Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

To pay or not to pay the ransom?

The pros and cons of paying ransom, coupled with a comprehensive survival guide to dealing with a ransomware attack.

[Images: Adobe Stock / Andrey Popov]

Profile photo of Elisha Riedlinger

Chief Operator Officer · NeuShield

William Shakespeare once pondered, “To be, or not to be? That is the question.” But in 2024, we can ask ourselves, “To pay, or not to pay?” given the escalating incidents of ransomware.

In this article, I review the pros and cons of paying ransom, coupled with a comprehensive survival guide to help answer the question. Hopefully, this guide will better prepare you for the latter part of the updated query if you find yourself contemplating payment.

PROS OF PAYING RANSOM IN A RANSOMWARE ATTACK

Let’s first examine the conditions under which you might consider paying ransom in the event of a ransomware attack.

  • If backups have become damaged in an attack, paying to unlock your data might be a necessity.
  • Lack of backups or incomplete backups, especially with limited capacity (e.g., Shadow Copy), could force you to pay.
  • In scenarios where data is air-gapped, offsite, or lacking sufficient bandwidth resulting in extremely slow recovery times, payment might become a necessity.
  • Industries in which uptime is critical (e.g., health, manufacturing) may find paying ransom to expedite recovery advantageous.

If you don’t have the ability to recover all necessary data from a backup, or in cases where the recovery time is exceedingly slow, the pros of paying may outweigh the cons.

CONS OF PAYING RANSOM IN A RANSOMWARE ATTACK

There exist numerous drawbacks, or cons, associated with paying ransom. Here are a few:

  • Paying contributes to funding ransomware gangs and perpetuating their malicious campaigns. 
  • Increased vulnerability to repeated ransomware threats, potentially facing double or triple extortion attempts (Yup, this is a thing!). 
  • Unlocking data does not address the root cause and can leave you susceptible to future attacks.
  • Decryption can be a very slow process.

SURVIVAL GUIDE: HOW TO AVOID PAYING RANSOM

In college, I learned that with proper preparation, virtually anything can be handled. However, this philosophical belief often falls short in everyday practices. Nevertheless, here are some key considerations to assess in your efforts to be prepared. Let’s call this the “blackout” preparation guide:

  • Evaluate the current time, bandwidth, and resources required for recovery, and whether or not they are in alignment with your overall business continuity strategy.
  • Classify data to prioritize and streamline the recovery process from most critical to least critical.
  • Assess whether recovery of the operating system is as critical as the data itself in case of an OS attack.
  • Ensure tools can recover all protected data, and even the whole operating system, within desired timeframe.
  • Store recovery data locally on each device to allow for extremely quick recovery times, and to eliminate the need to retrieve data from the network.
  • Harden recovery data or store it as read-only to ensure you always have access and to prevent attackers from damaging it.
  • Prepare for simultaneous recovery of multiple machines, including the reimaging of all machines that could be affected.
  • Balance detection and recovery tools, as an overreliance on detection, may leave gaps in preparedness.
  • Ensure detection measures don’t just cover malware variants (we’re seeing more and more malware-less attacks). Rather, make sure your solution has detection towards the integrity of the data itself.

Conduct a thorough assessment of your tools, recovery plans, and overall preparedness to determine if you can “just say no” to a ransomware event. I hope this article has helped give you some points to ponder in your preparedness strategy!  (Don’t forget the bread, milk, and D batteries!)


Elisha Riedlinger is the Chief Operating Officer at NeuShield.