Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Smart innovation: Tips for avoiding the dreaded “GenAI Swirl”

As generative AI mania nears its crescendo, GenAI “trend fatigue” is starting to hit business leaders and organizations.

Worried woman on a laptop

[Images: Adobe Stock / insta_photos]

Profile photo of Rio Longacre

Managing Director · Slalom Consulting

BY Rio Longacre

Generative AI has reached the zenith of its hype cycle, sucking up corporate time and attention like a black hole. Some leaders are beginning to complain about GenAI fatigue. Negativitity aside, GenAI is starting to deliver tangible results for marketers. According to some, the key to avoiding “GenAI Swirl” is to focus on core business activities while prioritizing practical—and promising—GenAI use cases with small, specialized teams.

HYPE CYCLE CRESCENDO

One year after ChatGPT’s launch in November 2022, it’s GenAI everywhere you go. Google’s CEO Sundar Pichai has said AI technology will be the biggest technological shift in our lifetimes—maybe bigger than the internet itself. At the Google I/O 2023, he mentioned the word 150 times during the two-hour keynote.

Salesforce proclaimed that this year’s Dreamforce, the tech company’s annual conference held in San Francisco, was the “biggest AI event in the world.” CEO Marc Benioff is famous for saying AI will be the most exciting business opportunity of not just this lifetime, but maybe any lifetime, ever.

Brand marketers have been quick to dedicate enormous resources to exploring GenAI. A survey by Gartner reported that 63% of marketing leaders plan to invest in this technology in the next 24 months.

Not ones to be left behind on any hot trend, agencies have been quick to dive in. Following Forrester’s prediction that 32,000 ad agency jobs, or 7.5% of the workforce, are at risk of being replaced, one large holding company instructed its employees to start learning GenAI or look for a new job. One media agency’s CTO reported its IT department is dedicating approximately 50% of its time to exploring GenAI use cases, and 11.5% of executives at ad agencies say they have already implemented generative AI to replace human jobs or plan to do so.

TREND FATIGUE AND PROMISE

Not surprisingly, generative AI sits at the very top of the “Peak of Inflated Expectations” on Gartner’s 2023 Hype Cycle for Emerging Technologies. “As the technologies in this Hype Cycle are still at an early stage, there is significant uncertainty about how they will evolve,” said Melissa Davis, VP Analyst at Gartner.

As GenAI mania nears its crescendo, GenAI “trend fatigue” is starting to hit business leaders and organizations. “Everyone’s trying to fit it in everywhere,” said one overwhelmed executive. “Anyone else just absolutely exhausted with the conversation around generative AI?” one user on Reddit recently asked. A senior leader at a major tech firm recently quipped in confidence that GenAI reminds him in many ways of Web3 and NFTs, with “many of the same people” involved.

PROMISING USE CASES EMERGE

Hype aside, some interesting GenAI innovations are starting to emerge as organizations roll out solutions with real-world applications. Here’s a list of some use cases emerging across the advertising and marketing world, as well as a few tips for using them at your company:

1. CURATE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCES 

Many initial GenAI use cases have involved chatbots for customer support to offer self-service and answer frequently asked questions to improve CX. To date, at least 38% of GenAI initiatives have been focused on this area, and some travel and hospitality brands are using chatbots to offer a curated experience.

A good example of this is our partnership with a cruise industry leader to launch a GenAI-powered digital human. The chatbot underpins our partner’s online customer experience and reshapes how consumers use technology to plan their vacations.

2. AUTOMATE TIME-CONSUMING TASKS

Because GenAI can perform some functions much more quickly than any human, automating tasks is a great way to get value. “[GenAI is] amplifying and augmenting what we’re already doing, not replacing it,” said Kyle Healy, an executive at an insurance firm. “It enables us to do more with the same amount of people.”

A CTO at a large online retailer used GenAI to write more than 10,000 product descriptions for an e-commerce website. Prior to this, the task would have taken a year. Using ChatGPT, it was completed in a few weeks, which included time for a small team to review the copy and correct mistakes or obvious errors.

3. PERSONALIZE CONTENT

In performance marketing, personalization is the proverbial Holy Grail. The challenge is creating differentiated content. As such, the ability of GenAI to produce content for campaigns is highly appealing to brands and agencies.

Earlier this year, Omnicom announced a joint initiative with Adobe to bring generative AI capabilities to their clients. Omnicom is using Adobe Firefly creative generative AI models, paired with Omni data, to power content development.

4. EXPAND SPECIALIZED SKILLS 

Some brands are experimenting with digital humans deployed with large language models trained on volumes of appropriate content to provide specialized skills in hard-to-find areas with high demand. Digital persons can augment existing teams and bring specialized skills where needed.

The field of accessibility is in high demand with a short supply of accredited professionals. This is where a digital human can bring specialized skills and knowledge. Trained on a curated knowledge base of articles and websites from accredited sources on disabilities, advocacy, and accessibility, an “accessibility advisor” can act as a champion for disadvantaged individuals.

5. OPTIMIZE PAID MEDIA

Running and optimizing complex paid media campaigns can be challenging. With so many variables to consider and a wide array of data points to review and understand, it’s no surprise agencies struggle to adjust campaigns frequently and are often accused of a “set it and forget it” approach.

Brands and agencies are experimenting with GenAI-powered “smart” dashboards to interact with media professionals and coach them on how to improve campaign performance in real time. These solutions can help media professionals run more effective campaigns and boost RoAS by providing timely insights or even spinning up new analyses on the fly.

FINAL THOUGHTS

If you are struggling with GenAI Swirl, you are not alone. A winning approach often begins with codifying problem statements and assessing the applicability of GenAI, then setting up small, ring-fenced teams of professionals to find solutions and tackle them head-on. This approach helps to avoid distraction while maximizing success.


Rio Longacre is a Managing Director at Slalom Consulting and has two decades of experience in the digital trenches.