Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

The polycrisis and the Great Convergence: Lessons learned from Cannes-Lions 2023

Privacy laws, cookie deprecation, and massive lawsuits are throwing the advertising world into turmoil, and forcing an unexpected—if overdue—convergence.

Megaphone

[Images: Shawn Hempel/Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Rio Longacre

Managing Director · Slalom Consulting

BY Rio Longacre

AI reigned supreme at this year’s Cannes-Lions, but a simultaneous occurrence of catastrophic events enveloping AdTech was the proverbial elephant in the room. Privacy laws, cookie deprecation, and massive lawsuits are throwing the advertising world into turmoil, and forcing an unexpected—if overdue—convergence.

THE BACKGROUND 

If there is a premier global event for advertising and marketing, Cannes-Lions is it. Held in Cannes, France, the international festival of creativity is the advertising world’s premier event. One analyst called it the industry’s “five-star luxury version of Burning Man.”

Celebrating its 70th year of existence, the show has transformed as advertising has evolved from its roots in creative ad copy to the technology-based discipline it is today. Global digital advertising is predicted to top $625 billion—or roughly two-thirds of overall ad spend—in 2023.

Not surprisingly, AI dominated this year’s event. Popular topics included AI and its impact on DEI, AI-generated content, and using AI to optimize audiences with data clean rooms. Generally lost in the hubbub was the polycrisis enveloping AdTech.

THE PLAYERS

Supporting the digital ad industry is the dizzying universe of players who power digital experiences. They fall into two distinct camps: Marketing Technology (MarTech) and Advertising Technology (AdTech). There are thousands of MarTech and AdTech solutions.

ChiefMarTec publishes a map of the marketing technology landscape, called the MarTech 5000, which outlines more than 8,000 MarTech solutions. AdTech is slightly less expensive but no less confusing—Luma Partners articulates the AdTech LUMAscape. While the two worlds overlap, they contain different solutions, are used by different audiences, and leverage data sets that remain largely distinct.

THE SCHISM

Since the dawn of the digital marketing universe, the worlds of MarTech and AdTech have always lived in separate spaces—MarTech run by internal marketing operations teams and AdTech run by media agencies. The MarTech and AdTech silos have different focuses, with AdTech supporting above-the-line (ATL) paid media activities, and MarTech, by contrast, focusing on owned channels and customer relationship management (CRM). Different activities use different tools and require different data sets to operate.

AdTech includes Supply Side Platforms, Demand Side Platforms, Trading Desks, and Data Management Platforms that engage with prospective customers across top-of-funnel, relying on signals gleaned from cookies, MAIDs (Mobile Ad IDs), IP addresses, and Device IDs to interact with and track users as they browse across channels and devices.

MarTech, on the other hand, leverages CRM, email service providers, web content management, customer data platforms (CDP), and marketing automation to orchestrate middle- and lower-funnel experiences that support demand generation and CRM. MarTech relies on email addresses, customer IDs, phone numbers, mailing addresses, and other information to maintain relationships with prospects or customers.

THE POLYCRISIS

Ready or not, the digital marketing world of the past 20 years is ending abruptly as cookies, trackers, and third-party data sources disappear, privacy laws go into effect, and AdTech companies reel from lawsuits and increased governmental scrutiny. AdTech is under siege.

The impetus for many of these changes is consumers are increasingly unhappy with the tools AdTech companies use to collect their Personally Identifiable Information (PII), and governments are responding by passing numerous privacy regulations, including most notably GDPR, CCPR, and CPRA.

In response, the tech world is rolling out platform changes such as Google’s plans to deprecate third-party cookies and Apple’s new App Tracking Transparency (ATT) privacy framework that requires apps to request user permission to track across applications.

Governments are stepping in—the DOJ in the U.S. recently filed an antitrust suit against Google’s digital advertising technologies, referred to as its “ad tech stack,” calling out anticompetitive conduct. Earlier this year, Google was charged in the EU with violating antitrust laws by using its dominance to undercut rivals.

Ad fraud is also a big issue. Many large media agencies and AdTech platforms have failed to protect brands from pervasive ad fraud totaling $81 billion globally in 2022, which is predicted to increase to $100 billion this year. 

The net result is it’s becoming increasingly difficult to rely on third-party data sources to build audiences, which is, in turn, resulting in plunging addressability, less effective ads, lower conversions, and cratering RoAS. The internet we have known is coming to an inglorious end as we enter a privacy-first, cookieless future.

THE GREAT CONVERGENCE: MADTECH

With the ability to collect and share data curtailed, certain AdTech technologies (the DMP, for example) are disappearing. As these changes roll out, the obvious solution for brands is to build up first-party data sources that can be integrated with AdTech platforms to build audiences, making up for signal loss as third-party data sources disappear. And because first-party data is stored in MarTech, this means the hitherto distinct worlds of MarTech and AdTech are crashing together in real time.

To survive, brands must begin making first-party data investments, and internal marketing ops teams should quickly get up to speed learning to collaborate with media agencies. Unless they wish to go all in on contextual marketing, media agencies should prepare to work directly with clients’ MarTech teams and accept that some AdTech will shift in-house as brands take control of their data.

As we enter a privacy-first, cookieless world, new tools like data clean rooms are popping up to bridge the two worlds. A solution to share pseudonymized information between these parties in a privacy-safe environment, data clean rooms offer a place to blend first-party data from MarTech—i.e., a CDP—with outside data sources to build models which can be pushed to a DSP to target consumers with ads. Data clean rooms are essentially replacing DMPs in the privacy-first tech stack.

Change is happening fast and the marketplace is responding. Paid media solutions that include integrations with things like Amazon Marketing Cloud and the Amazon Ads data clean room are popping up more and more, and brands should expect to see more solutions like this in the coming months as the Great Convergence unfolds and MarTech and AdTech become “MadTech.”


Rio Longacre is a Managing Director at Slalom Consulting and has two decades of experience in the digital trenches.