Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Why your customer experience isn’t working

Forward-leaning brands start with the customer, not the technology.

Happy customer on her phone

[Images: Adobe Stock / insta_photos]

Profile photo of Brian Mcintosh

BY Brian Mcintosh

Seventy percent of US adults surveyed believe we are living through a transformative change unlike anything experienced before. The average tenure of companies on the S&P 500 was 33 years in 1965; in 2023, it is 14 years. At this pace, over half will be replaced over the next 10 years. The average tenure of Fortune 500 CMOs is 40 months, the lowest in more than a decade. 

Seeking to keep pace with change and demonstrate value, marketing leaders are embracing new digital technologies at a record pace. This is the latest in a long line of “this changes everything” solutions that promise a truly personalized customer experience.

But delivering a superior customer experience is foremost about the customer. In other words, your customer experience isn’t failing because you don’t have the right platform. It’s failing because you’ve taken your focus off the customer.

A recent study by Interbrand found that the cumulative value of the world’s top 10 brands exceeds the value of the next 90. A brand is the promise of what will be delivered or experienced. Real, personalized experiences come from the moments of truth a customer has with that brand and the decisions a brand makes. Leaders of these super brands know how to deploy their brand as an asset. 

FROM TRACKING TO LISTENING

Zero-party data is the perfect case in point.

Coined by Forrester in 2020, the term “zero-party data” describes the data customers willingly offer to a brand. If customer data is currency, this is the gold mine.

Yet, as ironic as it sounds, listening to what customers say about their preferences has fallen well behind tracking and surveillance as the preferred marketing strategy. Marketers have for years prioritized first-party data (information collected on owned digital properties), second-party data (first-party data acquired from a trusted partner), and third-party data (purchased from a demand-side) over the information given intentionally by the customer.

However, with third-party data on its way out, the surveillance-first strategy is no longer viable. Customers are saying they won’t miss it: According to a recent survey of over 2,000 consumers, over half reported brands failed to inform them how their data was used or protected.

The good news for brands is that 81% still said they would share personal data if they got something of value. Understanding what customers value (a personalized offer or rewards?) when they want it and how they want it (via text or email?) is up to the brand. And all they have to do is ask—and then act.

GATHERING ZERO-PARTY DATA—AND ACTING ON IT

A new visitor to any retail website is initially understood as a “lowest common denominator,” or LCD. One way to refine that profile is to greet visitors with an annoying consent banner asking them to opt in or out with categories like “preferences” and “statistics.” A better way is to forgo this shoot-first approach. Earn the visitor’s trust by building her preferences dynamically as she browses—without the baseline presumption that her every move is being tracked (or sold).

What are the best tools for trustworthy preference-building? First, following the customer’s lead. If “Amanda” comes to your sports running shoe site, offer a single-page interaction with the option, but not the necessity, of visiting the preference center. “You appear to be interested in athletic footwear. Can we show you more of these products?” is a seamless way of confirming interest. An artificial intelligence (AI) chatbot offers a second way Amanda can express intent. If she types in “I’m looking for women’s trail running shoes on sale,” the brand now knows she’s a woman who runs on trails and is interested in deals. So, serving her the latest cutting-edge product is unlikely to appeal—unless it is at a discount.

Analyzing opt-out patterns, visit time, and duration are all fair game, but the analyses must have a purpose. If zero-party data signifies customer trust, it’s up to brands not to squander it. And if all that data is currency, the brand must offer something valuable in return.

The central question—which should guide every act of digital marketing—is: What kind of content does the customer need to feel valued? Details about our latest products? Information about company values? Current promotions? Secondly is determining each customer’s preferred channel—and cadence—for receiving content.  

FROM MICRO TO MACRO

This zoom-in on zero-party data reveals larger truths about brands’ digital customer experience.

First, most brands already have the zero-party data they need; they’re just not using it. This is true of data in general: The average company only analyzes 40%  of the data it collects. It’s also true of many digital marketing platforms. Most brands are not unlocking the full value, and more technology is not necessarily the answer—they need to train people how to use what they have and ensure proper implementation. Without this focus, that new digital tool is effectively no better than Excel. 

Second, the failure to leverage zero-party data boils down to three pitfalls that threaten all marketing efforts: no strategy, alignment, or leadership.       

  • Brands must have business metrics related to customer experience outcomes. They must be intentional and measurable.
  • Everyone “owns” the customer. Regardless of business unit, customers expect a seamless experience no matter which channel they use. Aligning with other units around strategy, and implementing internal measurement and incentives, must be aligned with the customer’s needs.
  • Without an institutional will, strategy is an empty exercise. Leaders must develop a consensus around the need for a strategy and alignment on its implementation. There’s no third way.

What unites all these insights? The fact that there are humans at the other end of all our tools, strategies, and goals. Digital marketing innovations will continue, and we should take advantage to improve customer experiences. But forward-leaning brands start with the customer, not the technology.


Brian is the Chief Consulting Officer for BlastX Consulting. https://www.blastx.com/about.