Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Why every seed-stage startup founder’s first hire should be a product marketer

By hiring a product marketer, your startup can strategically position itself for product market fit—and ultimately, the critical A round.

Man and woman shaking hands

[Images: Adobe Stock /djrandco]

Profile photo of Mack McKelvey

Founder & CEO · SalientMG and The Credentialed

As an early stage tech founder, you have one goal: Show product-market fit (PMF) as fast as possible. That’s it. And, if you are starting a company now, you know how challenging this market is; funding has become scarce as interest rates continue to soar. Gone are the days when founders could raise seed rounds based on vanity metrics or creative business ideas. 

Now, you have to show investors that you’re a viable company. There’s one way to show it, and that’s a repeatable process for converting pipeline to revenue. And that only happens if you are in front of the right prospect and your solutions meet their needs. 

VISION MATTERS, EXECUTION MATTERS MORE

Most founders begin with a vision, but the grim reality is that the odds are stacked against startups, which have a staggering 90% failure rate. A significant 60% shutter their operations before reaching the pre-seed and Series A funding stages.

Marc Andreesen defines PMF as “being in a good market with a product that can satisfy that market.” Fit isn’t just a nice-to-have. Thirty-five percent of startups fail because there is no market need for them. 

This means that founders must have a founding team member whose sole job is ensuring the company is obsessing over the customer.

FOCUS ON TRACTION

Companies in the seed stage are typically composed of 2-10 team members. I encourage founders to ensure one of these team members is a product marketer (PMM). By hiring a PMM, your startup can strategically position itself for PMF—and ultimately, the critical A round which will allow you the runway to build out your minimally viable product and customer acquisition.

Unlike content, demand generation, or other marketing specializations, the role of a PMM is often misunderstood. I define a PMM as a technical marketer who deeply understands a company’s product or solution, its current and future functional capabilities, the market it serves, and how it specifically solves a customer problem. At their core, and at this stage, a PMM is obsessed with driving PMF. 

The PMM is also the primary partner for the chief sales officer, who at this stage is also typically the founder. Your PMM conducts competitive research, analyzes your product’s functionality to see how it compares to other solutions in the market, regularly solicits direct customer feedback, and serves as the product evangelist. You may continuously wonder if your product is ready to go to market. Your PMM can give the green light through their research, acumen, pulse on the industry, and your target audience’s solution adoption.

By hiring a PMM early in your startup’s inception, they’ll have historic knowledge of where you started and how you’ve evolved, giving them the ability to have authentic relationships with your customers. Over time, in partnership with your product team, they can run your product’s beta program and eventually own your customer advisory board. 

The right PMM is scrappy and knows how to get access to information on your industry, competitors, and audience. Unlike PMMs at big tech companies with deep resources, your startup needs someone who thrives in the unknown and isn’t bogged down by uncertainty or the lack of processes.

HIRE FOR SCALE 

Early stage companies tend to make the mistake of hiring green or specialist marketers, like email or content. While this seemingly inexpensive hire may save you money in the short term, it’ll cost you down the line—or at the very least, it’ll require significant management time from the founder.

You can avoid this costly decision by hiring the most senior PMM you can, as early as you can. They’ll get to know your product, industry, and customer base and they will set your eventual sales team up for success. 

Practically, they will produce relevant content, particularly sales support assets, web copy, and opinion pieces on the industry and challenges of their buyers. The PMM will continuously learn what content and channel resonates, and what moves customers through conversion. 

Through this, they’ll put a strategy in place from the beginning, and they’ll establish the critical marketing foundations so your entire company can truly scale as it grows. 

When looking for a PMM, lean on your VC partners and network. This is one of the hardest hires to make, but it is the foundational glue of a strategic go-to-market plan. Invest in their growth as they may very well be the most qualified and capable person to lead marketing through your business’ next two funding rounds. 

Get creative in what you offer for salary and equity, or lean into your startup’s mission to attract someone with similar values. PMMs are builders by nature, so go big with the industry-wide challenge you’re looking to solve and you’ll attract top talent.

EMBRACE FRICTION

As a seed-stage founder, you need to surround yourself with leaders unafraid to question everything. PMMs are no exception. They’re highly critical people by nature; they see the bigger picture and question assumptions. Because product marketers can readily distinguish a viable reality from a lofty aspiration, they’re not “yes people.” And your startup is better for it. 

While this may occasionally slow down decision-making or cause points of friction, embrace the tension. This will ensure your startup is always making progress toward fulfilling your mission, rather than getting distracted with projects that fail to move the needle.  

In the early stages of your startup, every hire makes a substantial difference. While it may be tempting to hire a generalist marketer or some ‘growth hacker’ first, don’t follow old, conventional thinking. Hiring a dedicated PMM right from the beginning sets the tone for your business, fostering a growth-oriented perspective where marketing can play a pivotal role in revenue generation from the start.


Mack McKelvey is founder and CEO of SalientMG, a strategic marketing firm specializing in solutions for growth-stage tech companies.