Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

How to optimize your email marketing strategy for maximum engagement and conversions

Optimizing an email marketing strategy can help a business deliver messages to the right people at the right time.

A mail icon with 1 unread message

[images: Adobe Stock/ NicoElNino]

Profile photo of David Partain

Email continues to be one of the most effective channels for reaching customers, even as new options like social media and streaming advertisements prove their value. The only snag: The average person is flooded with messages, getting an average of 121 business emails daily. Add in spam, and it’s easy to understand how people get overwhelmed.

Optimizing an email marketing strategy can help a business deliver messages to the right people at the right time.

TRUST THE ANALYSIS

Every area of business has repeated mantras that are easy to find. But often, when professionals take the time to pursue an analysis, they’ll find that their previous practice or belief doesn’t exactly hold water.

I’ve found this to be true about when to send emails. Best practices say that the optimal days to send emails are Tuesday through Thursday—never Mondays or Fridays. After looking closer, one of the teams I managed in the past found that our internal data unexpectedly showed that people were reading our emails outside of that window, especially on Fridays. Perhaps they felt more relaxed on Fridays, or maybe their inboxes were flooded with messages on the other days.

Although some marketers promote the idea of sending campaigns to large lists of people, one company I worked at found that sending out a big blast didn’t get much traction. Armed with this knowledge, we quickly realized how important it is to segment our email lists. There aren’t enough people to buy in and click if the messages are too general. One company where I worked discovered another key finding: Putting more than one topic in a single email is okay. At the time, we’d always thought that we needed to hone down and send people an email focused on one idea in which they were interested. But if the emails dealt strictly with a product and didn’t deal with thought leadership or events coming up, people didn’t open them.

I recognize that businesses, especially those in other industries, might not get the same results we did, but that’s part of the fun. Doing an analysis shows a company what is true for them, and highlights where to increase or decrease their efforts. Informed companies can make better decisions when they know what they’re dealing with. I recommend teams get their own numbers and feedback to understand how they perform best.

TRACK AND CUSTOMIZE

Many tools and codes allow teams to track what people are reading and personalize messages, such as adding the recipient’s first name. But a little extra effort in tracking and customization can pay off.

Consider creating a place in your database called “preferred name.” Now, you can go into the database and verify the recipient’s preferred name—maybe William goes by Bill, or Stephen actually prefers Stephen to Steve. That personal added touch will help you stand out when emailing people from your lists.

Be mindful of how tracking tools behave. In Outlook, a recent upgrade by Microsoft can track an email as opened, even if someone only hovers over it. The best way to view a campaign’s performance is to look beyond open rates to click rates from within the email. Tools like Marketo or HubSpot can also show teams where recipients went after the click or how long they stayed on your site, highlighting points like deliverability and conversion. A HubSpot dashboard shows what people are interested in beyond the click. But the most important element in choosing a tool is that it can help a business see the recipient’s journey.

Personalization often takes a commitment from one or more people on a team to work well. Someone should follow up on the emails’ analytics, learning constantly. If a company can afford to dedicate staff to it, the commitment is worth it, as it gives the business the data it needs.

DESIGN SUBSEQUENT MESSAGES

Recipients might convert or engage with a message immediately, while others need a few nudges to decide what they’d like to do. Other times, you might have a campaign that connects to other potential actions or offers.

In those cases, don’t stop with a single message. Instead, do a drip campaign utilizing workflow emails based on the recipient’s interactions with the campaign. Standard drip campaigns will send a new email every two or three days, which is a good way to build brand awareness. In my industry, most campaigns would have anywhere from two to eight messages. The frequency depends on the goal of the campaign. Some teams routinely put out messages once a week. If a campaign asks the recipient to take action, you might like to give them a little extra time between messages to review the company website.

Teams should override the default drip sequence with a new workflow, depending on what readers do. If a campaign has four steps and the user clicks during step two, sending a new workflow instead of the remaining steps makes sense because they’ve engaged.

KEEP IT SHORT AND SIMPLE

Remain concise in the subject line and body of the email. The median for subject lines is fewer than 60 characters, with the best-performing subject lines using intriguing questions (e.g., “Does inflation have you stressed?”) rather than dull, descriptive phrases. AI tools like Copy.ai can suggest subject lines that might work, or can at least get the marketing team’s wheels turning. Additionally, 80% of emails have fewer than 200 words. Every word counts. In my experience, don’t waste time on an elaborate template. A clean banner and relevant image work just fine. It’s also good practice not to overwhelm the recipient with choices. Being too salesy is a turnoff, so focus on a single call to action per email.

TO STAND OUT, OPTIMIZATION IS NOT OPTIONAL

Email marketing is a reliable way to reach an audience, but the massive number of emails people receive means optimizing any strategy will encourage people to read the messages and engage. Teams should gather their own data. If a business can personalize a campaign based on unique data and psychological concepts while showing recipients a clear path, they’re more likely to succeed.


David Partain is SVP Head of Brand Activation and Administration at Northern Trust.