Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Why DEI and HR need a divorce

Both HR and DEI are crucial, but the evidence suggests that separating them is the most effective way to meet the demands of the 21st century.

[Images: Adobe Stock / Vitezslav Vylicil]

Profile photo of Joe Santana

BY Joseph Santana

In the early 20th century, as labor laws and industrialization challenges surfaced, many organizations struggled with emerging labor laws and industrialization issues. To respond to these, HR departments were created. Later, when the civil rights movement ignited in the middle of the 1900s, business leaders saw HR as a natural fit for what they at the time saw as a need to avoid legal issues and reputational harm to their companies relative to their hiring and promotion practices. Unfortunately, HR’s solution to the challenge was to promote limited performative DEI practices focused on optics rather than to make substantive change.

Today, these performative approaches continue to be what HR leaders push DEI leaders under their control to focus on. Meanwhile, the modern workforce has become increasingly louder in their demands for meaningful progress, not patronizing slogans about being welcome, valued, and heard. As for the marketplace, it continues to crave responsive products, and more and more investors are seeking companies with a healthy economic future as they look at changing workforce and marketplace demographics. And corporate resolutions, where investors challenge CEOs and Boards to produce proof of DEI progress, tell us that these corporate owners do not believe the self-reported results of companies backed by vanity awards that are more smoke and mirrors than evidence of real progress. (Check out the number of companies facing investor demands relative to the success of their DEI effort on the As You Sow’s website.)

Now, some may ask, is this something the DEI under HR partnership can work out? And my unequivocal answer is no! Why? Because I believe the DEI and HR marriage has never worked, and that it’s time for them to amicably part ways. I think both functions are essential, but they have irreconcilable differences that suggest a divorce is best for them to serve the needs of CEOs and investors.

So, in the balance of this article, I will present to investors and CEOs the evidence for what I believe proves the CEO should officiate the long overdue formal divorce of DEI from HR.

PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 1: HR OBSTRUCTS DEI’S WORKPLACE POLICY CHANGE PROPOSALS

Under the control of HR, DEI has produced what best can be called the appearance of underrepresented people being welcome, valued, and heard. But let’s look at the actual 2023 report card:

  • Underrepresentation of marginalized groups and women in leadership positions persists.
  • Gender, racial, and ethnic pay gaps continue.  
  • Antiquated policies, such as inadequate expense reimbursements and other outdated 20th-century policies and practices that hamstring the emerging workforce’s performance, are still in place after six decades of HR-controlled DEI.

And despite all the internal branding efforts, employees are not buying it.

The best way I can describe HR-controlled DEI workplace efforts over the last decade is that they have tried to shove elephants into a house built for a giraffe, then attempted to convince the elephants that they just need to go on a diet to be happy.

PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 2: CONFLICTS OF INTEREST

To address workplace and workforce issues effectively, DEI cannot report to the very same leader they often need to challenge: the Chief Human Resources Officer (CHRO). Some HR departments make this even more challenging by having the DEI leaders report to someone lower than the CHRO.

That’s like having your financial auditor and advisor report to one of your accounting department’s supervisors of accounts receivable.

PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 3: ISOLATION WITHIN HR PREVENTS DEI FROM SUPPORTING THE WHOLE ORGANIZATION

HR does not concern itself with how the company can expand its available market by creating new or tweaking existing products or services to appeal to the emerging diverse marketplace. It does not focus on how to leverage supplier diversity to grow revenue. And it does not focus on what the Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) investors are looking for relative to DEI under the social and governance pillars.

However, these are CEO, Board, and major stakeholder concerns. Under HR, DEI cannot focus on these CEO and investor priorities because it is a wholly owned subsidiary of HR.

PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 4: UNDER HR, DEI IS RESOURCE STARVED

When diversity is housed in HR, the average annual diversity budget is $239,000. Meanwhile, recruiting budgets in many of these companies are more than ten times as large at around $2.6 million. DEI initiatives require adequate funding and resources to produce results, but when it comes to DEI, HR usually has one or two people dedicated to the function and they give them “HR window dressing money.” And when the CFO comes looking for cost savings, HR is more likely to cut what it considers less core (e.g., its DEI practice) than to take the axe to that fat recruiting budget and other functions it believes are its “bread and butter.”

PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 5: DIFFERENT SKILL SETS

The skills required for HR and DEI roles differ significantly. HR professionals typically possess expertise in personnel management, labor law, and compliance. That is precisely what they need.

However, DEI specialists need expertise across the entire business strategy components, including supply chain, markets, and other business topics. As for knowledge of HR, they just need to know how to work with the HR experts; they don’t need to be the HR experts.

CONCLUSION

Given these irreconcilable differences, I submit the time has come for CEOs to officiate a formal divorce between HR and DEI. Both these functions are crucial, but the evidence suggests that separating them is the most effective way to meet the demands of the 21st century. This way, HR can continue to focus on its core mission, and DEI can fully pursue its role as a direct report to the CEO, helping to transform the company for the emerging needs of the 21st century.

As an investor in a public company, I would demand this. Clearly, it’s time for a change that opens the pathway to greater accountability and success for DEI and HR in the 21st century. I rest my case!


Joe Santana is a DEI strategist, author, speaker, Forbes Council member, and CEO of Joseph Santana, LLC.