Launching a new business venture starts with a euphoric realm of possibilities—envisioning soaring profits, satisfied customers, and industry recognition. Yet, behind this optimism lies a stark truth: Approximately 20% of small businesses fail within their first year, 30% by the end of their second year, 50% by the fifth year, and 70% by the tenth year.
Similarly, Harvard Business School’s Clayton Christensen uncovered that a staggering 95% of new product designs fail. After more than 35 years in the industry, it hasn’t been difficult to notice the parallels between designing a product and starting a business. Doing both simultaneously has an even higher risk. In fact, I believe that understanding the pitfalls in product development can also provide valuable insights into navigating early-stage development of a business operation. Let’s dive a bit deeper:
1. IN-DEPTH MARKET RESEARCH
After a new product idea is hatched, research starts before a detailed diagram can be drawn—improper product-market fit can doom a project from the start. Beyond intuition and a gut feel for the market, clear and quantifiable research of your target buyer and user, and the ability to demonstrate the need and desire for your product, is required. Quantifiable user value data is highly useful as you justify the forthcoming R&D expense.
The same applies to starting a business. Before going all in on an idea, comprehensive financial market research is indispensable. Relying solely on gut feelings won’t cut it in the business landscape. What’s needed is solid, quantifiable data gauging genuine demand and market size to validate assumptions and qualify the market need for your product or service.
Moreover, it’s crucial not to underestimate the impact of achieving good product-market fit, especially in the initial years when market fit uncertainties, your evolving consumer preference understanding, and revenue continuity and growth are so critical to survival.
2. RIGOROUS TESTING AND ADAPTATION
Much like in product design, user behavior with respect to the purchase matters immensely in business. It’s essential that your business operations team’s selection and service offerings function seamlessly from sales through to customer support in real-world scenarios. Just as a poorly designed product can deter potential customers, a business model that doesn’t cater to buyer needs will struggle to gain traction, making failure almost certain.
Poor experiences of any kind can turn a consumer off of a product (or even an entire brand) indefinitely and lead to damaging public customer reviews. For business creation and operational development, customer identification, satisfaction, and feedback are critical. Operational failure like inconsistent customer service or poor sales staff training, often leads to negative business outcomes, extending the vulnerable early stages of a business and often causing outright failure.
3. AVOID OVER COMPLEXITY, DILUTING THE SELF-EVIDENT VALUE
Oftentimes, a product designer will load a product with marginally useful extra features hoping to increase its appeal and target audiences. More often than not, this excess of features leads to buyer and end-user confusion, perceiving the product as not doing any single thing well. Consumers tend to want the new product to help them perform a task better rather than just provide a whole host of other useless or redundant features they may already have in other products they use.
In product design, the tendency to over-engineer aligns with attempting to do too much and thinking that it adds additional value, often resulting in confusion and reduced acceptance. Similarly, focusing on doing one thing exceptionally well rather than spreading finances, equipment, and staff across multiple objectives can lead to greater business stability and growth.
4. CONSIDERING COSTS AND SUPPLIER RELATIONS
In product development, one mistake I’ve witnessed consistently is the lack of attention given to production costs during the design stage, which ultimately affects the end-user price. The logic makes sense—a higher price should mean better quality and a more useful product—but consumers don’t always see it that way (without a groundbreaking new feature they cannot find elsewhere). And if they do, you are still limiting your potential customer base with a non-competitive price.
The same goes for business. Overlooking operations costs or failing to communicate effectively with partners and suppliers on objectives and expectations can prove detrimental. Cost-to-price strategy can limit your sales and customer base if done poorly. Establishing clear communication channels with suppliers or partners from the start reduces headaches down the line when a product is in manufacturing and is so much harder to change.
One way to reduce business and operations risk is to select experienced and trusted partners who know what they’re doing in product development, manufacturing, and in-market product operations. This limits the headaches and poorly spent dollars, giving the business a better shot at survival.
5. ADAPTING TO MARKET SHIFTS
Consider this: A product designer spends time and effort to produce an explicitly environmentally friendly product, but packages it in non-recyclable materials. This is a quick and surefire way to alienate the entire market at which the product is directed.
In the business realm, failing to anticipate and strategize to adapt to evolving consumer preferences or market trend shifts can also spell disaster. Understanding market demands and adjusting your business strategy or offerings accordingly is vital. For instance, continuing to offer outdated or unimportant services in a rapidly changing market focused on doing tasks faster and more effectively could frustrate users and alienate your target consumer.
The perils and pitfalls that a product designer must navigate are extensive and successful design teams leverage both data collection and experienced guides. This short list of examples and insights from product development mirrors the challenges of developing a new business operation and provides valuable insights through similar applications of strategies. And if you’re trying to avoid the fate of 95% of new products or 70% of new businesses, these thoughts may prove useful in identifying and navigating risks in your startup business operations decisions, increasing your chances of success in a competitive market.
Kevin Bailey is the founder of Design 1st and has 35 years experience developing new innovative devices to clients, across many markets.