Years ago, I was quarterbacking a new product launch for a major U.S. fast-moving consumer goods brand. As a senior marketing manager, I orchestrated multiple cross-functional teams in the run-up to the launch. We were about to launch a product that the analysts, investors, and entire company had eagerly anticipated.
Anyone who has ever worked in FMCG would tell you that a “launch” is aptly named. Everyone involved in a launch is running two-minute drills with no timeouts. Despite the best planning, keeping the seemingly precarious launch on track is always challenging.
There was palpable pressure on all of us. My then-manager pulled me aside one evening and uttered those dreaded four words: “Launch at all costs.” In hindsight, perhaps she believed she had reasons to give that directive. There was a precedence of delayed launches ending careers at this organization. Or maybe it was because her superior had also said these words to her, as did most of the division leadership to their teams. Yet, at that time, I had no idea that those four words would begin a reflective journey of priceless insights into leadership and corporate culture.
WORDS: THE HIGHER THEY COME FROM … THE HEAVIER THEY FALL
It has always fascinated me how a mere throwaway remark from someone in the C-suite can send the rank-and-file scurrying into action. Unless a deliberate culture of reasoning and questioning has been imbibed, this is the unfortunate reality of most corporations. The more senior the person, the quicker the reaction and the disproportionate response to their comments, ideas, feedback, and even off-the-cuff remarks. When my manager told us to launch at all costs, it gathered momentum as it percolated down the hierarchy. A snowball was set in motion.
Approvals fell through like dominos despite fundamental problems with the launch. We knew there were issues with nutrition claims, channel strategies, and pricing. The customer argument was flimsy at best, and our promotion plan had serious flaws. Yet, instead of the product’s viability, we were driven by the heroics of releasing on schedule.
How many red flags did you count? Still, back then, it appeared like nothing was going wrong. When every other person was greenlighting their section of the launch, flagging issues seemed off. Our goal morphed into launching on time instead of launching a viable new product consumers would love.
The product faltered in the markets less than six months after the launch. While the top brass was surprised, those on the ground knew this day was coming. The culture had muzzled the team’s discussions of the imminent and apparent problems.
CULTURE: SO OBVIOUS YET SO EXACTING
Coming out of this experience, I vividly remember thinking how ridiculously easy it would have been to avoid such a spectacular failure. Just empower people to speak up.
It took me over a decade to practice, learn, and distill that thought into lessons, frameworks, and interventions to build such a culture for my teams. And I can say now that it is anything but easy.
Building a culture that encourages radical candor at all levels requires constant work from the leadership. Bad news must travel faster upward. However, that goes against the human tendency to prefer positive reinforcement from sharing only the good news. Leadership goes beyond ensuring a zero-retribution policy toward whistleblowers. It requires a deliberate reversal of the path of least resistance.
What would I have done differently? I should have paused to flag the “launch at all costs” directive. I also should have built a credible relationship with a confidante on the leadership team that I could reach out to in such crucial moments of dissonance. The company could have saved a costly mistake if we had nurtured a culture driven by collective achievement versus one held back by fear.
ATL AND BTL OF LEADERSHIP
The “launch at all costs” approach ultimately led to a disastrous product launch. However, I am glad I went through this experience early on in my career, as it made me stop and think about my own leadership style and the kind of culture I want to build.
I did a simple yet powerful reflective exercise to define my North Star in leadership. I took a blank sheet of paper, drew a line across the middle, and listed the adjectives and behaviors I wanted to embody as a leader above the line. Similarly, below the line, I wrote the adjectives and behaviors I never wanted to be associated with as a leader.
This exercise crystallized the kind of leader I aspired to be and allowed me to identify actions and thought patterns that hindered my growth as a leader. And I didn’t stop there. I continued to reflect and adjust the phrases and adjectives in this above-the-line and below-the-line exercise as I went through various roles and experiences.
LEADERSHIP: THE REWARD IS WHO YOU AND YOUR ORGANIZATION BECOME
The most important lesson I learned from this event is the value of a purposeful corporate culture that drives desired behaviors in good and not-so-good times. The reward of the leadership process is genuinely what you become.
If you are in a leadership position, I encourage you to weigh your words and non-verbal cues twice. The higher you are in terms of designation, the heavier your words fall on your team. Leadership is indeed a lifelong process. It doesn’t stop when you have achieved a particular title. Instead, the practice of leadership is constantly evolving and being tested in new environments, with different teams facing harder and more complex challenges.
Organizations thrive when leaders continuously nurture a culture where individuals can express concerns, communicate freely about difficulties, and flag foreseen issues. Creating a healthy culture that invites radical candor, diversity of thought, and rich debates while respecting others is critical to an organization’s long-term success and is the breeding ground for second- and third-generation leadership to root.
Yumi Clevenger-Lee is the Global Chief Marketing Officer for Quest Global, an end-to-end product engineering services company.