Nonprofit organizations play a crucial role in addressing social issues and creating positive change in the communities. However, a concerning trend has continued to grow unchecked within the sector, and it is one that I have sadly experienced personally for decades: an emphasis on the cause at the expense of internal culture.
I understand. While many nonprofits are solving societal ills and want their noble cause at the forefront—and it truly should be—it is essential to recognize that a healthy internal culture is the backbone of sustained success. High turnover, long hours, and low pay can no longer be the standard for public work. I’m tired of seeing nonprofits continually ignore their culture and drive their organizations into the ground, and I think it is time we do something about it.
1. THE MYTH OF SACRIFICING CULTURE FOR THE CAUSE
Nonprofit employees are often seen as individuals driven by a passion for the cause they serve. This perception has led to the dangerous assumption that these employees should be willing to make personal sacrifices, particularly in terms of time, compensation, and energy, because they are supposed to “care about the mission.”
While dedication to a cause is undoubtedly important, the belief that nonprofit workers should earn less and be more available as a reflection of their commitment can lead to a toxic work environment, and in turn, the insane turnover rates that plague the industry. Few employees stay at their nonprofit job for longer than 16 months. How can you gain your clients’ trust, develop relationships with stakeholders and clients, or even remember organizational history if your employees are different every single year?
2. THE IMPACT OF COMPENSATION ON EMPLOYEE MORALE
Another common issue in many nonprofits is the tendency to underpay employees compared to their counterparts in the for-profit sector. While it’s true that nonprofits may operate on tighter budgets, neglecting fair compensation can result in demotivated and burnt-out staff.
To address this, nonprofits should prioritize fair and competitive salaries to attract and retain skilled professionals. While subsidizing employees’ lives may seem like a well-intentioned effort to support those committed to a cause, it can inadvertently lead to burnout. Overreliance on subsidies can create a culture of dependency, preventing employees from advocating for fair compensation and fostering an unhealthy sense of guilt when considering personal needs.
3. FLEXIBLE WORK HOURS AND AUTONOMY
Flexible work hours and employee autonomy are critical elements of a healthy organizational culture. Nonprofits often face intense deadlines and unpredictable workloads, making it essential to allow employees flexibility in their schedules. Trusting employees to manage their time and providing autonomy in decision-making can not only improve morale but also enhance productivity and creativity.
As a working mom with two kids and one on the way, I simply can’t imagine working in a position that didn’t offer flexibility with the realization that even though my “office” hours may be different, I get everything done, and then some. I apply this principle to each of my employees. I don’t need people sitting at a desk for eight hours—I need them accomplishing our goals and doing the work, however that looks.
BUILDING A SUSTAINABLE NONPROFIT CULTURE
Okay, that all sounds nice, but how can we address these issues and build a sustainable culture in nonprofits? As a start, each nonprofit leader should address the following:
• Fair compensation: Prioritize fair and competitive salaries to attract and retain skilled professionals.
• Flexible work policies: Implement flexible work hours and remote work options to accommodate the unpredictable nature of nonprofit work.
• Empowerment and autonomy: Trust employees to make decisions and provide opportunities for professional growth and development.
• Open communication: Encourage open communication about organizational values, expectations, and challenges to foster a culture of transparency.
Nonprofits play a crucial role in creating positive social change, but their impact is hindered when internal culture is neglected. By prioritizing fair compensation, flexible work policies, and employee autonomy, nonprofits can build a strong foundation for sustained success.
It’s time to recognize that a healthy internal culture—and, heaven forbid, well-compensated and cared-for employees—is not a distraction from the cause but an essential component of achieving long-term goals and making a lasting impact on the world.
Ashley Sharp is the Executive Director of Dwell with Dignity.