Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Don’t buy more buckets, fix the leak: Changing the paradigm for DDOS

When it comes to ‘bad’ traffic related to things like DDoS attacks, we tend to wait until it arrives at its destination before ditching it—wasting capacity and energy along the way. Why is this and what can we do about it?

Fixing a pipe

[Images: Adobe Stock / kunakorn]

Profile photo of Darren Anstee

Chief Technology Officer for Security · NETSCOUT

If there’s a plumbing problem, the first thing we do is turn off the water. Then, we fix the leak. We don’t just let the water continue to pour out and buy bigger buckets to protect our possessions.

If we think about it though, this is similar to what we have been doing when it comes to mitigating distributed denial of service (DDoS) attacks sourced from consumer internet connections. We wait for the attack traffic to coalesce at a target—potentially having traveled across multiple ISPs, oceans, and continents—and then we throw it away. This is extremely expensive, in lots of ways.

Whether we are an internet service provider (ISP) or an enterprise, we deploy and scale our network infrastructure to deliver services to our users. The infrastructure within our networks is expensive to procure, as is the energy that infrastructure consumes. It’s estimated that the information and communication technology (ICT) sector is responsible for between 3% and 4% of global CO2 emissions, more even than the aviation sector. And, a report from Boston Consulting Group estimates that this could rise to 14% by 2040, given the inexorable growth of internet traffic.

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT: EUROPE’S TELECOM CLIMATE LEADERS

Given the paramount importance of reducing environmental impact, and the need to operate profitably, ISPs are looking at ways to reduce their infrastructure and energy costs. Some ISPs are looking to source their energy from renewable sources, with the top three companies on FT-Statista’s list of Europe’s Climate Leaders being from the telecom sector. In fact, the top three—Tele2, Telia, and Deutsche Telekom—all cut their greenhouse emissions from both their operations and energy purchases by over 90% between 2016 and 2021.

Reducing environmental impact in this way is great, but reducing wasted resources can also play a role. As I mentioned above, when it comes to the ‘bad’ traffic, related to things like DDoS attacks, we tend to wait until it arrives at its destination before ditching it—wasting capacity, and energy, along the way. So, why is this? Well, quite simply, the risk of this traffic causing problems near to its source has been low, and therefore there was no incentive to do anything about it.

EDGE CONNECTIVITY SPEED AND IOT DEVICES

Don’t get me wrong, some ISPs delivering subscriber services have experienced service slow-downs and even outages due to synchronous activity from a large number of compromised Internet of Things (IoT) devices, and those operators have generally taken a more proactive stance on subscriber threat management—but they have been in the minority. What we are hearing, from customers right across the world, is that ISPs’ views on this are changing. Some of our ISP customers are seeing much larger volumes of malicious traffic coming from their subscribers, with a more frequent impact on services and critical infrastructure. But, why?

Well, one factor is certainly the ever-growing population of IoT devices that can be exploited, but the big one is simply edge connectivity speed. As ISPs around the world deploy new technologies such as fiber-to-the-X (FTTX), data over cable service interface specification 4.0 (DOCSIS 4.0), and 5G fixed wireless access (FWA) at the edge of their networks, the upstream capacity available to each subscriber is increasing. This removes the throttle on the bad traffic that compromised devices or misbehaving users can generate, leading to much higher volumes of malicious traffic travelling through and across subscriber ISP networks. This traffic represents a much larger risk to service performance and availability and represents more of a cost in terms of capacity usage.

RETHINKING THREAT DETECTION AND MANAGEMENT

As you might expect, this is driving ISPs to re-think their threat detection and management strategies, with additional monitoring across their internal subscriber edge. We are seeing some operators focusing on being able to detect and mitigate traffic that will cause an immediate impact on their network and service infrastructure—a reactive stance. We are also seeing some operators focusing on identifying subscriber endpoints communicating with known botnet command-and-control infrastructure, so that they determine what level of risk they may face—a more proactive stance. Both are important and will only become more so as edge connectivity speeds and IoT populations—and risk—continue to grow.

More interesting though, is what the above means for how we think about threats like DDoS. As I mentioned at the start, we’ve always focused on defending targets—throwing away bad traffic as it reaches its destination—and this capability will always be needed. However, being able to suppress malicious traffic at source—turning off the water, in the terms of our analogy—is now becoming more common. Suppressing bad traffic at the subscriber aggregation layer can help ISPs to better protect the performance and availability of their services, protect their reputation (as they are not seen as generating lots of problems for others), and reduce the amount of bad traffic they push into the internet—reducing the capacity and energy that this consumes, and that we all pay for.


Darren Anstee is CTO for Security at NETSCOUT, which helps assure digital business services against disruptions.