When the economic picture looks less than rosy, ensuring every dollar you invest gives the highest ROI is vital. Marketing is one area that can be a money pit if you aren’t pulling the right levers, but with the correct strategy, it can be one budget that pays back in dividends. It depends on whether you know which buttons to press and when.
ENOUGH WITH THE SILOS
The easiest way to ensure you’re wasting your marketing budget is to keep every element siloed. Different stakeholders within your organization measure their medium differently—for example, social media is about engagement, and paid advertising is all about impressions and conversions. Yet, each silo overlaps and cannot always be identified or understood in isolation. These overlaps are often wasters of money and time.
And when silos exist, the results can easily be misinterpreted. The social media team might not seem to be performing because no one is buying through Facebook. The PPC team is on fire because the paid ads appear to be converting, right? Siloing information like this means that you will never see how the social media work is actually directing customers to the paid ad work. Both are contributing in their own way. Conversion attribution should never be based on anything other than pure mathematical analysis. It’s a numbers game, not a guessing game.
WHAT DO WE WANT? AND HOW DID WE GET HERE?
These two questions are at the heart of ROI maximization. Most organizations have similar goals: sales, conversions, and new customers. But knowing how you got there is a little trickier. When you’ve identified the equivalent of your goal—a sale, a new sign-up, etc.—you should track your customer’s path there. Tracking that path forward can lead you astray because you’ll likely miss out on quite a few touchpoints along the way. When you track backward, it’s far easier to see every point at which your customer interacted with your media.
Another mistake is asking your platform—say Google—to give you the data on how many successful ads you ran in a month. Google will undoubtedly tell you all of your ads were the reason your customers converted. They will emphasize the success of their own platform, and the same would be true for any other platform. Running a holistic attribution system is like flicking the switch on a floodlight that illuminates every single place your customer paused on the path to conversion. It’s a single source of truth.
NO MORE ANALYSIS PARALYSIS
The best part of digital marketing is the massive amount of data that marketers have access to, but it’s also the most difficult part to contend with if you don’t have the tools to analyze that data properly. Thankfully, artificial intelligence (AI) is making this easier by the day. In the past, a whole team of data scientists might have been needed to get valuable insights from a dataset. But today, more and more, this job can be done by AI tools with proper inputs.
Be warned, the insights you get are only as valuable as the integrity of the data you’ve gleaned. This goes back to the type of attribution you’re using to gather this data. Regardless of whether you’re using humans or AI to analyze your data, the output will be less than useful if the source is not holistic.
WHEN TRACKING IS NOT THAT EASY
Digital marketing channels are easy enough to track with all the mechanisms in place to do so, but not all valuable customer interactions take place online. Telephone calls are a very important piece of the puzzle. In a 2021 study, 36% of respondents over 56 ranked calls as their preferred method of communicating with businesses. Those in the 40-55 age bracket ranked it as their close second only to email. That is a significant part of the spending demographic and likely a portion of your customer base. Tracking phone activity with customers is a vital bridge in multipoint attribution.
Phone calls are not an obvious thing to track, but it’s not a difficult step to implement. On the other hand, other offline channels are far more difficult. For instance, radio, television, and print ads need to be specifically crafted to ensure you can track conversions. One way of doing this is using the offline medium to take the customer onto an online medium—like a QR code or a CTA to social media or a website.
Again, the infrastructure hosting that ad will undoubtedly skew the analytics to favor their own platforms. While a radio station can tell you how many listeners were tuned in while your ad was playing, they cannot tell you how many were actually listening. This is where you should start thinking outside the box because all the pieces of this puzzle add up to increased ROI.
HACK YOUR ROI WITH ATTRIBUTION
Cutting budgets is not the path to success. Rather, you should ensure you have the tools in place to maximize the return on your investment in every space in your business, including marketing. Putting a holistic media attribution strategy in place can give you a single source of truth from which to draw insights that guide your decision-making.
Evaluate your current marketing and analytics infrastructure for data capture and integration capabilities to establish an effective holistic media attribution strategy. Identifying gaps in this process is crucial. Then, define clear objectives and KPIs aligned with broader business goals.
Mapping out the complete customer journey, from various touchpoints to distinct stages, and collecting data on customer behavior is also essential for gaining insights into your overall customer experience. Additionally, encouraging cross-functional collaboration among your teams is vital, as it enables a comprehensive understanding of the customer journey and facilitates informed decision-making.
Digital marketing is a brave new world with endless business opportunities, but it can also become a money pit with no real return if you don’t create mechanisms to foster a deep understanding of your customer journey.
Sergio Alvarez is a performance marketing expert, digital attribution leader, and the CEO and founder of Ai Media Group.