Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

A resilient workforce begins with an empathetic leader

Too often, empathy is conflated with sympathy and compassion, and the perception that expressing empathy burdens leaders to take on and solve the problems of employees.

Leader checking in with employees

[Images: Flamingo Images/Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Chris Shipley

Author · The Empathy Advantage

BY Chris Shipley

Productivity took the sharpest decline in the past five quarters than in any time in the previous 75 years. That is according to EY-Parthenon, the global strategy consulting arm of Ernst & Young. Predictably, fingers point, without evidence, to a range of causes: remote work, a lack of work ethic among the youngest (Gen Z) workers, and a workforce that’s “gone soft.”

There is, however, a more likely culprit: post-pandemic stress and burnout. The workforce is simply drained, exhausted by the uneven bargain that exchanges labor for diminishing reward. Indeed, something fundamental is shifting in the workplace. Having faced the existential crisis that was COVID-19, workers have reordered their lives to give priority to activities—work and leisure—that are enriching across many different vectors. These employees won’t be motivated by heavy-handed mandates or disingenuous platitudes. They are seeking authentic relationships that value and reward their contributions. 

This is a tremendous opportunity for leaders to unlock performance. As leaders, we have the choice to eschew management styles that no longer work and embrace a more human connection, weaving a web of empathy, autonomy, engagement, resilience, and performance. 

Empathy has become the management buzzword. Yet lost in the discussion is a clear understanding of just what empathy is and how empathy can drive performance, particularly as leaders help their teams navigate stress and combat burnout.

Too often, empathy is conflated with sympathy and compassion, and the perception that expressing empathy burdens leaders to take on and solve the problems of employees. To be empathetic, some believe, is to be overly nice, to lower expectations, and to demand and expect less. Although empathy, compassion, and sympathy are different things, they can collectively drive long-term performance. (This quick video from the Compassion Research Lab is an excellent description of the differences and connections among sympathy, empathy, and compassion.) Research at Cornell University and the University of Michigan found that compassionate workplaces that help workers process suffering see higher levels of engagement and commitment to the organization. 

Tapping empathy simply asks leaders to listen more deeply to understand and share the feelings of another person. Empathetic leaders see their employees as human beings with unique needs, experiences, and challenges. They take the time to listen, understand, and connect with their people on a deeper level. When leaders practice empathy, they create an environment of trust, collaboration, autonomy, and innovation, which ultimately leads to a more engaged workforce. Case in point, a study by Effectory found workers with autonomy are 79% more engaged than their nonautonomous peers.

When employees believe their leaders care about them as individuals, they are more likely to feel a sense of loyalty and commitment to their organization, which in turn can reduce turnover. “Employees who feel their employer cares about their wellbeing are 69% less likely to actively search for a job,” a Gallup report found.  Labor shortages will likely continue unabated for the next decade or longer, and there is no better defense in the battle for talent than reducing turnover—and that has a profound impact on business continuity and performance. Yet at exactly the time that leaders need to lean into empathy, they are pulling away from it. At the height of the pandemic, leaders generally expressed more care and concern for their employees, even as they worked remotely. Now, however, both trust in leadership and employee engagement are in decline.

Research has long shown that empathy is directly linked to improved performance. A study by the Center for Creative Leadership found that empathy is a critical component of effective leadership and that leaders who demonstrate high levels of empathy are more likely to have high-performing teams. That study is backed up by Harvard Business Review’s 2016 Empathy Index, highlighting the top most empathetic companies. According to this research, the top ten most empathetic companies outperformed the bottom ten by at least 50% in productivity, earnings, and growth. Yet even this clear evidence of the importance of empathy is not having the impact it should. The latest State of Empathy Workplace report found that “over the past eight years, our data has made it clear that empathy is critical to employee engagement, culture, and organizational success. But the data is showing us that, year over year, the empathy gap is only getting wider.”

Clearly, empathy is a force multiplier. A genuine connection between and among team members cultivates trust, the foundation for effective collaboration, candid communications, efficient decision making, and outstanding performance. Empathy gives everyone a seat at the table which can profoundly expand the knowledge, insight, and perspectives to make better informed and inclusive decisions. Empathy is a steady force in an uncertain world by leveling a sense of shared understanding and shared sacrifice.

Empathy is not, however, an invitation to lowered expectations, the worry of too many leaders who fear that “being nice” to employees means settling for lesser results. Empathy doesn’t let people off the hook, as some have suggested; in fact, empathy drives accountability rooted in a sense of shared responsibility. If we learned anything in the pandemic, it is that when we were more human at work, even in the face of a crisis and while working 100% remotely in some cases, we had rather good business continuity with higher levels of engagement and trust in leadership than we have today. 

By valuing their employees as individuals and taking the time to understand their unique needs and challenges, leaders can create a sense of belonging that leads to increased engagement, productivity, performance, and ultimately resilience. The pandemic is not the last crisis or moment of uncertainty we face. With a more humanistic workplace, we can create greater resilience for the inevitable shocks ahead. Empathy is not a path to lower expectations, but rather a performance driver that can help organizations achieve their goals and create a better world for all.


Chris Shipley has co-authored The Adaptation Advantage and The Empathy Advantage.