: OPERATIONS OPTIMIZATION
We all know the adage: time is money. With that in mind, let’s address operations optimization—ways to make HR function more efficiently and effectively. The first step is doing another audit, only this time, look for the tools that will maximize the value of how you spend your time.
Many organizations are understaffed for HR, and one study found that a shocking 98% of HR professionals felt burned out within the past six months. What happens, then? Performance management gets sacrificed because “it takes too long.” Nobody looks at compensation. “Too complicated.” Instead of hiring the best people, HR puts together an underqualified team because the recruitment process takes too long.
Another classic example is not creating a clear list of qualifications or screening questions for an employment ad because they’re too busy. Including pass-fail questions on basic criteria is vital. Otherwise, companies will get too many resumes and may interview a handful of underqualified candidates. At this point, leadership may even begin to rationalize why a candidate without enough experience could do the job of an accountant.
We also tend to hire based on skill but fire based on fit. It might be possible to prevent this by using validated behavioral assessments tailored to each position. Keep in mind, validation is essential. Companies sued for discrimination are more likely to be fined if they have used assessment tools that aren’t validated for selection.
Research shows that the use of validated assessments like The Predictive Index is linked to 33% higher revenue per employee and 59% less turnover. Now we are taking care of both the first two layers at the same time.
LAYER 3: TALENT STRATEGY
The final layer of the cake is talent strategy—essentially, a more sophisticated approach to getting employees to exert discretionary effort (engagement) and go above and beyond. Talent strategy involves culture, values, leadership styles, and coaching, which can help in creating an overall sense of belonging.
Often, we see organizations trying to drive employee engagement, but it doesn’t work because they have not equipped their HR team with the tools and resources to deal with the first two layers. The answer could be having more experienced HR teams or using fractional HR services or consultants to support your internal team.
However, people are often appointed to HR without fully understanding the role. The Administrative Assistant who becomes Office Manager and then HR Manager has likely never run recruitment or HR operations. The irony is that owners keep telling us that the biggest problem in their organization is people, yet they fail to invest in people management and training. We need to stop setting up HR teams for failure.
HAVE YOUR CAKE (AND EAT IT, TOO)
Marketing may bring you business leads, but if your hiring process is insufficient or staff leaves because supervisors can’t manage people, there’s no one to service the extra demand. Ignorance will not save you from failure.
Therefore, each layer of the cake must be managed individually for a strong and successful HR department. Only when you develop better HR habits can you perform talent strategy at a high level and complete the final layer of the cake. It may not be your birthday cake, but it will be the best gift you give yourself as a business owner.
Robert Newland is CEO of Newland Associates & HRfrenzy. He’s an expert consultant and public speaker on executive search and talent strategy