For decades, employers in many industries have required a four-year degree in most of their job descriptions. Worsening workforce shortages across the U.S. economy are prompting employers to drop requirements that candidates must hold a four-year degree, particularly for middle-skill positions. This opens up the recruitment pool, allowing employers to recruit for soft skills and “train up” for desired competencies.
Dropping degree requirements drastically expands the talent pool—only about a third of Americans have a four-year college degree—and has the potential to drive gains in productivity, retention, and fit. Now that there are lots of online training options, employers have more tools than ever before to train new hires on the specific knowledge and hard skills needed to thrive in their workplace.
Such a seismic shift, though, requires CEO support and deep organizational changes from job descriptions to compensation, and from recruiting practices to training. The following strategies can help lead a company away from so-called “degree inflation” while also forging a crucial competitive advantage amid ever-tighter labor markets.
DIAGNOSE MISAPPLIED DEGREE REQUIREMENTS
Challenge management teams to review each department’s job descriptions that require a four-year degree and identify where that degree could be substituted with a list of soft skills and core competencies combined with job-specific training.
Questions to ask:
• Which jobs require a degree?
• When did the company add a degree to the requirements for each of those roles?
• Why did the company add a degree requirement, and have technological advancements or industry developments nullified the initial reasoning behind the requirement?
EVALUATE THE NUMBERS
Many organizations neither track nor compare the costs of hiring for jobs requiring a degree relative to the costs of hiring for jobs not requiring a degree. But, they should; the process sheds light on the next steps needed and can earn broader buy-in for dropping degree requirements.
Ask team leaders across departments and HR leadership—who typically don’t use the same list of KPIs—to jointly discuss these considerations:
• What is the average time to fill a job that requires a degree compared to the time needed to fill a job that doesn’t?
• How do other workforce management indicators—such as turnover, productivity, performance ratings, time to promotion, and engagement—compare between workers with a college degree and workers without a degree?
The data is very likely to reveal that unnecessary degree requirements bear a higher-than-expected cost. The dialog between the people who hire and the people who manage will be crucial to identifying which roles should no longer carry mandates for a two- or four-year degree.
REDEFINE REQUIREMENTS
For every role whose job description includes a degree requirement, ask team leaders to spell out the skills that candidates actually need—the foundational competencies that new hires must possess. The goal is to identify hard skills specific to those positions that could be taught instead of expecting that they are already in place on the first day of work.
Those foundational competencies form the basis of revised job descriptions. Once in place, the door is opened to qualified applicants who previously could not meet the minimum degree requirement. Additionally, seeing those skills mandated in the new job descriptions sends important signals to external candidates, as well as to existing staff interested in career advancement. These existing staff are often in entry-level positions and at high risk to move on when instead it makes sense to invest in their growth and keep them on board.
INVEST IN INCUMBENTS
Essentially, this process is a recalibration of investments in talent. Putting more emphasis on building pathways for career advancement for existing workers—especially those in entry-level positions—is a wise investment.
Employers looking to fill positions that don’t actually require a degree should routinely survey their current staff—after all, their soft skills, competencies, attitudes, and drive are likely known and recorded in personnel files. Prioritizing incumbent workers for career advancement cuts hiring costs and brings greater returns for the costs associated with training programs.
WRAPPING UP
Relying more on key competencies needed for each job makes it easier to align new hires to the right internal and external training programs and the certifications needed for your workforce. This is a way to build a robust talent pipeline that also improves the diversity of candidates available to you. Furthermore, it has the potential to make a significant social impact, opening career pathways to workers who do not have college degrees but have terrific potential.
Craig Sprinkle is Chief Executive Officer at MedCerts, a national online training provider in Allied healthcare and IT.