Are machines creative enough to mostly, if not completely, replace humankind? This question, which plumbs the depths of science, psychology, and philosophy, underlies some of the biggest debates about the future of humanity’s use of artificial intelligence (AI). What people really want to know is whether AI can fully replicate human intelligence, but to answer that question, we need to dispense with linear thinking—not just once, but over and again as machine learning stretches the boundaries of what we thought possible.
Think of human creativity as a large circle and AI capabilities as a smaller sub-circle that begins as a single point poking a hole in the bigger circle. As AI takes on more problem-solving abilities, its circle will expand and, therefore, shrink the area left for human creativity.
This is what “redefine” means. Note that because the boundary of the large circle is also ever-expanding, it is the area that is shrinking—not necessarily human intelligence.
Here’s one illustration of how the evolution of AI is redefining human intelligence or creativity: Instead of representing the entire large circle, AI is now occupying the space between the two spheres. Whether the smaller circle will expand beyond the larger circle is a separate question, but I believe it will not eclipse it completely.
Rather than relegating human intelligence, the growth of AI will leave aside higher-order social, economic, and business problems for our finest minds to tackle. This is the message business leaders can give people concerned about their jobs and our collective future.
THE NEW ROLE OF HUMAN CREATIVITY
We should be wary of creating an adversarial relationship with AI, even while acknowledging people’s concerns are valid. Recent MIT research suggests the near-term displacement of jobs by automation will not be as significant as presumed—or feared. Using a model that quantifies tasks that are both technically feasible and economically attractive to automate, the research found that only 23% of tasks or roles would be replaced by AI today. The caveat is that the rate of displacement could change if costs fall rapidly, or if there is widespread adoption of AI-as-a-service platforms.
While the gradual rollout of automation is mitigating labor disruption, it is also giving us time to adapt to the way AI is eliminating the need to reinvent the wheel in human endeavors. It’s important to remember that many of these are repetitive and labor-intensive tasks based on a model of maintenance over value.
This perspective may calm some of the existentialist fears around AI because machine learning is redefining the boundaries of our creativity, not making human intelligence redundant. With collective human knowledge now more accessible through AI, we can spend less time tending to business-as-usual and more time reimagining our companies and our world.
COLLECTIVIZING HUMAN KNOWLEDGE
AI is putting collective human knowledge at an individual’s disposal. In this emerging paradigm, the traditional labor-intensive methods of learning will become obsolete as new models allow people to enter the knowledge playing field at a much higher baseline. The fundamentals of logic and reason still form a foundation for critical thinking, but this evolution will allow businesses to innovate faster and test concepts in real time.
Despite this growth, we still need an understanding of what AI can and cannot do. The most advanced AI systems today are limited by their reliance on natural language processing, whereas human intelligence transcends written or spoken language. There are still domains of human creativity, problem-solving, and emotional/intuitive perception that cannot be easily understood or replicated through language-based AI.
All to say, human creativity will still be required for most things—and that’s a lesson extracted from history. From agrarian to industrial society and then the information age, machines have never replaced the human spirit of invention, but allowed us more time and resources to enhance it.
The rise of AI will create new types of jobs requiring continuous learning and upskilling, even as some of the old ones are eliminated.
THE AI-HUMAN PARTNERSHIP
We have already seen how AI automating creative processes has revolutionized website and graphic design. It builds a memory of all the common functions, color palettes, and layouts already used successfully by designers to remove the stress of starting from scratch. This allows designers to focus their creative skills on original elements that will make a website unique.
Moving from creativity to complex pattern detection, the potential to leverage the vast training data of machine learning—previously the domain of human specialization—only grows. In medicine, for instance, automated diagnosis could compare symptoms to an ever-expanding library of past cases.
While a study of over 2,000 chest X-rays last year revealed AI’s limitations in analyzing complex cases, a separate study found autonomous AI showed almost 27% higher sensitivity than radiology reports for abnormal chest X-rays. Contrasting results like these are partly why a hybrid technology-human system has been proposed to reduce radiologist burnout and enhance patient care.
The key takeaway for businesses is to make sure we have a complementary relationship with AI and use upskilling and reskilling to optimize its capacities. The AI sub-circle will only grow, and when we speak of replacement in the above case, it will more likely involve radiologists who use AI replacing those who don’t. This is just one example of adapting to what AI has to offer instead of seeing it as a zero-sum game.
THE PARADOX OF LESS IS MORE
As humans, we are hard-wired for survival, and higher-cortical problem-solving can only fully come online when we feel secure. That’s partly why it is so important to talk about the biggest concerns out there about AI—firstly, that it is coming for people’s jobs, and secondly, that AI is going to take over society.
Collectively, we need to take the long view. By allowing us to do more with less, AI not only promises to free up human intelligence to take on intractable problems but also be an indispensable ally in changing the world for the good.
Simin Cai is the President & CEO of GoFoton!