Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

The modern publishing landscape for business executives

Book publishing has evolved dramatically, presenting authors, business professionals, and thought leaders with an array of choices.

Woman reading a book

[Images: Adobe Stock / igolaizola]

Profile photo of Miles Rote

Cofounder · Author.Inc

BY Miles Rote

Book publishing has evolved dramatically, presenting authors, business professionals, and thought leaders with an array of choices. It’s never been easier to publish a book and there are many options to choose from. 

At the heart of this evolution are three distinct ways of publishing: traditional, hybrid, and self-publishing. Each has its pros and cons, so understanding the nuances of each is vital. 

TRADITIONAL PUBLISHING: LEGACY CHOICE

When most people think of publishing, traditional publishing is the model that springs to mind. Often represented by the “Big-Five”—Penguin Random House, Simon & Schuster, Hachette, Macmillan, and HarperCollins—this approach also encompasses numerous reputable smaller publishing houses. 

Although the oldest and most authoritative, it’s also the most difficult to achieve: less than 1% of manuscripts are accepted. Prestige, professional support, and broad reach are traded for patience, perseverance, and a willingness to cede certain control. 

TRADITIONAL PUBLISHING PROS

• Advance payments: Authors receive an upfront payment instead of paying out of pocket for support. 

• Authority: Being accepted by a traditional publisher provides authority, lending a boost to an author’s credibility and widening their audience.

• Support: Authors receive professional editing, book cover and interior design, marketing strategy, and sometimes even PR campaigns.

• Distribution: Get your book into major retail chains, airports, and independent bookstores, and receive support with international rights, translating, and global distribution.

TRADITIONAL PUBLISHING CONS

• Highly competitive: Publishers receive thousands of manuscripts and accept a tiny fraction. A well-crafted proposal and agent representation increase your chances, but you’ll still need a large following.

• Loss of rights: Publishers often retain the rights to the book, which might limit how you can use and market your work in the future.

• Royalty rates: Once the advance is “earned out,” authors begin earning royalties, usually ranging from 7% to 15% for physical copies.

HYBRID PUBLISHING: MIDDLE GROUND

Hybrid publishing combines elements of both traditional and self-publishing. It’s an increasingly popular model, tailored for leaders seeking the expertise and infrastructure of traditional publishing while maintaining more control and receiving higher royalties.

Hybrid publishing can be seen as the “best of both worlds,” but it requires discernment. The model is dynamic, shifting in response to both the author’s and the market’s needs. It’s especially attractive to business leaders who have a clear vision for their book but appreciate the guidance and services that a publisher provides. This route can also appeal to those who might have self-published in the past but are looking for a more structured and supportive approach for their next project.

HYBRID PUBLISHING PROS

• Professional services: From editorial and design to marketing and distribution, this model allows authors to choose where they want professional input.

• Higher royalties: Because the author invests upfront, the subsequent royalties are generally higher, often hovering around 50%.

• Speedier time to market: Without the long and uncertain manuscript approval process of traditional houses, hybrid publishers can bring a book to market more swiftly.

• Retention of rights: Authors keep more of their rights, giving them additional flexibility with their content.

• Book authority: Although they may not provide as much clout as a traditional publisher, top hybrids have some well-known titles. 

HYBRID PUBLISHING CONS

• Upfront costs: This model often requires authors to cover initial publishing costs, meaning it’s essential to understand what you’re getting for your investment.

• Research required: The hybrid publishing space is vast, so it’s crucial to vet companies to ensure they’re reputable and a good fit for your goals.

• Balanced effort: While receiving more professional services than going solo, the marketing and promotion might still demand significant effort on the author’s part.

SELF-PUBLISHING: COMPLETE CONTROL

This is the modern frontier for business executives seeking total control over their book’s journey. As the entrepreneurial spirit in the literary world, self-publishing offers unparalleled control. There are services to assist—sometimes handling as much as a hybrid publisher—but there’s less professionalism, distribution, and marketing support. 

This model is perfect for executives who have a clear vision for their book, are ready to invest time and resources, and desire direct engagement with their audience. The rewards can be substantial both in terms of financial return and the satisfaction of having navigated the publishing journey on your own terms.

SELF-PUBLISHING PROS

• Creative freedom: Every decision about the content, design, and format is yours. If this feels more intimidating than exciting, you could always hire professionals for guidance in each of these areas. 

• Direct profit: Royalties are higher in self-publishing because they all go to you. Typically, for every book sold, you’ll keep seven times the royalties a traditionally published author would receive. 

• Speed to market: Once your manuscript is polished and ready, you can have it available for sale in a matter of days or weeks, depending on your chosen platform and format.

• Direct interaction: You can build your brand, cultivate your audience, and engage directly with your readers without interference. You also have total control over how you communicate with them.

• Monetization: Turn your book into a course, podcast, or sell merchandise. With full rights, authors can make money in ways others are restricted from. 

SELF-PUBLISHING CONS

• Responsibility: From editing to marketing, the entirety of the book’s success rests on your shoulders. 

• Investment: While there are cost-effective ways to self-publish, ensuring a professional final product might necessitate investments in editing, design, and marketing services.

• Navigation: Without the guidance of a publishing house, you’ll need to understand and leverage the dynamics of book sales platforms, distribution channels, and marketing strategies.

• Perception: There’s a lingering stigma around self-published books that they lack the quality of traditionally published books, but improved quality and countless successes are proving otherwise.

FINDING YOUR UNIQUE PATH 

Today, the power lies with the author instead of publishing houses. Traditional publishing might appeal to leaders with a large following who want to see their book on bookshelves. Hybrid offers the allure of professional guidance while ensuring more control. Self-publishing promises total autonomy, allowing for experimentation and direct connection with readers.

It’s never been easier to share your story. Which path will you take?


Miles Rote is the Chief of Author Strategy at the #1 NYT-Bestselling Ghostwriting firm, Kevin Anderson & Associates.