Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Improve your one-on-one meetings by harnessing the power of probing questions

While most leaders try to use open-ended questions when talking to employees, too often their questions are overly general. Hence, they fail to produce the desired results.

One-on-one meeting

[Images: insta_photos/Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Matthew Wride

BY Matthew Wride

Years ago, I was asked by a close friend for some career advice. He was contemplating whether to return for an MBA or enroll in law school. He did not see himself being a lawyer, but he was intrigued by law school’s educational rigor, which is grounded upon learning through questions and answers—i.e., the Socratic Method. As we weighed the pros and cons together, I shared some wisdom I had heard, and it rang true for both of us. A former CEO once remarked that law school was valuable to him not because it gave him specific answers, but because it taught him to ask the right questions.

We know that asking the right questions is a core competency within effective leadership. Along these lines, Professor Hal Gregersen has spent years studying and analyzing the power of questions. In a recent book on the topic, Gregersen observes: “Questions have a curious power to unlock new insights and positive behavior change in every part of our lives. They can get people unstuck and open new directions for progress no matter what they are struggling with.”

While most try to use open-ended questions, too often our questions are overly general. Hence, they fail to produce the desired results. This is why I like to talk not only about the power of questions, but also how a question’s real power is captured when it is specific and targeted. I call these probing questions.

Consider the common scenario in which managers habitually start their one-on-one sessions with questions like:

  • How’s your team?
  • How are things going?
  • How are you feeling about things?

At first blush, these questions seem to be right on target. They are open-ended and require some thought. No simple “yes” or “no” will suffice! Yet, these types of questions are too simple in their design and thus get lethargic answers such as: fine, good, or okay. Plus, did we actually learn something from the response, and, more importantly, did we invite the respondent to engage in critical thinking and analysis? Not really. 

Now, let us reimagine our earlier scenario by having our manager develop a few probing questions to guide the conversation’s flow and purpose. Here are some possibilities:

  • What do you think drove last quarter’s sales increase?
  • What will most likely keep you from meeting your goals this month?
  • How can we prevent further attrition on your team from happening?

By using careful, probing questions we accomplish four key objectives:

  1. First, we open a deeper dialogue to help drive our understanding of what our colleague is facing.
  2. Second, we force the other person to think and reason with us—to engage in a shared process of critical thinking.
  3. Third, as we touch upon specifics, we implicitly signal our desire to see particular behaviors or actions take place.
  4. Fourth, through targeted questions, we remove the temptation to tell us only what we want to hear instead of what is actually happening on the ground. 

Of course, you should never spring a probing process on someone without first telling them what to expect. Otherwise, they will feel like they are being interrogated—and that is not our goal! Lay down the ground rules up front and make this a collaborative process. Indicate how you do not expect them to know all the answers. Instead, explain how your questions are designed to facilitate a joint discussion where both parties share responsibility for a successful outcome. Furthermore, encourage participation by having them suggest questions they would like to explore. Finally, assure your colleagues that this is a technique to improve thinking and analysis and is not a way to assert control or signal your place in the hierarchy. 

Here are some suggestions to get your creative juices flowing as you develop your own probing questions:

Goals:

  • Which of your personal goals is giving you the most trouble?
  • Where are you making the most progress with your goals?
  • Who or what inspires you?
  • What is something you would like to learn?

Progress:

  • What have you done recently that will have the most impact on your KPIs?
  • What is your highest priority this week?
  • What projects are currently on the backburner and why?
  • How confident are you in achieving our objectives?
  • What have you learned from a recent mistake?

Team Members:

  • Who needs your support the most this week?
  • If you had to promote someone right away, who would that be?
  • Where or why is your team slowing down?

Blockers:

  • What specifically is keeping you or your team from meeting their objectives?
  • What is your team’s single biggest frustration right now?
  • What is it about our processes or structure that causes you the most difficulty?
  • Describe the last obstacle you successfully navigated.

Success:

  • What is something that caused you to say thank you?
  • Who or what is most vital to your future success?
  • Who gave you the most support this week and have you thanked them?
  • How do you define success for you or your team?

Next time you find yourself preparing for a key meeting or discussion, I would encourage you to do two things. One: Include in your preparation the notion of brainstorming for questions instead of answers. Two: Add to your agenda a list of probing questions that will help you: (i) get the answers you need, (ii) promote critical thinking, (iii) highlight behaviors and actions that matter most to you and your organization, and (iv) which are designed to surface what is going well and where improvement is needed.

Circling back to my introductory story, most law students despise the Socratic Method when they are being grilled in front of their classmates. Yet, when they graduate, many tend to recognize, and even extol, its immense value in driving deep understanding through the power of targeted, probing questions.  


Matthew Wride is the president of DecisionWise. He is a tech executive, author, consultant, and executive coach.