Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Why your diversity and inclusion training may not be producing results

In the increasingly demanding, ever more diverse, and global 21st century, it's time for organizations to take meaningful action by addressing systemic issues first.

Diverse team of employees

[Images: Adobe Stock – Nicholas Felix/peopleimages.com]

Profile photo of Joe Santana

BY Joseph Santana

Organizations have experienced a hockey-stick rise in discrimination across several undersupported demographic groups in the last couple of years. These displays of bias and discrimination have not been deterred by giving managers and executives diversity and bias training.

For instance, Google, a tech giant known for its efforts in diversity and inclusion, recently settled a $118 million case of pay discrimination against women despite conducting extensive diversity training. And more recently, a former Google employee sued the company, claiming it systematically discriminated against Black workers by placing them in lower-level jobs, underpaying them, and denying them opportunities to advance. This is not to pick on Google. They are, after all, just one of many organizations in the same situation.

DIVERSITY AND INCLUSION TRAINING

If you check out any magazine article on creating a more inclusive organization, you will trip over tons of pages that continue to sell diversity and inclusion training for managers as the solution. These articles discuss how leaders must authentically commit to continuous diversity and inclusion education.

These training programs, they claim, will help managers become better at seeking input from team members and creating environments that value uniqueness and individual voices while addressing accountability challenges. They will highlight how training teaches leaders listening skills crucial in fostering inclusion and driving retention rates. And they will talk about how leaders need to be equipped to ensure fair opportunities for career advancement for all team members by seeking feedback, distributing work equitably, and providing support and sponsorship.

This all sounds wonderful. And I hate to be the wet blanket on all of this warm, fuzzy advice, but I can tell you that if one ingredient is missing in your organization, all this well-meaning diversity and inclusion training of leaders won’t matter much in terms of protecting you from the kind of behavior that will land you on the losing end of a discrimination lawsuit.

So, what is this essential ingredient? Having a truly fair and equitable corporate environment.

THE STANFORD PRISON EXPERIMENT

What I’m talking about here is not based on findings in a new research breakthrough. Back in 1971, a psychologist named Philip Zimbardo conducted what came to be known as the Stanford Prison Experiment, an unconventional study using college students in a mock prison setting.

This experiment examined the influence of social situations and structures on behavior. The participants in the study were 24 male college students randomly assigned to act either as “guards” or “prisoners” in the mock prison. Participants were carefully selected for their mental and physical health and were randomly assigned to act as prisoners or guards in a simulated prison at Stanford University.

The results were shocking. Students acting as prisoners experienced and displayed severe emotional distress due to the cruel and dehumanizing behavior of the students playing guards, all of whom were previously just ordinary college students. These behaviors appeared very early in the study, revealing the power of external factors over individual actions. In fact, originally, the study was intended to last two weeks, but it had to be halted after just six days due to drastic and unexpected changes in participants’ behavior.

The results of the Stanford Prison Experiment served as a vivid example of how seemingly good, healthy, and caring people can become perpetrators of evil while others become hapless victims under the situational influence of institutional practices and policies. More recently, we witnessed a real-life parallel of the conditions of this experiment in the cruel abuse of prisoners at Abu Ghraib.

AN IMPORTANT LESSON FOR BUSINESSES

These findings highlight the importance of recognizing and addressing the conditions that support systemic issues in an institution rather than blaming the wrongdoing on a “few bad apples.” This important lesson has been incorporated into textbooks, classroom lectures, and popular media. Moreover, it has had practical applications, such as influencing legislation for the separate housing of juveniles in federal prisons and serving as training material for military interrogators.

Yet, it does not seem these insights have ever reached organizational leaders or HR. In the report Elevating Equity: The Real Story of Diversity and Inclusion, it was found that the primary reason organizations provide diversity training to managers and supervisors is often to provide cover for the organization.

It’s the typical bad apple defense speech when something goes wrong: “We invest in diversity and inclusion training and do not support the actions of this bad apple. Blah, blah, blah.” Yet, based on empirical evidence, it is ineffective to train individual managers to be more inclusive without institutional and policy changes that correct pay and promotion disparity and other forms of organizational abuse of targeted individuals.

It’s as helpful as giving “How to be nice people” classes to the prison guards in the Stanford experiment or at Abu Ghraib, while the institutional conditions signaled the prisoners were lesser human than the guards. And as you can see by the large settlement in the above discrimination cases, diversity and inclusion training as a tool for protecting a company’s reputation and bank account does not work. Neither judges nor the public buy it.

IT’S TIME FOR ORGANIZATIONS TO ADDRESS SYSTEMIC ISSUES

In the increasingly demanding, ever more diverse and global 21st century, it’s time for organizations to take meaningful action by addressing systemic issues—like pay and promotion disparities—alongside providing DEI training to managers and supervisors.

Training alone won’t suffice if institutional practices and policies continue perpetuating inequality, so it’s time to stop spending money on a useless smokescreen. On the other hand, training offered to speed up the shedding and replacing of bad behaviors that were part of the old system can be helpful.

So, commit to advocating for fair and equitable corporate environments that genuinely foster and support inclusion and diversity. Then you can invest in training within an environment where its impact will truly be meaningful to both employees and your organization.


Joe Santana is a DEI strategist, author, speaker, Forbes Council member, and CEO of Joseph Santana, LLC.